Walking by the new little store where The Anne Bonny used to be on Summit this morning, I came across a serious cowboy-and-Indian window display advertising used clothing and shoes—a setup of Western pioneerey styles on one side and beaded moccasins, a little teepee, and a full headdress on the other side, separated by American flags draped over the door windows.

Jen Graves (The Stranger’s former arts critic) mostly writes about things you approach with your eyeballs. But she’s also a history nerd interested in anything that needs more talking about, from male...

85 replies on “The Hipster Headdress and Other Tribal Fashions”

  1. This slog post is ridiculous! The window front isn’t racist, if anything it’s on trend. She is selling FASHION, not racist ideas. Spring 2011 runways were full of Native American and Western trends. Check out Gucci, L.A.M.B., Missoni and Hermes. You’re the one putting racist ideas in others heads, not Adria.

  2. Thank you Stagger Lee for you comment. I have been in the midst of my own rebuttal filled with a similar tone. How offensive and upsetting that Jen Graves is in a position to voice such arrogantly ignorant opinions in a forum of social media where people may be swayed to agree. That this person can make such flagrant accusations that lack even an ounce of research or back story. She ought to be ashamed, and so should The Stranger for keeping her on the payroll. Adria, the Indian Summer store front is an incredible, beautiful, and bravely honest representation of who you are and an homage to your family, strengths and ingenuity. Once inside, you discover Adria’s acute eye for all that is esthetically pleasing. This quip saddens me to my soul; that people such as Jen Graves could speak so ferociously with such a lack of respect for social culture in this country. It is delightful to know that Indian Summer has already become such a huge success and will continue this path in the face of this turmoil and outrage.

  3. Jen Graves should do her research before “reporting”. Adria is a stand up gal who’s been a fashion icon in Seattle for as long as she’s been here. Indian Summer is the best thing to happen to the vintage market in this city, and her window display is refreshing among the mundane displays we see every day. The fact that it’s a reflection of her heritage makes it even more special, and to call it “racist” or even “cute” is offensive. I hope that Jen has the decency to write Adria an apology. She’ll want to when she realizes how amazing her store really is.

  4. Jen Graves should do her research before “reporting”. Adria is a stand up gal who’s been a fashion icon in Seattle for as long as she’s been here. Indian Summer is the best thing to happen to the vintage market in this city, and her window display is refreshing among the mundane displays we see every day. The fact that it’s a reflection of her heritage makes it even more special, and to call it “racist” or even “cute” is offensive. I hope that Jen has the decency to write Adria an apology. She’ll want to when she realizes how amazing her store really is.

  5. I am outraged that Graves is in a position to voice such flagrantly arrogant ignorance in such a dangerously persuasive forum. She ought to be ashamed and so should The Stranger for allowing this kind of media representation to influence the reputation of the magazine. Adria has created an exquisite store front for Indian Summer that reflects a deeply personal homage to her family, American history/culture, and who she is. Once inside you find yourself immersed in a beautiful world created by Adria’s acute eye and ability to display and honor all things esthetically pleasing. How dare Graves poison fashion, art and expression with her narrow minded and lazy quips. How dare she make such extreme accusations that lack an ounce of knowledge or research on her target. How dare she publicize and nurture the continuation of racial and cultural intolerance. I am mortified and deeply saddened.

  6. I am outraged that Graves is in a position to voice such flagrantly arrogant ignorance in such a dangerously persuasive forum. She ought to be ashamed and so should The Stranger for allowing this kind of media representation to influence the reputation of the magazine. Adria has created an exquisite store front for Indian Summer that reflects a deeply personal homage to her family, American history/culture, and who she is. Once inside you find yourself immersed in a beautiful world created by Adria’s acute eye and ability to display and honor all things esthetically pleasing. How dare Graves poison fashion, art and expression with her narrow minded and lazy quips. How dare she make such extreme accusations that lack an ounce of knowledge or research on her target. How dare she publicize and nurture the continuation of racial and cultural intolerance. I am mortified and deeply saddened.

  7. jeez, Jen I hear you. This is getting out of control.

    I just discovered this painter, uh, Frida Kahlo, who used Mexican kitsch in the most offensive manner.

    Yeah, and there’s this singer Buffy Sainte-Marie who tries to position herself as having a native perspective and uses it to critique American culture.

    Oh, and there’s this guy Tupac Shakur who really took advantage of black culture and exploited it to his benefit.

