From Facebook—is this a joke? “Inserting his opinion”? Why so censorious, Steve? Everybody loves Cliff—what’s your damage?
To All,
With sadness I must announce that I have released Cliff Mass from his weekly weather and science segment on Weekday. For more than 15 years Cliff has been a regular volunteer, contributor presenting an informative and entertaining segment about science and weather. Over time Cliff began inserting his opinion on a wider range of issues outside of science and weather, most notably education. Although we value Cliff’s opinion I do not want the weather segment to become an opinion and views segment. Every Weekday we use a full hour to take up controversial issues which brings many voices with a variety of opinions and views.
I spoke with Cliff on several occasions about my concerns but Cliff disagreed that his science and weather segment should not include his views about other subjects. As a result I have decided to terminate Cliff’s weather and science segment. We will continue to look at other ways to involve Cliff on Weekday that will allow him to share his expertise on other issues. Below is the e-mail that I sent to Cliff discussing this relationship.
Sincerely,
Steve Scher

Years ago I thought Steve Scher was a very awkward interviewer and I still don’t know why he has to lead in every show with the same Elvis Costello “What’s So Funny ‘Bout..” riff. Last year, James Fallows: “Do you really play that every day? Really?” These days he’s much more skilled, informed on topics and asks great questions. This whole thing must be personal. Every Wednesday Vaughn Palmer calls in to deliver the “news” from Canada – if only it were just that. His squeaky, see-saw voice (sorry, it’s annoying) cranking out his own insider-flavored commentary, regarding politics, scandal, crime, sports, etc. So why the double-standard? Smells like a piddle contest,
Cliff Mass was asked to stay on topic, he didn’t so he wasn’t asked back. He didn’t have a contract with KUOW, there was no commitment on either side.
Good point, @50. True. I’ll look them up. I guess it’s just that he’s a more competent interviewer than I would be! Not saying much, of course, but I still like the program. Good point, too, about the agents of the interesting people doing the booking, not so much the producer.
Why would Mass want to stay on Weekday if he wasn’t welcome? The easy answer is to give him his own segment, ala birdnote.
Steve Sher’s interviews are more about giving himself air time than allowing the
guest the air time. I have been distressed for some time by Sher’s lack of directness
when asking questions…an example of his interviewing style might look something like this: “So, are you saying that black is white or vice versa or am I missing something here like
your definition of black and white? I would assume that you’re not saying that but I just
want to be clear on where you stand on this issue since there has been some controversy
about your views in the past on this subject. So, I’m asking whether you’re saying that
black is white, or are you saying that white is black, or is are you saying that there is
possibly an alternative view that you’re espousing that we have not considered as we
explore this issue?”
Steve, the question should be simple: “Do you believe that black is white?” You don’t
need to try to anticipate how the guest will answer by giving all possible alternatives
to the answer in the question.
Scher is one of the most inept interviewers I’ve encountered. My favorite bit is when he asks as question, then interrupts the guest to make a stupid joke about how poorly phrased his question was. EVERY FUCKING TIME.
I’m not surprised to find out he’s a total dick in person as well as on-air.
I agree with 55. If Scher didn’t ‘um’ so much, there’d be plenty of time for actual engagement.
To whom it should concern,
I am a contributor who has been listening to KUOW for about half a century. I see the open and intelligent dialog it provides as vital to everything from quality entertainment to the public education pivotal in resolving problems whose increasing gravity has mirrored our increasing power to reshape everything around us. In a media desert bereft of the dedication to truth and the joy of its discovery, I have found KUOW and Public Broadcasting to be the resource most needed in our world.
I am writing out of concern that Cliff Mass will no longer be heard on KUOW. He is unquestionably the gold standard in his field. I was forwarded his blog posting by another contributor to KUOW who values his broadcasts. I accept that I do not know all the facts. However, I am deeply concerned that so excellent a voice has been silenced. I found his foray into math a snore. A balancing voice could have been found to extol the virtues of fuzzy math or what ever the issue was. Defending the University of Washington and its admission standards also seems like an issue unworthy of termination from a University of Washington broadcast. Even if he had been guilty of a long string of similar transgressions, we need institutions like KUOW to provide managers and producers able to use readily available editing and programming tools to balance these easily surmountable sins. How tough is it to hit delete and talk to Cliff? How difficult is it to find someone who thinks fuzzy math is actually warm and fuzzy?
