Hey, Dan: Life is not horrible. I am an American college student. Compared to most places in the world, I’m pretty well off. Oh, and I go to college in Bellingham—the weed is awesome, the weather is great, and there are lots of hot guys. Score! But! I’m a homo. And I didn’t know how horrible my life was before I got here….

It seems like every gay or queer event/person who is involved in anything gay/queer on campus has this idea that gay people are SO oppressed that we need to constantly discuss it and feel like victims. Don’t get me wrong: we are a ways away from equality, and I recognize this. But it seems that the constant thread on college campuses for queers—other than talking about Lady Gaga or sucking dick—is complaining about, putting on events about, or creating overly-inclusive language about how oppressed queer people are.

How do I respectfully say, “STFU, we’re doing just fine, you white, upper-class American kids” without sounding like an insensitive assdouche?

M.G.

My response after the jump…

···················

You know… when I came out to my parents in 1981ishwhateversomething, telling mom and dad that I was gay didn’t just mean telling them I liked to kissandotherstuff boys. It meant telling them that I would never marry, never have children, and never be a Marine. Or at least that’s what I thought I was telling them. Because here we are, three short decades later, and I’m married. And I have a child. And now I can be a Marine. (Not that I want to be a Marine—well, not anymore. After seeing this pic in today’s NYT I wanna be a Navy Seal.)

And I live in Seattle, where the weed is awesome (I’m told), the weather is great (if you like to snowboard), and the boy I marriedandkissandotherstuff is a lotta hot guy all by himself.

So I agree with you, M.G. Things are good. Things have gotten better—and not just for me.

But we have work left to do. We have our full civil equality yet to secure, for starters, homo- and transphobic violence to confront, bigoted lawmakers to defeat. But the discrimination and challenges we face shouldn’t prevent us from appreciating the good things. Yes, it has gotten better. That doesn’t mean we can ignore the bashings and outrages and tragedies. But we shouldn’t be so in love with our victimization—or so insecure about the progress we’ve made so far—that we can’t acknowledge the triumphs and joys and Navy Seals.

So I’m with you, M.G.—up to a point.

I disagree about the STFU part. You don’t have to hang out with the kind of LGBT activists who aren’t capable of fighting for our full civil equality—theirs, mine, and yours—while also enjoying all the good things life has to offer. But not all LGBT activists are humorless scolds. Some are, for sure (and they tend to be overrepresented on college campuses), but there are plenty of people out there who can organize a protest one night and a party with good weed and cute boys the next.

And guys like you and me, M.G., the gay guys who have it good, we have to remember that there are LGBT folks out there who have it lousy and not all of them are in a position to speak up for themselves. Let me see if I can think of an example… okay, got one: There are bullied and isolated and abused LGBT kids out there who don’t live in places like Bellingham or Seattle, who don’t have the love and support of their parents, and who aren’t “doing fine.” If we don’t speak up for those isolated LGBT kids, if we don’t do something, who will? (And for the record: there are lots and lots and lots of loved and accepted LGBT kids out there too—not all LGBT kids are miserable—who are doing fine and fighting for their own rights and the rights of other LGBT kids.)

We don’t have to mope around in sackcloth and ashes because some folks out there are miserable. We don’t have to pretend that we feel oppressed 24/7 when we clearly aren’t. And we don’t have to attend pointless queer events that are run/overrun by LGBT whiners who mistake wallowing in self-pity for activism and imagined slights for outrages. And once you get out of college, M.G., you’ll find that most of us aren’t moping, pretending, or attending. Most of us are getting on with our lives.

But, again, not all LGBT people are doing fine, M.G., just as not all LGBT people are white or upper-class or in college or lucky enough to live in a Bellingham or a Seattle. And if you’re in a position to do something, M.G., you should. It doesn’t have to take over your life and you don’t have to pretend to be any more oppressed than you actually are. But you should do something. Because the only thing more annoying than a whiny, college-age queer with a persecution complex is a smug, college-age queer who takes his good fortune for granted and could give a shit about other people because, hey, he’s got his (his weed, his boys, his education).