    Also I don’t know if you heard of this guy Dan Savage who is appropriating queer culture and claiming to have empathy for the political struggles of queer people.

    I just don’t know where these people get off!!!! Enough of these white, mono-culture assholes trying to assert minority opinions and perspectives as if they belong to these far-out cultures that only exist outside of the Northwest.

  8. I am outraged that Graves is in a position to voice such flagrantly arrogant ignorance in such a dangerously persuasive forum. She ought to be ashamed and so should The Stranger for allowing this kind of media representation to influence the reputation of the magazine. Adria has created an exquisite store front for Indian Summer that reflects a deeply personal homage to her family, American history/culture, and who she is. Once inside you find yourself immersed in a beautiful world created by Adria’s acute eye and ability to display and honor all things esthetically pleasing. How dare Graves poison fashion, art and expression with her narrow minded and lazy quips. How dare she make such extreme accusations that lack an ounce of knowledge or research on her target. How dare she publicize and nurture the continuation of racial and cultural intolerance. I am mortified and deeply saddened.

  9. Adria’s store is fucking awesome, fact.

    Jen Graves is racist?! not fact.

    I don’t think there’s any reason to get personal, I don’t think Jen is actually calling anyone racist. If the SLOG has one fault, it’s to make quick general snap-judgement posts that are meant to provoke and get reactions. Hell, I reacted. And yes it was a mistake to not talk to the store owner so say that, because it’s a fact, too.

    But man, people, there are bigger issues to talk about, if we’re actually going to talk.

    I guess this is in the end, a blog post, and not an actual discussion. What a pity. :/

  10. more typical elitist art snob asswipe ~ aimed this time, at my ‘little sister’ whom happens to be a great artist musician. if the critic got around a bit, she might know this, or have read my two page color spread on adria in an ‘alternative’ publication. and maybe write about her and others like adria. jen graves also has never written about the late first nation artist john t williams, as far as i know, kinda alludes to him, but not really. because apparently these people don’t qualify in the little circle jerk of the seattle “artiste” clique. ish. clark weigman was the only person that i know of in the arts community that even gave a shout out about john t. williams. all the rest of the scenesters were opening their martini bars and the like. social consciousness? kma!
    masturbating the grants world people, and criticizing people that remain ‘outsiders’ at your critics table, yecch. this is one of the main reasons why i dread the bullshit kiss-ass seattle art world and the people that suck up to people like graves.
    john raymond ulkoniemi stevens berry~ and i am a celtic viking.

  11. more typical elitist art snob asswipe ~ aimed this time, at my ‘little sister’ whom happens to be a great artist musician. if the critic got around a bit, she might know this, or have read my two page color spread on adria in an ‘alternative’ publication. and maybe write about her and others like adria. jen graves also has never written about the late first nation artist john t williams, as far as i know, kinda alludes to him, but not really. because apparently these people don’t qualify in the little circle jerk of the seattle “artiste” clique. ish. clark weigman was the only person that i know of in the arts community that even gave a shout out about john t. williams. all the rest of the scenesters were opening their martini bars and the like. social consciousness? kma!
    masturbating the grants world people, and criticizing people that remain ‘outsiders’ at your critics table, yecch. this is one of the main reasons why i dread the bullshit kiss-ass seattle art world and the people that suck up to people like graves.
    john raymond ulkoniemi stevens berry~ and i am a celtic viking.

  12. more typical elitist art snob asswipe ~ aimed this time, at my ‘little sister’ whom happens to be a great artist musician. if the critic got around a bit, she might know this, or have read my two page color spread on adria in an ‘alternative’ publication. and maybe write about her and others like adria. jen graves also has never written about the late first nation artist john t williams, as far as i know, kinda alludes to him, but not really. because apparently these people don’t qualify in the little circle jerk of the seattle “artiste” clique. ish. clark weigman was the only person that i know of in the arts community that even gave a shout out about john t. williams. all the rest of the scenesters were opening their martini bars and the like. social consciousness? kma!
    masturbating the grants world people, and criticizing people that remain ‘outsiders’ at your critics table, yecch. this is one of the main reasons why i dread the bullshit kiss-ass seattle art world and the people that suck up to people like graves.
    john raymond ulkoniemi stevens berry~ and i am a celtic viking.

  13. it’s very disappointing to see jen posting things like this without doing any actual research. the shop owner is native and accusations of racism should NOT be thrown around lightly. if not libelous, this is at least VERY misleading.

