Almost a year ago, I wrote about staffing shortages and recruiting problems at SPD. Since my piece came out, the police guild has signed a hefty contract with the city, which helped department pull in 100 new officers. But was all that extra money worth it?
Well, last week the Seattle Police Department released its mid-year crime stats and it appears that, with one big exception, all of those extra cops might’ve paid off as (reported) crime is down 11% across the city:

As you can see, while property crimes and assaults are down, rapes are up a whopping 41%. Additionally, the stats don’t include data for the late-summer months, which is when this whole apparent spike in gang-related violence picked up.
Tomorrow, the SPD and the King County Sheriff’s office is holding a press conference tomorrow to talk about their new regional “gang crime information sharing project.” Given the supposed growing epidemic of gang violence, the timing of the release of SPD’s stat report is a bit suspicious. Obviously violence has increased enough to warrant a taskforce, so what’re the odds this supposed 11% drop in crime holds through the end of the year?

Wow, vehicle theft really plummeted!
wtf? rapes are up 41 percent and you are reporting that the SPD and sheriff’s office are holding a press conference tomorrow about gang violence? property crimes and assaults are down? reported rapes are up 41 percent? am I repeating myself?!
WTF?! What the FUCK!
Rapes are down from two years ago, as is every other category shown. Two-year figures are a lot more important than one-year. One-year numbers undoubtedly contain a lot of random noise.
I’m guessing that single perpetrators account for vastly more vehicle thefts than rapes, which are almost always non-repeating one-offs, so arresting a couple of high-profile car thieves can really knock off those theft numbers, while arresting a rapist doesn’t reduce the rape rate at all.
This has more to do with not wasting scarce tax dollars on MJ and spending more on arresting, jailing, trying, and sending away rapists.
Plus, the major reason why vehicle theft dropped is they stopped investigating it under a higher dollar amount, so all the poor people driving used cars don’t get five cop cars showing up an hour after they phone in that their car got stolen.
Will are you saying that they don’t take car theft reports under $10,000? You are an idiot. The fact that they are now not investigating theft (all) under $10,000 should increase thefts not reduce them.
Price of gas up > car thefts down. Or maybe it’s because we’re getting light rail or maybe because they are afraid to drive on the Viaduct.
Before you just take the numbers they give you, you should take a look at the number crunching and analysis JvA did on crime statistics reporting numbers earlier this year:
http://midbeaconhill.blogspot.com/2008/0…
http://midbeaconhill.blogspot.com/2008/0…
http://midbeaconhill.blogspot.com/2008/0…
http://midbeaconhill.blogspot.com/2008/0…
http://midbeaconhill.blogspot.com/2008/1…
We can make those numbers come out anyway you want.
12-10-08
And Will that’s the King County Sheriff not the SPD. Subtle difference for you.
Fnarf is exactly right. Rapes are down 8 percent from two years ago, which is more significant than last year’s numbers, not to mention that whenever you have so few events (less than per year 80) the change in percentage can look a lot worse than it actually is.
Did anyone else read “STD Releases Mid-Year Crime Stats” at first glance?
I’d like to predict that “robbery” and “larceny” rates have a sharp increase as the economy worsens.
Yeah, but hiring new cops doesn’t necessarily deter crime. Some cause/ effect problems in Jonah’s reading of stats, independent of the stats themselves.
Here in San Diego this year’s stats look pretty similar
Crime’s dropped overall here by quite a bit, but murders are up 10% and rapes up 35%.
Even though SD is twice as large as Seattle, the crime rates in both places are roughly inline. It’d be useful to see what other mid-sized cities are reporting.
http://www.signonsandiego.com/news/metro…
With more cops on the force, shouldn’t crime go up? More people to enforce the law = more people busted for breaking it.
Education, social programs, etc. would be responsible for driving crime down.
It could be that rape isn’t so much up as being reported more often. Rape is always the most under reported crime.
The biggest drop of all, auto thefts, is due to Dan Satterberg and the King County Prosecutors Office.
They made it harder for car thieves to escape prosecution, whereas before they were turned loose until a few convictions. They also instituted better tracking and noticed that there was an 80:20 rule at work and by getting the biggest offenders behind bars the could “take a bite out of crime”…and so they did!