I’m not saying you’re that guy, M.G. In fact, I know you’re not. But be careful you don’t become that guy.

48 replies on “SL Letter of the Day: It Is Better”

  1. Well said sir. (I’m sure there is a typo or homophone in there that I should scold you over but I’ll take the high road).

    This isn’t just an LGBT issue either. In society it is fine line between earnest and joykill. We all should learn to walk it.

  2. Anybody who is at least concerned about “sounding like an insensitive assdouche” is 50 notches up on my internal checklist, and of course that puts them well above the waterline of most Republicans and Slog trolls.

  3. Nicely put, Dan. MG, maybe you could organize a group of your friends to go volunteer at a youth crisis center or hotline, so they can lavish their angst on kids who don’t have it as good as you all seem to.

  4. Yeah, I don’t think being a touch over-zealous when there are still people being denied rights, beaten up & hurting themselves for being different, is a bad thing. Definitely, balance the fun-having with the good-doing, but don’t forget the latter in pursuit of the former. It’s a big world, you can do both.

  5. M.G., perhaps you need to be reminded that one of the many reasons things are good for you is in large part because of all of those who came before you and helped make it that way. Things were very different 10, 20, 30 years ago.

  6. So I was distracted by the amazing physique in the SEAL photo and read:
    “A Seal member preparing to top insurgents in 2007.” Wow, not a bad way to go…

  7. Research bears out MG’s observation:

    Gay and lesbian youth and suicide-
    An article in the December issue of APA’s Journal of Consulting and Clinical Psychology points to a possible cause of seemingly higher rates of suicide among LGB and transgendered (LGBT) youth: discrepancies between what gay youth report about suicide attempts and what they’re actually doing.
    The article, by Cornell University’s Ritch C. Savin-Williams, PhD, reports on two studies that conclude that even though sexual-minority teens are more likely than heterosexual youth to report suicide attempts, half of those reports are false–that is, the young people had thought about suicide but hadn’t acted on it. In addition, Savin-Williams found, many of the true attempts the young people reported weren’t life-threatening.
    “When you ask in-depth questions about suicide attempts, the responses you get account for the rate differences between heterosexual and sexual minority youth suicide,” Savin-Williams says. “The heterosexual youth had hardly any false attempts, while those with same-sex attractions had a lot of them.”
    In one of the studies, 23 percent of 83 young sexual-minority women said they’d attempted suicide at least once. On further questioning, though, 29 percent of the reported attempts turned out to be false, and 80 percent of the true attempts were not life-threatening, Savin-Williams writes. The one exception was a small number of young women who were part of a support group, whose rate of actual suicide attempts was much higher than others in the sample.
    In the other study, Savin-Williams compared reported suicide attempts in 126 young sexual-minority young people and 140 young heterosexual men and women. Again, while sexual-minority men and women were far more likely to report suicide attempts than heterosexual subjects, the two groups showed similar rates of true suicide attempts.
    The findings suggest that gay youth are vulnerable to the media’s and researchers’ well-meaning but negative depictions of gay youth as highly troubled people heading on a collision course with life, Savin-Williams maintains.
    “There’s a script we have in our culture–a ‘suffering suicidal’ script–that these kids have picked up on,” he says. A better approach for researchers, teachers and other youth workers, he believes, is to treat all young LGBT people as ordinary kids with great potential, unless they show research-based or visible indicators of suicide risk.

    Activists like Dan (who have a vested interest in the perception of gay oppression) present a distorted picture of reality. Gay kids who buy Dan’s narrative are actually way more likely to be depressed and feel despair.

