Amanda Marcotte:

[When] anti-choicers suck it up and try to pretend like they care about women, they do a poor job of it. Anti-choicers tend to pass around lists of what they claim are the negative effects on women of abortion (which are invariably disproved by real science), but their reaction to these beliefs doesn’t resemble how you would actually react if you believed these things and were concerned about women.

For instance, anti-choicers claim to believe that abortion causes mental health problems in women. There is no scientific evidence for this, of course, but if you did really believe that and were concerned about women, you wouldn’t react by wanting to drive abortion underground, where the mental health effects would be compounded. You would instead demand free contraception for all, comprehensive sex education, of course. But more than that, you would be demanding research to make sure the correlation that you claim exists is causal, or if it’s reflecting something else. If you cared about women’s mental health, you would demand federal funding for family planning clinics to do mental health screenings. If you cared about women’s mental health, you would worry about the scientifically established link between giving birth and developing mental illness. Instead, we get crickets from anti-choicers.

Go read the whole thing. Via Atrios.

42 replies on “What She Said”

  1. The moral case against slaughtering innocent babies really doesn’t depend on fondness, feigned or otherwise, for the women who want to kill their children.

  2. “… link between giving birth and developing mental illness….”

    that’s easy to fix-
    don’t get pregnant if you don’t want to give birth and reap the inevitable debilitating mental illnesses…

  3. I am so glad to see women are using the term “anti-choice” and “pro-choice” again. Sometime in the 90s, everyone (including the media) picked up on and blindly repeated the anti-choice message, and began calling them “Pro-Life” and calling us Pro-Abortion—and it’s bullshit. It’s heartening and inspiring to see women are taking this issue seriously again after so many years of being bullied.

  4. @2 – You forget (or don’t care) that someone women do not have that choice. Some women, and this may shock you, get pregnant because they’ve been raped. So no, it isn’t “easy to fix.”

    Your response aligns perfectly with the gist of this article; You offer no solution, and when it comes down to it, you couldn’t give a flying fuck about the health of women.

  5. A very rational point. However, anti-choicers don’t simply want to eliminate choice. They want to restructure the entire society so that there is no premarital sex and no unwanted pregnancies. That’s some grand scale crazy. So it’s a mistake to take issue with a single item on their agenda in isolation from the big picture.

  6. Period Troll@2’s comment inspired me to finally make the donation to Planned Parenthood I’d been planning to make.

  7. Not that any of this will stop the ignorant, the hypocritical or the flat-out religious zealots – they want women subjugated, reduced to the level of breeding stock, and they won’t be satisfied until they’ve turned their patriarchal wet-dream into a reality.

    Because, it’s pretty clear to the rest of us that their faux-piety and “respect for life”, is merely a sham, a moralistic flim-flam. They don’t respect “life”; if they DID they’d oppose a capital punishment system that executes the innocent alongside the guilty, they’d strive to feed the starving and heal the sick, they’d demand an end to unjust and unprovoked military actions, they’d fight against the oppression and subjugation of innocent civilian populations by despotic governments – but they do none of these things. In point of fact, many tacitly – heck, many actively and proudly – express unabashed support for politicians whose philosophies and policies fly in the face of what ANY reasonable person could characterize as a “pro-life” position.

    They don’t care one whit about “life”; all they care about is control.

  8. Interestingly enough, a prominent Pro-Life Congressman from NJ recently criticized NGOs for “highjacking” the issue of maternal health for their secret pro-abortion agenda. (I took this to be at least partially aimed at Amnesty Interntional’s Demand Dignity campaign.)

  9. @4

    you are so right.
    0.1% of abortions are rape related.
    Zero point One…
    We will gladly support abortion in cases of rape if you will support protecting the life of the baby in abortions of convenience.

    Deal?

  10. @7 COMTE
    I’d amend that to say that a real pro-lifer would oppose all capital punishment including that of the guilty. All life is worth preserving even if some of it needs to be kept in a cage. It’s the delusion that an error-free system can be found that allows innocent people to be executed.

    I just finished watching “Deadline” which I highly recommend to anyone concerned about justice in America.

  11. 6

    GREAT!

