Enough of the bad side of Muslim culture, let’s have a look at the more lovely aspects of that world:

st3-682x1024.jpg

Muslim (and non-Muslim) women who want to buy this delightful item can do so here. Sadly, the skirt does not come with that belly button.

Charles Mudede—who writes about film, books, music, and his life in Rhodesia, Zimbabwe, the USA, and the UK for The Stranger—was born near a steel plant in Kwe Kwe, Zimbabwe. He has no memory...

24 replies on “The Fruits of Islam”

  1. Charles,
    In contrast, I just sent this photo from the NY Times to a friend:

    http://www.nytimes.com/imagepages/2009/1…

    What’s interesting is I saw this kind of attire in Egypt and Mali (as I expected). But now, I see it is being worn in the Occident. One wouldn’t expect this particular kind of attire in Marseille (yes, I know it is 25% Muslim). Still, this is the land of Voltaire, Notre Dame, Brigitte Bardot and St. Tropez (topless beaches). So, it poses some tough questions regarding future demographics and culture in France and the USA for that matter.

    BTW, Fruit of Islam is (was?) the name of the security branch of Nation of Islam.

  2. Lark, i know about the fruit of islam. that was my little joke. but that image you sent to your friend made me sad. why do they hate women so much?

  3. Charles,
    Agree, it (the photo I sent) made me sad too. You pose a good question.

    Cool that you knew about Fruit of Islam, I didn’t know if they were still around.

  4. I don’t get what, specifically, is making Charles and lark sad in that photo. Is it that the ladies are covered, implying sexist oppression? That they’re getting rained on? I mean, they’re carrying an umbrella that they’re not using.

  5. @11
    I believe the burqua or full chador (as exhibited in the photo) where the the entire woman’s body is covered head to toe in black or dark tone fabric save for a small slit for the eyes (in some cases there is actually a net over the slit) is sexist oppression and the fact that it is happening in the West (Marseille, France) and growing elsewhere in the West is quite disturbing.

  6. “I believe the burqua or full chador is sexist oppression and the fact that it is happening in the West (Marseille, France) and growing elsewhere in the West is quite disturbing.”

    It’s certainly sexist oppression in Muslim countries where women are REQUIRED to dress that way. But Muslim women in the West are free to choose how they dress and don’t be so quick to presume they’re choosing to be “oppressed.”

    This LA Times article from September says:

    In a column that was published a year ago but has grabbed widespread interest on the Internet in recent days, America’s own Naomi Wolf had a revelation. Islamic dress protocol, she says, can be empowering and is infused with feminist dimensions that Westerners, in their Islamaphobia, are too quick to deny. [When Wolf] donned full-body covering and a chador and visited a Moroccan bazaar, she had something of an epiphany. “As I moved about the market — the curve of my breasts covered, the shape of my legs obscured, my long hair not flying about me — I felt a novel sense of calm and serenity,” Wolf wrote. “I felt, yes, in certain ways, free.”

    http://articles.latimes.com/2009/sep/10/…

  7. My favorite adaption is the “hijab bimbo” look that I see here in Oslo quite a bit. Modest hijab with everything else so tight it could be body paint. In some ways it does allow (often late teen) muslim women to claim a dual identity as a sex object and an innocent. This is what Britney would have done had she been, for example, Pakistani.

    I do feel bad for women who are forced to wear the full Burka with only a hole to see through when they are trying to carry shopping through a frozen, slippery, uneven landscape. I feel extra sorry for them because they are much more likely to have had their clits inexpertly carved off of them at the begining of puberty.

    As for the idea that muslim dress can be liberating for women: that is a consequence of muslim men (in general) being such fucking sexist pigs to women in their culture. The men-folk are so weak, you see…if they see an exposed toe they get sprung and go into a rutting frenzy. This problem is solved not with self control, but by making the women cover themselves entirely so that the men can pretend they are not there. Fucking weak.

  8. @13 Roma,
    My conclusion is the same whether in the Orient or Occident, the attire is sexist oppression. I am highly dubious that women even in the West are “choosing” to dress in burqua. We have no idea what goes on in a strict Muslim household for a girl in say Paris or even Seattle. In contrast, consider a nun who sports similar garb. Is she oppressed? Last time I checked it is a choice to enter a convent and wear such clothes which have actually become less confining in recent years. In fact, some nuns choose not to wear habits at all. That is not the case with a daughter being raised in a traditional Muslim household.