I don’t care much about tomorrow’s weather. I care about intelligent voices who can describe its dynamics and critical future impact. I am offended by canceling that dialog. I am deeply concerned that the management of KUOW has been unable to manage this issue. I am most concerned about the choice prioritizing narrow compartmentalization of ideas; we have Fox for that. If there is no cause with actual substance, I will unfortunately remain offended and will support other Public Broadcasting venues. I hope that instead, he will be returned and that no more choices are made that value controlled McNuggets of wisdom over true brilliance, intellectual rigor and infectious enthusiasm. That choice insults your listeners and the most fundamental principals of the University upon which you are founded.
Sincerely,
Brian Sherlock
To whom it should concern,
I am a contributor who has been listening to KUOW for about half a century. I see the open and intelligent dialog it provides as vital to everything from quality entertainment to the public education pivotal in resolving problems whose increasing gravity has mirrored our increasing power to reshape everything around us. In a media desert bereft of the dedication to truth and the joy of its discovery, I have found KUOW and Public Broadcasting to be the resource most needed in our world.
I am writing out of concern that Cliff Mass will no longer be heard on KUOW. He is unquestionably the gold standard in his field. I was forwarded his blog posting by another contributor to KUOW who values his broadcasts. I accept that I do not know all the facts. However, I am deeply concerned that so excellent a voice has been silenced. I found his foray into math a snore. A balancing voice could have been found to extol the virtues of fuzzy math or what ever the issue was. Defending the University of Washington and its admission standards also seems like an issue unworthy of termination from a University of Washington broadcast. Even if he had been guilty of a long string of similar transgressions, we need institutions like KUOW to provide managers and producers able to use readily available editing and programming tools to balance these easily surmountable sins. How tough is it to hit delete and talk to Cliff? How difficult is it to find someone who thinks fuzzy math is actually warm and fuzzy?
I don’t care much about tomorrow’s weather. I care about intelligent voices who can describe its dynamics and critical future impact. I am offended by canceling that dialog. I am deeply concerned that the management of KUOW has been unable to manage this issue. I am most concerned about the choice prioritizing narrow compartmentalization of ideas; we have Fox for that. If there is no cause with actual substance, I will unfortunately remain offended and will support other Public Broadcasting venues. I hope that instead, he will be returned and that no more choices are made that value controlled McNuggets of wisdom over true brilliance, intellectual rigor and infectious enthusiasm. That choice insults your listeners and the most fundamental principals of the University upon which you are founded.
Sincerely,
Brian Sherlock
Cliff Mass might be a brilliant meteorologist and he may be right on the math education stuff, but the stridency of his advocacy of his position is off-putting and his readiness to demonize those who disagree with him comes across, to me, as childish. I don’t care to hear or read much of it.
KUOW has a right and responsibility to control the content on the show. They want to have a regular weather segment. They don’t want to have a regular math education rant segment. This isn’t a surprise to anybody, including Dr. Mass.
I know a lot of people here don’t like Steve Scher, and frankly, I don’t see why. He’s no Terry Gross but neither does he come across as a buffoon. I look forward every week to the segment with Vaughn Palmer. Most of the rest of the content- not so much. But that’s the nature of the format, and as far as I can see Scher does a decent job with it.
There does seem to be some legitimate question as to why Steves is permitted to add advocacy to his travel content without getting a similar Dear John letter from KUOW. Maybe that’s because he’s invariably a delight to listen to, or maybe he is just skilled at skating near the thin ice. Or maybe his letter is in the mail.
The journalistic integrity comment has to do with KUOW bowing to the UW when they got pissed about Mass’s truthful comments on the situation there. They didn’t like the accurate criticism, squeezed KUOW’s balls, and now Mass is gone right along with the journalistic integrity of KUOW who has shown it WILL capitulate and hide the truth if one of its masters growls.
Scher is clearly -such- hot shit that KUOW has no need to worry about getting enough money. That’s great, I’m sure that there are Math Illiteracy charities that’ll gladly take my pledge money.
The grammatical error(s) in Scher’s letter remind me why I always hated him on-air. Proofread, people!
Steve Scher drives me cuckoo. So inattentive, unprepared, ham handed, out to lunch… etc etc. But I called Arvid and I told him all this, and we talked and then I realized he (also) was googling -or something – while we were talking, and I tried to finish up but he kept mindlessly asking me for further comments- I finally said, I HAVE TO GO!!!