    It’s about time you mooching Liberals quit sucking off the taxpayer teat and started paying for your own babies’ slaughter…

  12. @11 – Oh, don’t worry, I donate to pro-choice politicians too. And next time I do, it’ll be in honor of you. It will give me that extra sense of glee, knowing I’m doing a small bit to help undo the damage that you seek to inflict upon this nation.

  13. @1, 2, 9, 11…

    You FORCED-BIRTH jackasses give two shits less about the life and health of the baby and the mother AFTER the “blessed” event.

    Go to the matresses before the birth…lie, cheat, bamboozle to get the kid born…then??? “Sorry Sarah…you’re on your own.”

    NO healthcare…no pre-natal care for that matter…

    NO childcare…

    NO job….

    NO funding for early education…

    NO funding for schools.

    What a bunch of fucking sanctimonious hypocrites.

  14. 7

    now now now….

    one need not work equally hard on all worthy causes to support some good causes.

    how hard do Liberals work to educate children on the benefits of abstinence? (you know- the only way to 100% protect against STDs and pregnancy….)

    what?

    why, obviously you hypocritical coldblooded bastards WANT to see America’s youth catch AIDS and have babies that will die abused before they’re a year old…

  15. I want to know who’s going to be taking care of all these unwanted children if anti-choicers get their way. It sure as hell won’t be me.

  16. @16…

    …did shithead even READ the article????

    Try this one:

    http://law.bepress.com/cgi/viewcontent.c…

    Abstinence-only Adolescent Education: Ineffective, Unpopular and Unconstitutional
    James J. McGrath, Appalachian School of Law

    Download the Paper | Tell a Colleague | Printing Tips Abstract

    This article examines the recent changes in the funding of “abstinence only” educational programs that attempt to reduce the incidence of teen pregnancy and sexually transmitted diseases. Although funding for these programs was previously ruled to be facially constitutional, this is no longer the case as their lack of efficacy for their stated purpose has been exposed. Newer programs are in direct violation of unconstitutional conditions doctrine, and none of these programs address a significant segment of the student population, lesbian and gay students. My article addresses this oversight as dangerous public health policy as well as a potential constitutional violation in light of the recent Lawrence v. Texas ruling, which struck down the remaining sodomy laws.

    Recommended Citation
    James J. McGrath, “Abstinence-only Adolescent Education: Ineffective, Unpopular and Unconstitutional” (February 29, 2004). bepress Legal Series. Working Paper 150.
    http://law.bepress.com/expresso/eps/150

  17. 17

    OK slick, we have a policy against feeding trolls but we’ll make an exception-
    Some folks believe it is individuals’ responsibility to educate themselves and get a decent job and provide for themselves.
    They don’t see it as the government’s job to raise your kids and pay your doctor bills and wipe your lazy shitty ass…
    So, when those folks object to you slaughtering your babies they don’t feel compelled to also take you on to raise.
    Of course, you are free to present your ideas in the marketplace of ideas and convince your fellow voters to enact the nanny state you want.
    (too bad they’re figuring out that that path leads/has lead to bancruptcy and ruin….)

  18. 20

    goodness, did you even read the post? shit. head?

    no one said anything about abstinence ‘only’

    are you calling Danny a Liar?

    cause he’s posted government studies that show that including abstinence in sex ed gives better results than sex ed without abstinence.

  19. 10

    not really.

    how much is the life of an innocent murdered person worth?

    20 years in prison?

    30?

    hell no.

    because we value life we expect a just price be paid for taking an innocent life.

    the life of a scumbag murderer actually doesn’t make it even but we’ll settle for it….

  20. http://www.americablog.com/2011/06/catho…

    Catholic Charities abandons needy kids in order to take another swipe at gays. Kick them out of CHN.

    by John Aravosis (DC) on 6/02/2011 11:51:00 AM

    Candy Hill, bigot
    Someone needs to start a movement to kick Catholic Charities out of every progressive coalition they’re in. For example, what is a bigoted organization, an organization that would let poor children suffer, doing on the board of director of the Coalition on Human Needs, a liberal advocacy group that includes some of the biggest progressive organizations in Washington? Yet there she is, Candy Hill of Catholic Charities, on the board of CHN.