Bravo to a great Prosecutor!
@5 – do you actually READ what you post?
Look, unless it’s a new car in the model year or just after, the blue book value is BELOW the amount.
Hence, it’s NOT REPORTED.
Hence, it’s NOT PROSECUTED.
Geesh.
I understand that robbery and assault and burglary and car theft and robbery can be frightening and infuriating and expensive and inconvenient, and that gangs are a part of what brings the above into our neighborhoods.
but these costs are small compared to the lifetime impact of rape on a child, a man, or a woman, not to mention those who love her or him. yet resources are shrinking for these victims. your car’s stolen? take the bus or get a new one. your laptops and video games are taken? you feel violated, get better locks, and new stuff eventually. you get held up? you loose your cash, maybe a watch, you become incontinent and are more careful in the future; all things you’ll get over with ease, with any luck.
you get raped? different story.
fnarf, I usually love and agree with every thing you have to say and am generally delighted by how you go about saying what you say. just know it’s not a good idea to go with the statistics when you are discussing rape
p.s. fnarf: I guess that makes me a hypocrite, since I began this by citing a horrifying (to me) statistic.
also, bad choice to call a rape a “one off.” just sayin’.
@3: I tend to think Fnarf is a nut job, ever since he raged to his full extent against me (and was 100% wrong, making him look volatile). Is he right about da rape? I always assumed that when reported rapes were relatively low for an area, 2-3 rapists could change all statistics and feelings of “safe” over a relatively short period.
Either rapes are up by a whopping 40%, or the dramatic decrease between 06 and 07 isn’t real. In that case, they’re really down, by 8% between 06 and 08. I’d run over the last decade with a window in which a few years were averaged, and see if the trend is as dramatic as the one year between 06 and 07 would suggest.
Don’t let statistics fool you.
The vast majority of the rapes are committed by black men, who themselves are a tiny, tiny minority around here.
@grace
I think fnarf’s just talking stats, not trying to make a moral statement about rape. And he’s right, when the numbers are as low as they are, a small increase is going to look bigger than it really is. For example, if there were only 3 more murders, that would be a 20% increase. Telling people there are 20% more murders this year than last year looks enormous, but it’s really not. The rape rate fluctuates too much and makes it look like dramatic rises and falls, but it’s misleading. The auto theft rate, on the other hand, IS a real dramatic effect, there is a significant decrease in auto theft, whereas the increase/decrease in rape looks big but is not really real or significant.
Anyone know who the other two homicide victims are?
1. Jan. 11 — Allen Joplin
2. Jan. 12 — De Che Morrison
3. Jan. 26 shot / Feb. 6 died — Perry Henderson
4. Jan. 26 — Maurice “Moe” Allen
5. Jan. 30 — Degene Berecha Dashasa
6. Feb. 21 — William Francis Ball
7. March 3 — Matthew Korpinen
8. April 13 — Noel Lopez
9. April 18 — Tracy Creamer
10. April 18 — Debra Lynn Bonilla
11. April 22 — Candace L. Kaake
12. June 28 — Roald “Rolly” Hanson.
13. June 27 — Eldora Earlycutt
I don’t think fnarf said anything, or meant anything wrong with his post. I don’t quite understand what he is saying, but in no way do I think he was underplaying the devastating effect rape has on the victim as well as the victim’s family. (I agree with fnarf a little more than half the time but I find we can disagree without being dicks about it).
I have no figures to back this up, just my gut feeling, that there isn’t much, statistically, to the rise or fall of rapes. I think the percentage per capita probably remains steady. I think some years, for some reason, women are just reporting it more.
Maybe it depends on the news. Someone should study the numbers of “reported” rapes after high profile rape trials fall in favor of the suspect. I am specifically thinking of the Duke Lacrosse team and Kobe Bryant cases.
Regardless of the innocence of the team, or of Bryant, in both cases the victim was vilified in the press.
I could imagine that after such case the victim might be trepidacious about reporting the crime.
Grace:
have you ever had your car stolen?
Then you will know what is like, for some people it is the only way to get to their job.
It is a big deal to some of us, don’t say it is like your Ipod getting stolen.