  8. When I came out and was in college, I swear there was at least one year where I managed to work in gay rights or gay oppression or something similar into every paper I wrote, whether the class was History of sexuality, Nursing ethics or algebra;

    when people first come out and esp when they are in college and basically having their consciousness raised (pardon the ancient reference) for the first time, we tend to be a little one note-ish about it. Its all gay, all gay oppression, all queerqueerqueer all the time. We can work it into any conversation.

    We grow out of it.

    The letter writer should have some fun, go to class and get their degree, be political on occasion and act on your beliefs and make friends; that is what college is for.

  9. Excellent post, Dan. Every word.

    I would only add that there is a certain inertia and tradition in queer groups too. 20-30 years ago, gay college groups acted like victims most of the time because they were. So gay student groups were formed to create a safe place for students. In some fortunate places, like WWU, gay students may not be victims much any more, and that safe space may not be needed as much. But the inertia of the group remains, and model in which it was formed not yet abandoned. And college age queers can feel self-rightious if their group feels like they serve as a function of social good, rather than merely a pickup spot for gays.

    So if you don’t like the format of your college queer group… change it.

  10. “But we have work left to do…. homo- and transphobic violence to confront,… bashings and outrages and tragedies….”

    Dan, perhaps you have tunnel vision that keeps you from putting things in perspective.

    How many homosexuals were killed in this country last year by homophobic violence?
    One is too many, but what was the number?

    Compare that to how many TENS OF THOUSANDS of homosexuals were killed by AIDS some other homosexual gave them.

    Sure, you find it satisfying to rail against Christian Bigots- it really pumps up one’s sense of moral superiority, doesn’t it- but if one looks at what would actually benefit America’s homosexual community it is obvious that the sound and fury is misdirected and very inefficient if the goal is to improve the lives of homosexuals.

    Sure, there may not be as much Fame and Adoration in advocating responsible behavior but how many thousands of dead homosexuals is that attention worth to you?

  11. Did you notice, Danny, the OUTRAGE you linked was about three suicides in one year in one Minnesota school district?

    That is actually pretty common; teen suicide clusters: one kid commits suicide and it gets a ton of attention and then other kids decide to cash in as well.

    By focusing so much attention on suicides and making (literally) national cases out of local tragedies many other kids get the same idea. By nationalizing the phenomena there is the potential to create a huge homosuicide cluster.

    Of course, the more teen suicides Queer,Inc. can claim the better for business, right?

  12. When one spends all of their time navel gazing at their own perceived oppressions it is easy to get sucked up in morose self pity.
    Taking a look around and helping someone else often reminds the navel gazer that they don’t have it so bad after all.

    The same can be true of demographic groups.

    Perhaps if Queer,Inc did just a teeny tiny something for an oppressed group that doesn’t happen to be homosexual it might improve everyones frame of mind.

    Perhaps exploited underage polygamy victims?….

  13. Verite, are you a sock puppet of the recently departed Period Troll? Your word choices tend to lead me to that conclusion.

  14. Dan, If you’re thirty-four, and you came out to your parents in 1981, that would mean that you were…four(?)

  15. I’m a recent WWU grad, and my BF is a current student… All I can say is if you don’t like the focus of events, get invoked and change it. Campus organizations change year to year, and the programing varies widely – lame events from do-nothing resume padders, lame ones from the more-aware-than-thou kids with no sense of humor, and great events from committed, intelligent students. Be the latter. And be very, very thankful you chose Western over Evergreen.

  16. Dan, thanks very much – while I was still reading MG’s letter, I almost got to yelling at the monitor “you live in WA, you close-minded prick, of course you have freedom”. Even in Washington, there’s marriage rights to talk about. But you don’t have to go much less liberal to find it still being hard for us LGBT folk. I can’t walk into my student union bar dressed somewhat femme without having insults hurled at me all night, and this in a liberal city in the 21st century.

  17. Verite, your non-verbal communication (four long posts in less than 30 minutes) tells me you’re not very secure, emotionally speaking, and you have difficulty with the concept of perspective.