  14. it’s very disappointing to see jen posting things like this without doing any actual research. the shop owner is native and accusations of racism should NOT be thrown around lightly. if not libelous, this is at least VERY misleading.

  15. @ 62 – is jen graves expressing racism in this case? YES! 100% in my book. to SO QUICKLY be willing to reference what’s obviously an art piece, one that confronts and addresses cultural divides no less, as either cute or racist is so fucking unacceptable, it’s just foul. to even mention adria’s art in connection with the murder of any person is irresponsible, sick, and sensationalistic in this case. that jen graves made HUGE assumptions that hurt and harmed another person in relation to their own cultural and ethnic identity is totally racist. try to imagine what it might feel like to have someone (a reporter no less) comment so horribly and inaccurately (in a public format no less) about a piece of art that is so personal to your cultural identity? does it feel racist? how about when you experience similar crap from white seattleites all the time and this time it has the potential to impact A) how people you don’t even know feel about you and B) your new business? does it feel like an attack on your ability to voice your sense of cultural/ethic identity with some semblance of responsible social discourse from your local “alternative” media? does it feel racist? you said there is no reason to get “personal” – is that very much what jen graves just did? these are very personal topics, hence the requirement for a reporter to inquire about the artist before posting her BS. to not do so is not just shitty reporting and libelous, but also racist.

  16. Oh, Ms. Graves. How nice of you to incite the masses against a business just recently opened by a Taino tribeswoman whose window display is meant as a celebration of her Native American heritage. Was that your intent or just the result of an utter lack of journalistic method and ethics? Shame on you.

  17. In light of recent events, the word “racist” does not sit well with anyone in the Seattle area.

    Secondly, I am CERTAIN that Adria (who is Indian) had no intentions of putting racist vibes in her window.

    We are in a fucking recession and this is how Jen Graves supports her community? Bashing on a new business that will bring more love, tolerance and wonderful fashion at an AFFORDABLE PRICE! Who’s to argue with that?

    Perhaps Jen is just jealous because her big ass head cannot fit into the “Hipster Headdress”

    (can you even put the word “hipster” next to headdress?

  18. Is part of being Native the inability to correctly post in a comment thread or are you all posting the same posts over an over because you have-um heap firewater?

  19. Adrian is a beautiful Italian-American woman who did the right thing by marrying Rocky Balboa! Just because she is a shy person doesn’t mean that she isn’t a crucial source of love and support for her family, even including her good-for-nothing brother Paulie! I think it’s a terrible shame the way Jen accuses her of having mafia connections and promoting the use of garlic, and she should be fired from a cannon! Or at least fired from the editorial board of the Renton Reporter! Damn!

  20. @StaggerLee

    I’m not sure if you saw my initial lengthy reply above, but in it I was rather angry that this was even a debate, due to the larger issues at hand having to do with politics (or I should say the notable lack thereof) surrounding Native Americans in this country. I also said later on facebook I thought it was wrong for Jen to not at least go into the store to find out the story.

    But ultimately, all this is missing a much larger point.

    While there may be an indirect implication that Adria is racist – which she obviously is not — I see this post as more of a glib, hasty, smart aleck-y poll and unfair generalisation. I also felt that Jen was more accusing the people who might be supposedly “appropriating” this fashion as the racists, not the seller of these fashions.

    At the end of the day, I think it’s a ridiculous discussion. Why are we arguing about whether people, Native or not, should wear or sell Native dress? Why does it even fucking matter? Shouldn’t we be mad about an entirely different set of political racist issues such as poverty, failing economies and education systems on the Res and the homogenization of Native cultures?

    Yes, racism is personal. Yes, this post was inflammatory. Obviously. And yes I stand with Adria in her right and artistic freedom and celebrate her shop – I’ve been a supporter from the start!

    But for all the yelling about stuff in these comments, people don’t seem to get anywhere near as righteously upset about the things that get swept under the rug.

    So thanks but I don’t have to imagine. Speaking as a part-Native, it’s what pisses me off most.