Is the problem multi tasking? FOCUS MEN!! Or get out of the way and let someone else do a decent job.
Steve Scher is an embarrassment to Seattle Public Radio. I’ve been listening to public radio for twenty-five years, broadcast from stations in every city I’ve ever driven through or lived in, and he is by far the most ignorant, absent-minded clapping chimp that I can remember. The random pacing, the stumbling space cadet ramblings (is he reading and talking at the same time?), and the 11th grade reading level all form a show that comes across as just about as sophisticated as a Forest Gump quote. I think its clear that without the Vaughn Palmer, Rick Steeves and Cliff Mass segments, Weekday has basically no content. I pray for the day Steve Scher’s Weekday show is cancelled and those precious hour can be reclaimed for use by shows that actually mean something.
He’s got to better informed and prepared than Joni Balter. Throw her unctious prevaricatin’ ass off the show instead.
Listen to the last 10 minutes of Steve Scher’s 10 am “Weekday” show from Friday on kuow.org. One caller “snuck through” the highly reactionary talk show host’s screening process… and Scher WENT POSTAL on him for even bringing the subject up.
This, apparently, is indicative of the “free flow of information and opinion” that KUOW / UofW Institution, Inc love to encourage.
The level of self-absorbed, self-congratulatory passive-agressive Seattle snobbery on display every Weekday morning from 9-11 am gets worse and worse every year. I would rather suffer through 45 minutes of annoying commercial fm advertisements (along with the non-fake humility of Dave Ross and Luke Burbank) than suffer through two hours of commercial-free Steve Scher.
The way Scher, his producer, and the stale bureaucracy they pimp for treated Cliff Mass is not uncommon. This one happened to make “the news” because Mass was so well known, respected and enjoyed by the broader community. If Mass was a super-decent guy with no name recognition, Scher and his 800 lb reactionary gorilla would have chewed him up and spit him out a long time ago.
petition to get him back! http://www.petitionbuzz.com/petitions/cl…
My beef with Steve Scher is more his arrogance than his incompetence. His “Oh so casual” and “I’m bored with this interview” style drives me crazy. I simply cannot stand to listen to him unless the person he is interviewing is someone I ABSOLUTELY want to hear. No question that KUOW would be better off without Scher.
Best way to show displeasure – donate $0.02 to KUOW and in comments say “Fire Steve Scher, bring back Cliff Mass”.
What about that Jeannie Yandel? Whose decision was it to hire her? Off topic, perhaps, but if we are considering incompetence here, let’s open up the conversation. I want to lose my mind every time I hear her voice, her laugh, her “wow!” response to comments she clearly cannot comprehend. Seattle’s KUOW is far below the other public radio programming in terms of excellent, compelling interviewers. After listening to the station for a decade, Steve, actually, is the only one with some competence — though I agree with many re. some of his techniques. Ever hear him interviewing Garrison Keillor? Painful. Nearly as painful as listening to Jeannie Yandel.
It’s a 5 min show, it has no time for point counterpoint and while Scheer’s email was tacky, Mass made no effort to stay in the weather mode and wanted to voice his opinion without a counter viewpoint. Scheer had no choice and his colleagues would have lost respect for him, if by the final warning, he hadn’t dropped Herr Mass. I feel Mass is a bully when he doesn’t get his way and is showing so by his not dropping this issue over his 5 mins, once-a -week segment.
He wasn’t fired, how can you fire a volunteer on public radio? I would of phoned Mass and said “you’re done” after being warned several times. No email.
SScanning all this makes me wonder whether most commenters are talking about the same Steve Scher.
I would have kept Mass on the air — no problem for me if he throws in political and social commentary along with his excellent and entertaining weather analysis. As a semi-regular listener, I actually don’t recall any such comments; it doesn’t seem they were a dominant feature. So from what I know, I disagree with Scher’s decision. That said, I understand the reasoning — and reading between the lines, I have to suspect that Mass (who I also have met and like) has a big and easily bruised ego, and that he likely has been something of a pain the ass about it all.