    Result: your opinions can be proportionally discounted.

  18. That’s so awesome that you’re having a great time, MG.

    Meanwhile, I made the mistake of coming out to a person at work about 12 months ago. I was confronted during lunch. A shouting match ensured. Little jolly ranchers were thrown at my head as I tried to leave. They were screaming awful things at me about hell and disgust and within 24 hours I was fired. Excuse me, I was told my services would no longer be needed.

    And so, even though there is a lot going on my life, a lot of good, good shit, the good can lure you into a sense of complacency, a sense that you might go ahead and come out to a coworker during chit chat (after all, she spoke graphically about her sex life, why shouldn’t I?) even though there are no laws protecting you in the state you live and work and you can get fired for being honest about yourself.

    Have fun. I kinda hate you for having it so good right now.

  19. 24

    thank you for the analysis, shit4brains.

    perhaps you could proportionally shove them up your ass.

    (…and then you’d have more insight in your colon than in your cranium!)

  20. @25: Do you live in Washington state? If so, and you were discharged because of your sexual orientation, your former employer may have violated the law. Check the website for the Washington State Human Rights Commission, http://www.hum.wa.gov
    You may be too late to have them act on a complaint, since they are supposed to receive it within 6 months, but it might be worth notifying the commission about what happened in case the employer does it to someone else in the future.

  21. One minor quibble only: Is providing an illegal substance at parties a prerequisite for not being a humourless prig? I never got that memo.

    Interesting that MG doesn’t care whether or not he is an insensitive A.D., just whether he soundslike one. One might guess that he doesn’t want to scare off any white, upper-class American boys who might just happen to be cute enough for dalliance, but I’m not in that uncharitable a mood. (Love Triangle has been on the air only a few weeks and already has presented a same-sex triangle.)

    MG makes me think of the film Metropolitan. The earnest Tom, who disapproves of deb parties, attends one to see what it’s like if he’s going to disapprove of it, and happens to get drawn into a group of people he likes, still has an uneasy conscience about attending deb parties when the world is full of less fortunate people. Nick counters that, to some people, Tom is the less fortunate. He acts out a parody that since Tom doesn’t have a decent winter coat, I can’t go to any more parties.

    If I were feeling slightly more sentimental, I’d ask MG to go drop a few quarters in a children’s playground in memory of MKW. He lived in Bellingham and used to like to do that on a regular basis. Oh, dear, I’d better post this before I get into too much of a mood to be able to sleep.

  22. It’s a pretty big problem for college age queer folk. You want to hang around with other gay/queer people, but the GLBTQ clubs are full of dramatic GLEE loving attention whores who break out into song and dance routines or super angry bitter activists who make everything about oppression. The other place to meet gay guys is the gay clubs, but my friends hate gay bars for the reason I hate straight bars; I don’t appreciate being slavered over or randomly groped by men I find old and nasty. Six of my closest guy friends are gay guys who proclaim to ‘love gay people but hate gay culture’ for these reasons. They feel like they’re just regular guys who like other men, not prancing, lisping, fabulous interior designers and feel rejected by the community because of this disconnect. It’s hard for them to socialize, and it’s a legitimate problem.

  23. @32 I know your question was tongue in cheek, but I was curious enough to research it.

    Women can’t serve in “combat roles,” particularly not special forces. Part of it is that women simply cannot biologically hope to aspire to the same heights of physical fitness as men; they have periods, which makes hygiene an issue; they don’t want to have to worry about separating makeshift tents and potties by gender; and lastly, because of the chauvinistic (but possibly true, I don’t know any soldiers) belief that if women are around, they will provide a distraction and, by virtue of having breasts & vaginas, drive the men around them to foolish means of saving them if they get in a tight spot.

    Anyway, it’s not going to happen anytime soon. I’m not too fussed about it myself. We’ve got the google to sate our vicarious seal-lust, neh?