  21. you are absolutely correct all this is missing a much larger point – were jen behaving like an ACTUAL reporter, she would have entered the store, inquired about the storefront, and HEARD a great deal of critique of “an entirely different set of political racist issues such as poverty, failing economies and education systems on the Res and the homogenization of Native cultures”. i know from personal experience that adria cares a great deal about the larger issues at hand. jen could’ve and would’ve opened a wonderful door to do some reporting on how these larger issues get swept under the rug and how adria’s artwork is a part of her response to these larger issues. for myself, i have been an activist since i was fairly young and have spent plenty of time working directly on these issues. i would love to see a public discussion of any of the above and especially tack on some discussion of environmental racism and injustice – perhaps we can all request that as a response to her horrible behavior and slanderous reporting, the stranger requires that jen report on those issues for a period of time…

  22. Wow. Having a hard news day? I’m sure that your morning was incredibly boring if this is article you are posting. Well, you did a good job at attracting attention didn’t you? I bet some people are gonna check out INDIAN SUMMER at 534 Summit Ave E
    (between Republican St & Mercer St)
    Seattle, WA 98102
    Neighborhood: Capitol Hill
    (206) 588-0717
    tinyurl.com/indiansummer4ever (Run by Adria Garcia, call for hours)

    Just because of that thought provoking article. but seriously, they should.

    Adria is an amazing genuinely genius clothing picker and collector. She is a fashion queen. She has been doing it for 10+ years and in addition to writing for style magazines, dressing models and a ton of other cool fashion based stuff she is also a Native American. That’s her headdress. Get off it dudes.

    And for an amazing vintage collection like the one at Indian Summer??? It’s super reasonable priced. My friend bought the cutest vintage cocktail dress there for 40 dollars. in perfect condition and so fancy- fucking beautiful! I wish I had a picture.

    I got a green tie dyed t-shirt with a fucking cobra on it! Fuck you! or not.

    Wearing accessories is a good way to show your individuality.

  23. Seems to me like Jen Graves recklessly accused a business owner of racism without bothering to approach the woman or do the slightest bit of investigation. I’ve never heard of Ms. Graves before. Does she consider herself a journalist?

    What I do know is that Adria Garcia is a talented, conscientious, creative new business owner whose enterprise appears to have been slandered.

    There are many productive conversations that can come from Ms. Graves poor choice to post such a weak poll question: ones about tribal identity and rights; art and self expression; racism in capitalism, etc.

    And, I hope these conversations happen. But, not at the cost of any business for Adria. Check out the store, folks. It’s awesome! And, so is Adria.

  24. The author of this article in The Stranger is clearly a writer and not a journalist, certainly not an investigative journalist because one peek into the new Indian Summer vintage clothing & accessories store would have revealed the beautiful brown-skinned owner… an instant clue that possibly, just possibly the window display wasn’t done for ‘hipster’ appeal, but rather a cultural expression through fashion, the manner in which the fabulous artist, Adria, expresses herself.

    To me, if the term ‘racist’ is going to be thrown around, shouldn’t we consider that Jen Graves is racist for assuming the owner of the shop was a white, suburban hipster? Is it so unthinkable that a Taino woman could be the owner of a business??

    A writer can write anything they want, a journalist would have been required to do some investigating and provide facts, Jen Graves is a writer who just tossed out a careless, stupid comment without doing any homework and it hurt a very nice young lady’s feelings. Jen should do some sort of follow-up… an apology, a retraction, a true and accurate story. How many people may never shop at this store because just 2 weeks after opening, some thoughtless ignoramus makes disparaging remarks?

    To the person who asked if we should call someone Indian or Native American or Aboriginal etc., this is what I know to be PC: Native American is for tribes from the USA – those who were here first (native) before it was even called the USA. Indian is a name that is commonly understood to refer to Native Peoples, but is a misnomer given by Columbus when he mistakenly thought he had landed in India, but was in the Caribbean. As a result, when you hear the word Indian used to define someone, clarification is often asked for by someone asking “feather or dot” to distinguish between the two. The indigenous Taino people of the Caribbean and all the other countries of ‘the Americas’ have been stuck being referred to by the name Indian causing 500+ years of confusion. Canada refers to their Native population as “First Peoples”, Australia refers to their Native population as “Aboriginal”. But in my experience, most Native people prefer to be referred to by their tribal affiliation.

    Adria is Taino. To those who have known her for a long time, she had a Taino wedding ceremony and wore a headdress at her wedding. Her father is Taino and her mother is Irish/German from a long line of men who have served in the military. She had every right to do an artistic display that reflects who she is and shame on Jen Graves for passing judgement without doing even the teensiest bit of background check. The rest of us would lose our jobs if that was how we performed our duties… why does she get a pass?