    Also, consider the fact that no reasonable woman would wander on a beach in Yemen or Saudi Arabia in a bikini. What’s possible in the Occident isn’t possible in the Orient. The burqua isn’t just oppressive it is flat out dangerous. Wearing a veil with a slit for the eyes to see and sometimes even a net covering that slit prevents effective peripheral vision. One of the reasons it is forbidden that women drive in Saudi Arabia in addition to just flat out discrimination is the simple fact that wearing the veil and driving at the same time would be extremely hazardous.

  9. 15/lark: “@13 Roma, My conclusion is the same whether in the Orient or Occident, the attire is sexist oppression. I am highly dubious that women even in the West are “choosing” to dress in burqua. We have no idea what goes on in a strict Muslim household for a girl in say Paris or even Seattle. In contrast, consider a nun who sports similar garb. Is she oppressed? Last time I checked it is a choice to enter a convent and wear such clothes which have actually become less confining in recent years. In fact, some nuns choose not to wear habits at all. That is not the case with a daughter being raised in a traditional Muslim household.

    You remind me of some radical feminists back in the 60s. They felt that no woman could possibly “choose” to be a stay-at-home mom, that staying at home with children was “sexist oppression.” Other radical feminists felt — and some, likely still feel — that no woman could possibly “choose” to wear high heels. Wearing high heels is also “sexist oppression.”

    Now, there’s a difference between adult Muslim women and girls living at home in the West. But that difference exists for non-Muslim girls and women, and for boys and men too. When you’re living with your family, you have to obey their rules and I’m sure many children — whether religious or secular — find their parents’ rules oppressive. So if we’re talking about Muslim GIRLS in the West, living with their parents, who don’t want to dress in that attire, then I’d agree with you. But it’s a different matter for Muslim women in the West. They are free to choose.

    I’m completely in agreement with you about that attire being sexist oppression of Muslim women living in Muslim countries where that attired is required by the state, just as it would be sexist oppression if women in the U.S. were required by law to be stay-at-home moms or wear high heels.

  10. 14/Mayhem: “As for the idea that muslim dress can be liberating for women: that is a consequence of muslim men (in general) being such fucking sexist pigs to women in their culture. The men-folk are so weak, you see…if they see an exposed toe they get sprung and go into a rutting frenzy. This problem is solved not with self control, but by making the women cover themselves entirely so that the men can pretend they are not there. Fucking weak.”

    I’m in agreement with you, as I am with with lark, when it comes to women being FORCED to dress that way in Muslim countries. It’s very sexist to require women to cover themselves up in public because men aren’t expected to have any self-control.

    I don’t know if you’re familiar with the Arab Human Development Report (actually a series of reports; 2002, 2003, 2004, 2005 and 2009.) These are reports sponsored by the United Nations Development Program and carried out by leading Arab scholars and researchers.

    The initial report identified three main deficits in the Arab-Muslim world, one of which was the lack of empowerment of women.

    The 2005 report focused on women and was entitled: Towards the Rise of Women in the Arab World

    The report concluded that Arab countries have attained significant achievements in the advancement of women but that much more remains to be accomplished. The report argued for the full ratification and implementation of all the provisions of the United Nations Convention on the Elimination of All Forms of Discrimination Against Women (CEDAW), as well as a wide-ranging movement in Arab civil society that engages both women and men in the struggle to steadily expand the frontier of women’s opportunities – for the benefit not only of women but for Arab society as a whole. In particular, the report called for the adoption of time-bound affirmative action, tailored to the specificities of each Arab society, in order to expand the participation of women in all fields of human activity. The report argued that such measures were imperative to dismantle the structures of centuries of discrimination.

    Hardcore multicultural types typically complain that the U.S., or the West in general, has no right to force its beliefs on other cultures, that doing so is “cultural imperialism.” I think that’s bullshit — I believe that human rights are universal — but the good thing about these Arab Human Development reports is that it’s insiders, Arabs, calling for equality for women, not outsiders.