  24. Hey MG, the fact that you’re drawing such generalizations from your obvious place of privilege, and then writing to Dan to get him to validate your whining, makes you about as immature as the whiny, navel-gazing campus activists/victim complexes you’re complaining about. I went to Berkeley, so I know the type well, but queers in this country have not collectively reached a point yet where your ridiculing them doesn’t come off as spoiled and self-absorbed.

    Congratulations on the luxury of living in a safe place and having a good family–really. But don’t project your (still uniquely positive) experience onto others who are in much less fortunate circumstances and deal with real threats of harm and violence all the time. And don’t underestimate how much misogyny and homophobia there is among your peers, either. They might keep quiet while they’re on an ultra-liberal college campus, but it’s still lurking.

  25. Bellingham is a magical place.
    The weed is good, the boys are hot, and the gays are – very visible.

    MG – I don’t blame you. When I went to WWU I wanted to be a part of a LGBT group but was totally brushed/turned off by the “loud and prouds”. There is gay-on-gay discrimination and bullying. It’s real – and the fact that it currently exists is a growing pain in the fight for equal status.

    So MG – you are safe. Bellingham is safe. You are comfortable and don’t need the LGBT Club to look out for you……but 20 miles away in Lynden there are guys and girls who are not. Ferndale, Mt. Baker, Blaine, Burlington, etc…….there are kids out there who are suicidal and need to know there are people out there and nearby who are happy and living a proud life. You don’t have to join in the pride parade, but don’t work against them.

  26. @MG you have it good enjoy it, the real life outside college can be “slightly” different.
    You are fortunate to be Gay in a liberal state/college university ask how gays are feeling/living in colleges in Egypt, Lebanon , Iran, Iraq, etc….

  27. Join FetLife, join WHACK, come to a munch, meet up with some non-douche-y people. ;3

    Bellingham is great for the kinky kinksters whether they be gay, straight, bi, curious, whatever.

    Much love, bby. <3

  28. I had a comment to make about MG and the activists, but sadly I can’t remember what it was, because I just clicked on Dan’s Navy Seal link and I think that pic just turned me straight. Holy shit.

  29. M.G. reminds me of a friend of mine, who I know from the wonderfully comfortable and insular Lesbian village in my wonderfully diverse home city I inhabited before I moved to a smaller town.

    None of the girls were politicised or being victims. And it was just this blissfull universe where it was easy to believe that Lesbians were the only people in the world.

    No need to fight when your world is perfect, right? I can see why it must be annoying to see people talk about oppression and LGBT rights when you’re high on the good life, but if the “high on the good life” people are intolerant of people who aren’t there yet, then the people who are still contending with the politics and the struggle will be less likely to jump up on that cloud because their role models will be pushing them away.

    So my point is, “high on the good life” queers should try to be tolerant of these people, because they are important role models, and they represent the place that these “victims” will eventually aspire to reach.

  30. @17: Careful, careful! Remember, too much spam made you sick to your tummy last time and you got sent to your room.

  31. About 4 or 5 years ago, I had to do a college project about a social issue and I chose gay marriage. I had avoided going to the local GLBT group until then (which involves a hilarious misunderstanding with the Hmong club that shares the same room). When I told them my project they were all for it until it came time to actually start working on it and then they were nowhere to be found – except drag shows, etc.

    It kind of pissed me off that not only did I get screwed over for my project, but they were extremely ambivalent about doing something other than writing chalk messages on the sidewalk.

  32. I kinda agree with this, mostly because I’m also really tired of hearing about Lady Gaga all the time I hang out with other LGBT students… :p

  33. Well said, Dan. I might add that MG’s sense of where thing stand for us might change a little more as he gets older, and his life starts to intersect with government policy a bit more. If you’re in a college environment, surrounded by your fellow liberal 20somethings, and all you’re looking for is hot guys, then it can seem like there isn’t a problem. Wait ’till you’re a little older, and want to get married or adopt kids — that’s when the phrase, “we are a ways away from equality” seems like a drastic understatement. I’m a “white, upper-class American”, and in a lot of important ways, thanks to our government, I’m not “doing just fine”.