In any case, the ad hominem attacks on Scher are misplaced. Twice over the years I was interviewed by him on topics in my specialty (STD and HIV/AIDS). He asked intelligent and insightful questions and clearly had done his homework. He knew the topic well, including the essence of the new developments that led to the interviews. And as a frequent but not regular listener, I am impressed by his generally excellent questions and the evidence he researches the topic completely. It’s hard for me to believe that any careful listener could call his questions softball or say with a straight face that he doesn’t know the topics. And even for those who believe it, please can the personal vitriol. It doesn’t get anyone anywhere and it looks bad for the person making the comment.
As for those who accuse the University of pressuring KUOW on political or social grounds — get real! I’ve been on UW faculty for over 4 decades. This is philosophically unrealistic and would be patently against the University’s interests. Just as the American Medical Association has no say in editorial policies of the Journal of the AMA (and burned their fingers when they tried to influence JAMA), meddling in their own media affiliate would backfire, and UW administration knows it. And the administration probably isn’t capable of putting political pressure on KUOW anyway. UW is anything but a single minded monolith; if anyone tried, from the president on down, there would just as assertive support for the station from other, equally highly placed quarters of the administration, faculty, etc.
HHH, MD
So the obvious solution, in the best spirit of public radio , is find some time to present the other side. I have been pretty dumbfounded that the problem of having to present the other side of CM’s opining was seen as a problem rather than an opportunity. Is this the KUOW that I know and love and pledge toevery year for 17 years now? I love Steve Scher and bashing
of him is unnecessary, but perhaps he and Superintendent Enfield can do a show together on what it’s like to make a rash personnel decision(I.e. Ingraham principal firing) and get creamed by the public for it, maybe throw in the other side of the math education issue in that show. And just maybe Steve will follow Dr Enfield’s example and reverse the decis
He was brought on to do the Fucking Weather, hello? He can’t turn it in to a salad bowl. Some of you sound like Ayn Rand disciples. Fucckiing move onnnnnnn. *****Cognitive Dissonance ALERT! *******It’s their station, it’s their station ********* Public radio does not give you a right to blather off topic. Go look at their station policies.
I support Steve Scher. Almost always the guests are great – Joni Balter excepted – and Steve asks thoughtful, interesting questions. I’m not sure where all this hate for Steve comes from – maybe from people who just turned the dial from “Morning Zoo”-like programs who yell and shriek and have a whole panel of buttons for ‘comical’ sound effects?
As far as the weatherman goes, despite all his other admirable qualities – and respect for Carl Sagan being one of them – on this show he was the weatherman. You think a tv news show would put up with a weatherman suddenly veering off course and initiating a diatribe about eugenics? “And here in the northwest we will have monsoons and . . . you know what really gets my goat? Eugenics! What the hell, people!? Stay outta my genes, MONSANTO!”
I think the best deal would be to give Cliff his own short segment akin to Keelers poetry segment in the afternoon. There is a lot of shady crap about his dismissal, and I doubt a smooth reconciliation can occur with Steve at this point. I understand some of the station issues but cliff Mass is obviously very well liked and could provide more to the station with his own short segment.
I think KUOW now blacklists the e-mail of anyone who sends a comment in support of Cliff Mass. I sent one (not super flamey) e-mail, got the stock e-mail from Jeff Hanson: “no one gets to talk about anything unless I say so, because that way it’s ‘fair and balanced'” e-mail, but when I tried to respond my e-mail had been blocked.
Censoring critics. Blocking e-mails….
H’mmm Did KUOW recently employ a new station manager who left Cairo in a hurry?
It is painful to listen to Sher TRY to interview. Go listen to his recent interview with Jodie Foster if you have any questions about this. I cringed everytime he opened his mouth. So did she.
I will not donate another dime-regular supporter here-until they undo this mess. Right or wrong on the decision, the hamhanded delivery is everything I abhor. If Steve supporters don’t think this is a telling demonstration of this “thoughtful preparedness”, I’m sorry for you.
Of course weathermen should be allowed to take a position on abortion … after all, the more babies that are aborted, the fewer people will be around to listen to the weather forecast.
Seriously, there is much blathering on Weekday. The Friday panel show is nothing but pontification. Guests frequently go off topic, and sometimes end up discussing topics they really don’t seem to know much about. What’s the big deal? If we can survive an hour a week of gardening minutiae, and endless dead-horse pummeling around transportation issues, surely we can allow a practicing scientist to have his say about science education.
I agree…Steve Scher is one of the most….he is…no, wait. Let me put it this way if he was …no, that’s not really what I meant…..ha,ha,…let me get this to you right….Steve is…ahh….