  11. @16 Roma,
    This is a good discussion. I don’t part with you too much. My one quibble is that modest dress is fine and family rules ok as long as they aren’t literally oppressive. I agree some women choose to wear very confining clothing especially in the West. That said, if those two women walking in Marseille wearing full chador (in the picture) choose to do so, then fine let them. My only reservation is that men and/or culture might be dictating that to them. I don’t like that anymore than pre-arranged marriages in the West (and East) which some cultures allow.

    I couldn’t agree with you more that human rights are universal. The hardcore multicultural types irritate me as well. I see “cultural imperialism” as sometimes the only option to empower women in some areas of the developing world. BTW, I highly recommend “Half the Sky” by Nicholas Kristof and Sheryl WuDunn. It is an excellent book recounting stories of women undergoing horrible traumas and somehow or other making a better situation of their lot. A great read.

  12. “@16 Roma, This is a good discussion.”

    Thanks, lark. I agree.

    If a Muslim girl was living at home and one of her parents’ rules was to cover up in public, who are you (or I) to conclude that is something that is “literally oppressive.” If the French government felt it was so oppressive as to constitute child abuse, you can be sure they would not permit parents to require this of their daughters.

    “That said, if those two women walking in Marseille wearing full chador (in the picture) choose to do so, then fine let them. My only reservation is that men and/or culture might be dictating that to them. I don’t like that anymore than pre-arranged marriages in the West (and East) which some cultures allow.”

    If an adult Muslim woman doesn’t want to cover up in public, then she should marry a Muslim man (or non-Muslim man) who won’t require her to do that. Culture and/or religion can can certainly “dictate” codes of dress and behavior and ideas to people — and I don’t like that any more than you do — but, again, you have to give people more credit for free will. People aren’t mindless robots that can be programmed.

    I’m not familiar with the book, but I always read Kristof’s columns in the NY Times and know how passionate he is about women’s rights, especially in parts of the world where they’re very oppressed. It’s been heartbreaking to read some of his stories from places like Darfur and Pakistan. Women in the Arab-Muslim world may eventually be treated as equals but I think it’s going to take a long time. And while the West should apply some pressure, I think that most of the pressure for change has to come from within, from Muslims who are liberal and moderate.

    As Tom Friedman, another Times columnist, has pointed out, there is a “war of ideas” going on in the Muslim world. The conservatives and extremists seek what they view as a “pure” Islam and the liberals feel that Islam needs to undergo the same kind of reformation that Christianity did. I sure hope the liberals win but the conservatives and extremists are going to put up a fierce fight.

  13. @19 Roma
    I believe I read that very same piece by Friedman in the NYT. I’ve read at least one of his books too. Not a few people have suggested Islam needs a Reformation. Another fine book I recommend is “After the Prophet” by Lesley Hazelton, a British scholar who resides right here in Wash. St. The origins of Islam are quite shocking. Much of it embroiling a family. Fascinating read as well.

    Yeah, I believe we have more in common than not. Excellent discussion. Thank you.

  14. Lark, thank you as well. I appreciate your intelligence and perspective and civility and I enjoyed the discussion. We definitely have more in common than not, in our views. Thanks for the tip about “After the Prophet” and the other book. Perhaps we’ll cross paths on another SLOG post. Cheers!

  15. Lark. P.S. . . . have you been to Marseilles or the south of France? I love it there, especially Nice and the nearby area. I’ve only been to Marseilles once, to change trains, but I want to go back and spend more time there. I read an article in a travel magazine a few years ago which said that Marseilles is the #1 city in France young French people want to move to. Cool that you’ve been to Egypt and Mali.

  16. @22Roma,
    I’ve yet to visit Marseille. But, I do speak French and want to return to France soon. I’ve visted Paris and Nancy. A la prochaine.

  17. “But, I do speak French…”

    Bon! I speak and understand some, but just minimal tourist-type phrases. I’ve been to Paris too. Absolutely beautiful. My favorite city in Europe after Rome. If you ever get to the south of France try to make it to Nice. That area of France used to be part of Italy so it’s got a real Italian look and feel to it in parts.

Comments are closed.