    For instance: In my state, I can’t marry my partner (which has real, practical, non-symbolic consequences — if I die, my partner may not be able to inherit our shared property, and even with an employer who offers same-sex-partner health insurance, getting my partner covered was both more difficult and costlier than it would’ve been if we were straight) and we’re finding our adoption process a whole lot more difficult than our straight friends’, thanks to the fact that a lot of countries, states, and agencies are off-limits to us. And in a lot of ways, we’re the best-case scenario — we live in a liberal city, and I work in a liberal workplace, and at least the state where we live hasn’t placed an outright ban on adoption. But MG might want to enjoy his sense that “we’re doing just fine” while it lasts. (That’s not to say that MG’s classmates might not have chosen the wrong battles to fight. But that doesn’t mean that the battles don’t exist.)

  34. Instead of saying STFU, I think MG should just stick to his first few sentences as an elevator pitch for his views, then live and let live. College has a way of turning every political question into a fierce debate that must end with someone being clearly right, in part because college students are there to think about things deeply and seek the right answer (that’s what college is for) but also because college shields you from the reality that good intelligent people aren’t all going to end up with the same political priorities.

    College creates the illusion that consensus is within reach, leaving kids arguing over the minutiae of exactly how outraged we should be on any given issue, with little need to agree to disagree. But when you grow up, you’re gonna end up with friends and loved ones who are passionate activists for causes you think are stupid, and you’re gonna end up with friends and loved ones who think your passionate causes are stupid, and coming to some kind of agreement becomes a lot less important once you’re in the world of work and family.

    It wasn’t until after college that I started hitting those walls where political disagreements actually soured friendships, where I started to learn the old Midwestern trick of biting my tongue and disagreeing silently to keep the peace. But I discovered that’s actually one of the better ways of convincing people, whereas confrontational debate is more polarizing than convincing. Ultimately the most thought-provoking thing to an entrenched ideologue is a respectable peer that disagrees but won’t argue about it; that’s what prompts them to reflect on what they might be wrong about and what they’re missing, instead of wallowing in the self-righteousness of having a retort for every retort.

    So, you want your college friends to play the victimization card less? The best way to do this is simply to not play it yourself, not let them drag you into playing it, and set your own example of what a well-off well-adjusted homo looks like. Let your actions and your attitude be what makes your case; you don’t have to lay it out explicitly. Otherwise, there’s no polite way to say STFU, and saying it isn’t as likely to get the job done, anyway.

    Oh, and as others pointed out, keep in mind that there’s plenty of folks who still really are victims. Don’t let your irritation at college victimization complexes blind you to that reality. I don’t think it’s quite a moral imperative to fight and worry until all discrimination has ended–I do think part of enjoying real pockets of equality is being able to sometimes say, “I got mine, and that’s all I’m worried about for now.” But where you’ve got the energy for a political battle, better to use that energy to protect the people who really are victims. Don’t waste it on telling folks who aren’t victims that they’re not; they can mostly just be ignored. And once you leave college, it’ll get better. 😉

  35. @34 Sorry, but I can’t agree with you on that. Everyone says ‘women can’t physically X’ until they let women actually try X. I don’t think there’s been a physical skill/level of athleticism that women couldn’t master. Add in to that that women are discouraged from athletic excellence, and cultural BS about how a lady should act and what she should look like, how can we know the true potential of women’s physicality yet?

    And about menstruation, it really isn’t that big of a deal, and not a hygiene issue at all. Most women at that level of physical fitness lose their periods because their body fat percentage is too low. And if they don’t, menstrual sponges or menstrual cups only need clean/boiled water to work without any problem at all.

    We have women in combat roles in Canada. No problems here.

Comments are closed.