To provide the best experiences, we use technologies like cookies to store and/or access device information. Consenting to these technologies will allow us to process data such as browsing behavior or unique IDs on this site. Not consenting or withdrawing consent, may adversely affect certain features and functions.
The technical storage or access is strictly necessary for the legitimate purpose of enabling the use of a specific service explicitly requested by the subscriber or user, or for the sole purpose of carrying out the transmission of a communication over an electronic communications network.
The technical storage or access is necessary for the legitimate purpose of storing preferences that are not requested by the subscriber or user.
The technical storage or access that is used exclusively for statistical purposes.
The technical storage or access that is used exclusively for anonymous statistical purposes. Without a subpoena, voluntary compliance on the part of your Internet Service Provider, or additional records from a third party, information stored or retrieved for this purpose alone cannot usually be used to identify you.
The technical storage or access is required to create user profiles to send advertising, or to track the user on a website or across several websites for similar marketing purposes.
Do they still rock those dress whites? I can’t conjure a more delightful scenario than a big gay Navy wedding (hopefully taking place aboard the USS Maine, with Cher being heavily featured in the reception song list). I bet the fundies get apoplectic at the thought, which is just gravy.
I thought DADT was already repealed?
http://www.whitehouse.gov/photos-and-vid…
This is strange, since I thought bases were considered federal property and not subject to state laws (a real bonus when you’re living somewhere with draconian liquor store laws). If they are following local laws the civil unions/marriages are probably only as legally valid as they would be off base.
Reading the article it looks like conservatives are making the federal property argument against this, and while I think DOMA is odious and should be repealed, I suspect they’re probably right that an on-base wedding policy is a strange contradiction with DOMA; this is a nice perk and all, but the more important issue is that these marriages won’t be considered valid by the Navy itself, which is forbidden by federal law from recognizing these relationships. So, sailors legally married to people of the same sex are considered single in the eyes of the military, which has all kinds of unfortunate consequences for when the Navy moves them to be stationed elsewhere. An extra wedding venue is nice; equal rights would be a whole lot better.
sadly, @3 probably has a point.
I loved this part of the article:
“This new guidance from the Navy clearly violates the law,” Rep. Todd Akin, R-Mo., chairman of the House Armed Services seapower subcommittee, said in a statement Monday. “While our president may not like this law, it is unbelievable that our Navy would issue guidance that clearly violates this law.”
If you can’t count on your president to be a bigot, and you can’t count on your Navy to be bigoted, then who can you count on? The abandonment bigots must be feeling right now is surely overwhelming.
Maybe the Republicans should go crying to Fred Phelps.
@3 – I don’t think they can. The Navy’s not endorsing same-sex marriage. It’s merely permitting valid state law to be carried out. If Navy chaplains can perform religious ceremonies (i.e., hetero religious marriage ceremonies, baptism, etc) on federal land without violating the Establishment Clause, it shouldn’t be a problem to perform same-sex marriages. It’s like renting out space in a public park – can’t dictate what groups can and can’t use public land. As long as it’s not violating the still-in-place-although-repealed DADT (which, I suspect it is), DOMA shouldn’t be a problem.
…in the Navy…
The Navy won’t be issuing legal marriage licenses for gay couples any more than they currently do for straight couples. They will simply be providing a venue and a chaplain. Just like the minister/priest at a civilian church now does. In either case, the actual legal marriage license (or Civil Union or Domestic Partner document) will be issued by whatever state the base is located in.
I spent most of my enlistment stationed in California 20 years ago. When guys (and back then it was 95% guys) got married on base by the base chaplain, they were actually issued a marriage license by the state of California. I assume this same arrangement would prevail in gay marriages/civil unions/domestic partnerships.
Good — now I can marry that Navy SEAL from the NYT photo that Dan posted last week. Sure, I only saw his back and I’d have to convince him of this, but hell, anything close to marriage equality felt just as unlikely to me as a possibility not so many years ago.
(I’d also have to convince my current partner that it was a good idea, but I’m fairly sure he’d be cool with it.)
@3 – so, if your line of thinking is correct, a straight couple married in a base chapel stateside, is married per the laws of the federal government?
Remember – the federal government (prior to DOMA) always left the qualifications for marriage up to the states. If the marriage in a base chapel is valid in the state in which it’s performed, it’s valid. No federal territorial issues here.
Speaking from the experience of our Quaker Meeting here in Brooklyn, I can tell you that religious marriage ceremonies and legally-recognized marriage are not the same thing. We equally conduct/celebrate/witness straight and gay marriages within the sanctity of our religion, without discrimination or distinction. We’re still waiting for our state to catch up to us, but meanwhile everyone who chooses to marry in our Meeting gets an impressive-looking certificate, witnessed by members of our Meeting, suitable for framing, and our Meeting honors and treats them as married couples.
We’re one religious denomination which suffers discrimination, because the government won’t recognize our big, gay wedding certificates.
But, military chaplains have to represent all religions, so if a gay couple wanted to marry in the Navy, just point to the liberal side of the Quakers, and there you go, legal or otherwise.
Isn’t there an old saying, “If the Marines had wanted you to have a gay life-partner, we would have issued you one,”?
@13: Close. The actual saying is: “If God wanted men to fuck each other, he’d have given them assholes.”
What, am I the *only* one here who immediately thinks of the Village People when the topic of gays in the Navy comes up?
@11: From what I’ve been able to find out the marriage license is indeed issued by the state. So I guess it would be local laws, but it seems so strange to my non-lawyer self that in some cases the base is not subject to the laws of the state, but in this it clearly is.
But if I can buy liquor without being overcharged at a state-run store and the gays get to have on-base weddings, I suppose it’s the best of both worlds.