  25. The author of this article in The Stranger is clearly a writer and not a journalist, certainly not an investigative journalist because one peek into the new Indian Summer vintage clothing & accessories store would have revealed the beautiful brown-skinned owner… an instant clue that possibly, just possibly the window display wasn’t done for ‘hipster’ appeal, but rather a cultural expression through fashion, the manner in which the fabulous artist, Adria, expresses herself.

    To me, if the term ‘racist’ is going to be thrown around, shouldn’t we consider that Jen Graves is racist for assuming the owner of the shop was a white, suburban hipster? Is it so unthinkable that a Taino woman could be the owner of a business??

    A writer can write anything they want, a journalist would have been required to do some investigating and provide facts, Jen Graves is a writer who just tossed out a careless, stupid comment without doing any homework and it hurt a very nice young lady’s feelings. Jen should do some sort of follow-up… an apology, a retraction, a true and accurate story. How many people may never shop at this store because just 2 weeks after opening, some thoughtless ignoramus makes disparaging remarks?

    To the person who asked if we should call someone Indian or Native American or Aboriginal etc., this is what I know to be PC: Native American is for tribes from the USA – those who were here first (native) before it was even called the USA. Indian is a name that is commonly understood to refer to Native Peoples, but is a misnomer given by Columbus when he mistakenly thought he had landed in India, but was in the Caribbean. As a result, when you hear the word Indian used to define someone, clarification is often asked for by someone asking “feather or dot” to distinguish between the two. The indigenous Taino people of the Caribbean and all the other countries of ‘the Americas’ have been stuck being referred to by the name Indian causing 500+ years of confusion. Canada refers to their Native population as “First Peoples”, Australia refers to their Native population as “Aboriginal”. But in my experience, most Native people prefer to be referred to by their tribal affiliation.

    Adria is Taino. To those who have known her for a long time, she had a Taino wedding ceremony and wore a headdress at her wedding. Her father is Taino and her mother is Irish/German from a long line of men who have served in the military. She had every right to do an artistic display that reflects who she is and shame on Jen Graves for passing judgement without doing even the teensiest bit of background check. The rest of us would lose our jobs if that was how we performed our duties… why does she get a pass?

  26. I agree. Jen Graves should definitely write a retraction and apology. Maybe she could give it the headline “I Am Sorry, or Reckless Whiteness Rides Again” and post it at 9:15 AM on Friday.

  27. how about we cut a deal with the hipsters: they can wear these fashions without shame/ridicule IF they donate the equivalent amount of $ to help Native Americans get things like running water on the res, and write at least one letter to a congressperson concerning advancing Native American rights.

  28. it’s funny how jen graves loves to rag on fashion, but it way too pussy to criticize all the shitty artists in seattle because she is too afraid to run into them. haha!

    adria’s store is fucking awesome, maybe jen graves is just jealous because she has no fucking style.

  29. We should never forget what our ancestors did nor repeat mistakes of the past, but to blame someone (whatever creed, culture, or color) for something a completely different individual did is rediculous. material objects are material objects are material objects, people dont try and be offensive when wearing something ethnic. I love ornate ethnic things and respect the cultures they came from, and as one human being to another you are not to tell me what i am or am not allowed to wear, we are all children of the earth and when we die we all become the same energy. like all other fads; it will pass, dont be such a stick in the mud, let it go and move on. you cant grow when you hold on to grudges no matter how justified they are. as long as it is not used in an offensive way i dont see the problem, not allowing cultures to mix and mingle makes for more separation and prejudice. I am my own person with my own thoughts, i do not operate in a caucasian beehive mentality. When you start blaming a race for something you become as bad as them for whatever they did.

  30. We should never forget what our ancestors did nor repeat mistakes of the past, but to blame someone (whatever creed, culture, or color) for something a completely different individual did is rediculous. material objects are material objects are material objects, people dont try and be offensive when wearing something ethnic. I love ornate ethnic things and respect the cultures they came from, and as one human being to another you are not to tell me what i am or am not allowed to wear, we are all children of the earth and when we die we all become the same energy. like all other fads; it will pass, dont be such a stick in the mud, let it go and move on. you cant grow when you hold on to grudges no matter how justified they are. as long as it is not used in an offensive way i dont see the problem, not allowing cultures to mix and mingle makes for more separation and prejudice. I am my own person with my own thoughts, i do not operate in a caucasian beehive mentality. When you start blaming a race for something you become as bad as them for whatever they did.

Comments are closed.