It’s here.
I know I’m (mostly) preaching to the choir, but I’m going to keep posting these articles as they come for the few foot-draggers who read Slog and either a) argue for prohibition and against regulation in the comments or b) privately tell me they’re wary about ending prohibition.
The subhead: “It’s a no-brainer: ending the ‘war on drugs’ would create jobs, cut law enforcement costs, raise revenue — and benefit patients.”
The nut:
Meanwhile, New York City spends $75m per year to enforce the prohibition of marijuana. A recent study by the Drug Policy Alliance shows that between 2002 and 2010, New York City spent between $350m and $700m to arrest and charge people with low-level marijuana possession. Against this background, the city presently debates which schools to close and which public employees to lay off — decisions that will only deepen the impact of the recession.
Another report estimates that nationwide government spending on enforcing marijuana laws costs $7.7bn per year. A look at Montana, however, shows how the state has been given a much needed bump from the legalisation of medical marijuana. Since 2004, investors have put millions of dollars into the newly legalised medical marijuana sector, creating jobs for professional horticulturists, construction workers and electricians put out of work by the recession. This small marijuana industry created 1,400 jobs last year — this in a state with less than a million people.
A change in US marijuana policy would mean significant savings. Full legalisation would bring in an estimated $2.4bn annually if marijuana were taxed like most consumer goods, and $6.2bn annually if it were taxed at rates similar to those on alcohol and tobacco. In fact, legalisation of marijuana — the cessation of prosecutions and tax revenue — could put more than $13bn into government coffers. That would equal the entire budget of the department of labour. Maybe with a budget twice as large, it could focus on creating jobs and getting Americans back to work.

The link is broken.
Sorry, fixing.
any addicts out there who’d like to chime in?
that shit it hard to quit yo.
harder than alcohol or smokes, imho.
for a second there I though SPOG’s newspaper came out for legalization, and I was shocked. And then I saw that the link was guardian.co.uk, and realized how banal it was.
As someone who’s publicly wary about ending prohibition, it’s still nice to see the Guardian reprinting other papers’ stuff like they did here for their Comment is Free section.
It gets us no forrarder toward getting from here to there than what I’ve already read here and elsewhere, but I suppose having more voices chime in that something’s terribly wrong will have to be progress enough.
@3, Well I’m no addict but I do use it sometimes. Your humble opinion doesn’t actually have any factual scientific basis. There has never been a scientific study showing any physical addiction to pot. There have been countless studies showing tobacco to be one of the most addictive substances on the planet, up there above heroin in some of the studies.
Pot, like every other enjoyable thing in life (sex, TV, video games, food, etc), can be mentally addictive but that shit’s easy to quit yo.
@5, remember ending prohibition, contrary to the propaganda, does not mean selling it next to gum at the drug store. It means selling it next to the whiskey at the liquor store. We can regulate it and it will get much harder, not easier, for kids to get their hands on. If you legalized it you put street corner dealers out of business almost immediately. When people don’t have to go to street corner dealers you don’t have to worry about some punk “upselling” them to crack or meth.
Ugh. The article mentioned calls marijuana a “homeopathic” substance. That is entirely not true, not even slightly. The two thing are completely unrelated. Then they go on to list the “proven” effects of marijuana. Nothing has been proven, there is evidence to show, LOTS of evidence to show, that marijuana helps. There is however not proof yet which is in turn p[art of why it needs to be legalized so it can be studied further more freely.
I was hoping for a good piece of journalism. What I found was a hack writer who happens to agree with me on the marijuana issue but lists all the wrong reasons for legalization. These kinds of blunders only add fuel to our political opponents.
@6, I know what ending prohibition means, and am aware of what you suggest: that both sides of the issue like to insist it’s very simple. “Legalize it all this minute, it’s obvious” makes one admire one’s own halo, yes, but it also conveniently avoids helping public officials map out a plan for moving from where we are to where we could be in a way that will play with voters.
@8 The problem is not voters. Voters have been supporting legalization in full for some time now. The problem is that it takes more than 51% of the votes to actually get something done. When the issue is so close politicians are not willing to risk it. They want to wait until it is a slam dunk case and then all run like rats from the war on drugs ship.
The problem is our anemic political process that feels like it is always just behind progress enough to not risk personal careers but just following enough to not their current job. It’s pathetic and marijuana users, tax payers, and every citizen in general suffers because of it.
I like that this article didn’t just mention the enforcement savings and tax revenue, but also the real income GDP impact. This is something we CAN make domestically. This is something that is WORTH making domestically. And every unlaundered dollar spent legally on American goods and services is a dollar earned based on value grown from the ground. Maybe we could even sell some internationally and turn around a tiny portion of our trade imbalance.
Because while it’s certainly true that there is a thriving, relatively peaceful domestic pot cultivation industry (here, Humboldt County, etc), so much of our other drug money is being directly funneled from legitimate businesses to organized criminals who use that money to fund some pretty unspeakable things in the name of profit.
Remember – only YOU can buy American!
(Of course, once it becomes legal, I’m sure we’ll instantly see it factory-farmed Monsanto-style, but that’s another subject entirely – we can’t tackle every problem at once.)
@9, aren’t sort of making the point for me, though? Public leaders, elected officials, know that voters being x percent in favor of legalization is NOT the same thing as “I will support you through all the difficult policy changes, public safety shifts, possible missteps and problems, because the goal is worthy and you are right to champion it”.
Sure, you or I might take that attitude, but we have to give electeds reason to believe a substantial number of voters are willing to stick by them – rather than sit around castigating our leaders for not sticking their necks out, it’s time advocates worked out and built pubic support for a road map, one that acknowledges the obstacles and suggests ways around them.
@10, the Humbolt family growers are terrified of the price impact of legalization. Believe it or not, many of them are just getting by. If they have to lower prices the small operations fear going out of business, ceding the domestic grow market to the big boys.
http://www.times-standard.com/localnews/…
Damn – s/b “aren’t *you* sort of”. And “pubic support”? Oof.
@13 Don’t get me wrong, I’ll mourn the economies of Arcata, Eureka, etc – there are some great people out there who will absolutely lose their livelihoods if pot becomes factory-farmed, but as nice a people as they are, and while it sucks to have any local economy usurped by big business, this artificially-inflated price exists because pot is illegal [comparison to housing bubble redacted]. Legalizing it shouldn’t be stopped because a few really good local economies might then be undercut by big companies. That’s a separate issue, and one they’re already looking at.
It seems like there might still be a “boutique” economy for certain strains that can’t be mass-marketed, like how specialty wines from certain geographic locations command a higher premium than their mass-marketed equivalents. In that way, the artificial value is one of branding and taste rather than one based on law enforcement.
@3 “any addicts out there who’d like to chime in? that shit it hard to quit yo. harder than alcohol or smokes, imho.”
I love baseless DARE propaganda from the mouths of trolls.
fair point, @15. (I missed your @12 while composing my sloppy @13.) One young Humboldt grower was quoted to that effect – there’ll always be a place for the innovators of premium strains.
There will probably still be room for illegal growers to undercut legal prices, especially if they tax the heck out of it. But, as a grower, I’d much rather go up against the local cops now than against the IRS once this is passed. I can’t imagine how stupid one would have to be to risk that.