A lot of people are tripping balls over this new study released today claiming that alcohol is more harmful to society than heroin. Let’s go to the graph!

As you can see, the purple bar denotes the harm that’s done to others by the drugs, while the gold bar signifies the harm done to the individual. Putting the two figures together provided researchers with their conclusion that alcohol is more harmful overall than, say, marijuana. (Personally, I think I’m far more in danger of being bored to death by someone smoking marijuana… but I think that info’s for another study.)
It should also be noted that OF COURSE alcohol is the most dangerous since its the most plentiful and illegal legal (not counting smokes). If the world were dotted with meth bars, the graph might tell a different story.
Your thoughts?
No thoughts on this?
None?
Okay. I’ll dig up some Justin Bieber news.

Do you guys not actually work in the same office? I mean, cool study and all, and you had way more commentary, but, uh:
http://slog.thestranger.com/slog/archive…
And no, I will send you my first born to be your personal barista slave if you never post anything about Justin Bieber.
Yeah, I’m surprised to hear that anyone had the balls to publish this – If I’m reading it correctly – which is how you’re reading it Sir Wm.
Of course it is the most harmful! It is by far the most common. That is like saying that cars are more dangerous than motorcycles because more people die in car crashes than motor cycle crashes annually. It’s Alice in Wonderland type data.
I didn’t notice in the other story I read of these “findings” that the report was co-authored by the guy sacked for suggesting pot might not be as bad as Parliament thinks it is. He was right when he originally said it, but this isn’t vindication, this is a bullshit report that assumes 1% of 1,000 is “worse” than 7 out of 10.
Be funny to re-weight this study strictly excluding negatives today brought about by legal issues surrounding drugs–i.e., legal status.
Alcohol is not the most dangerous ONLY because it is more common. You can’t OD (aka alcohol poisoning) or die of liver or heart failure because of marijuana. If pot stores outnumbered bars and liquor stores by 100 to 1 that alcohol would still be a much more dangerous drug for society and for the user.
How can we take this study seriously when they did not rate Jenkem?
SLOG drug addicts want to take our booze away and sell us more crack.
Did you know that Justin Beiber can legally drink in Quebec?
WOO HOO!
Oh wow, man. Now, if only somebody could do something about the crows. They’re freakin’ me out.
This is such a ridiculous study. If crack cocaine were replaced with alcohol in every way it would be clearly more harmful. “Hey Tom, they’ve got a crack happy hour after work, a dollar a rock? Let’s say we go smoke a couple and watch the game!”
This is pretty clearly a snapshot of the current situation, not an assessment of potential harm.
Have a second thought, guys. Fuck.
@5 – I don’t think anyone here would argue the relatively innocuous nature of marijuana—outside of the prohibition aspects of it as a controlled substance, but I think it’s reasonable to scoff at his rationale for trying to convince us crack, meth, and heroin are less harmful substances.
@8, it never ends with you, does it, Will? The legal drinking age in Quebec is 18; Bieber is 16. You are completely wrong, AGAIN.
With your earlier comment about “Slovaks” on the LA Galaxy (there are none), you’re having a pretty bad day even for you.
@5: Uh, they’re not just comparing it to pot. It would also suggest to the casual reader that alcohol is far more dangerous than heroin and meth.
Care to argue that one?
I like that the graph uses the “Husky pride” color scheme. Go dawgs!
@13 in your house.
Man, you are so gullible.
Look at the label on the horizontal axis: “Overall Harm Score.” That should tell you something about the arbitrary nature of this graph. It all depends in how you calculate the harm score. Studies like this always should always raise a red flag because how you calculate the index to compare different phenomena has a huge impact on the results.
Isn’t meth as easily obtainable as pot? And yet more people smoke pot than meth.
I think hard drugs are just gross to most people who aren’t already fucked up, so it’s doesn’t really matter if their illegal or not, as far as consumption goes.
@17 you are correct. From the methods of this study “In June, 2010, a meeting under the auspices of the Independent Scientific Committee on Drugs (ISCD)—a new organisation of drug experts independent of government interference—was convened to develop the MCDA model and assess scores for 20 representative drugs that are relevant to the UK and which span the range of potential harms and extent of use. The expert group was formed from the ISCD expert committee plus two external experts with specialist knowledge of legal highs”
And
“The group scored each drug on each harm criterion in an open discussion and then assessed the relative importance of the criteria within each cluster and across clusters. They also reviewed the criteria and the definitions developed by the ACMD. This method resulted in a common unit of harm across all the criteria, from which a new analysis of relative drugs harms was achieved.”
Science by committee, and frankly, as a scientist, I’m not sure how I feel about that. I’ll have to reread the article.
The lancet is a weekly journal, it will be interesting to see the response letters next week
How the fuck is Butane a drug?
First of all, why would you sit around and watch someone smoke weed? Of course that’s boring. That’s why you JOIN them. Second of all, I don’t understand how a lot of these drugs are harmful to other people (Benziduazepines? LSD? But not mushrooms or ecstasy??). Third of all, I don’t see caffeine on the list of harmful drugs.
Clearly the only safe thing to do is take mushrooms–safer than breathing the air.
I think the main reason alchohol is ranked the highest is because it is the most available.
But a british study done a few years ago (and the BBC program, ‘the most dangerous drugs in britain) made a similar claim…alcohol was not the *most* dangerous, but it was right up there with heroin and crack, and way ahead of shrooms, pot, and LSD.
Somehow I don’t think the “harm to others” part of the marijuana bar takes into account the ongoing bloodbath in Mexico.
#18 – maybe things are different out west, or maybe I just run with the wrong crowd, but while I know at least 3 or 4 dependable pot dealers, I wouldn’t have the slightest idea where or how to get my hands on some meth. I guess I could ask around, but….seems like pot is a lot easier to get.
#24 – the bloodbath in Mexico is due to lots of things, most notably the currently illegal status of drugs. Not the drugs themselves, certainly not marijuana. That’s like saying the St. Valentine’s Day massacre was caused by alcohol.
….and I can always grow my own weed. Wouldn’t try to make my own meth unless I was willing to risk blowing myself up.
If you separate the ‘harm to users’ and ‘harm to others’ then it shows that alcohol is less harmful than crack & meth, to the user. Take the ‘harm to others’ into affect and that is what makes alcohol more harmful than the others.
rough estimate based on the graph: alcohol harm to self: ~26, heroin harm to self: ~33.
alcohol harm to others: ~45, heroin harm to others: ~22
What exactly is the nature of the harm to others by ecstasy? That they might accidentally whack you in the face when spinning in a circle on the dance floor? Raw spots from too much back rubbing? excessive dry humping?