    I wonder if the Coalition on Human Needs would permit a racist organization to be a board member. Or is anti-gay animus somehow less offensive to the Coalition on Human Needs?

    Catholic Charities is now stopping its foster care/adoption services in Illinois because the state passed a law permitting civil unions in the state. Rather than run the risk of having to let a disgusting, perverted inter-racial gay couple adopt, Catholic Charities will simply abandon all children at risk in Rockville, IL, just like they did in Washington, DC.

    More right-wing christianist goodness. Yumyum.

  21. I purposefully fuck pro-choice girls without protection & hope they get pregnant just so I can murder a baby! nah, I just like the way it feels. Oh and its not a baby. Its a blob of cells with no consciousness. Its equivalent to yanking a carrot out of the ground.

  22. I’m anti-abortion, and think that abortion is a bad thing. It’s traumatic to the mother, destroys an embryo, and costs people money. Of course, illegalizing abortion would only make the problem far worse, and I believe that it’s a woman’s right to decide what grows in her uterus.
    If you really want to reduce the number of abortions, you’ll stop pushing abstinence and support comprehensive sex ed, which encourages abstinence but teaches shaft-wrapping.
    Alleged is trolling hard today, and doesn’t really care about the issue. If you reply to his bullshit, I will fly into your kitchen tonight and make a mess of your pots and pans.

  23. If you really want to reduce the number of abortions, you’ll start putting the name and SS# of the father on every birth certificate.
    And make sure the IRS docks his ass $300 a month until the kid turns 18. Or docks his parents until he gets a job.
    DNA testing would make it easy.

    Start making males (it would be a travesty to call them ‘men’) responsible for the upkeep of the chiildren they spawn and they will figure out birth control soon enough.

  24. Couldn’t help myself, never posted on the comments before, but you go Rujax!!! Tell those idiot trolls to F off!!!

    I am Pro-Choice. Pro choice for you to choose to either have a baby or not have a baby. Could I *personally* have an abortion??? I don’t know, I haven’t had to make that choice before.

    But I AM a survivor of a violent rape. No protection. I *could* have gotten pregnant. I didn’t, thankfully. But if I *had*, I would want the right to choose. It’s been 5 months since I was raped. ***FIVE*** I am in counseling, I have PTSD, and my life is shit. I’m just *barely* surviving off of my life savings while I try to get the rest of my shit together so that I can get back to the work force and get *some* type of semblance back in my life. I’m doing all of this *without* being pregnant. I CAN NOT imagine the extra amount of pure HELL I would be going through if I was the size of a balloon with my rapist’s little reminder kicking at my bladder. (god. Just writing this is making me shake)

    So. FUCK you, you backwards-ass self-righteous pricks!!! You *haven’t* been raped, you DON’T know what it’s like, and *I* have the GOD DAMN right to make my own fucking choices!!!

    I didn’t get a say when I got raped. I couldn’t stop him, couldn’t fight him off, begging didn’t work and when I started to cry he told me to stop crying. It was the worst and most horrible experience of my entire life. Even worse, I knew him. So yeah, after getting forced onto my back and being hit and having my CHOICE of what to do with my OWN BODY being taken away from me in the most violent, personal and devastating way possible… You want to come in and preach to me about why it’s so fucking important that I CONTINUE to have absolutely NO say in what I can and can’t do with MY body???????

    F-U-C-K Y-O-U.

    When YOU get raped(or your mom, or your sister, or your daughter), YOU can decide then if your precious anti-choice bull is worth the devastation of having no control over what happens to you even after you survive the rape. Fuck you, and go to hell along with that douchebag who attacked me. You guys would be GREAT friends.

    (ugh, I feel sick and i am so pissed and disgusted right now. But thank you pro-choicers for standing up for my rights. It means the world to me. You DO make a difference!!!!!)

  25. I like when anti-choicers talk about taking responsibility for your actions, but then restrict access to contraceptives and abortion services.

  26. I recently found out that my mom had an abortion a few years before I was born. It was on medical grounds, which as I understand it meant that if there was some cancer issue involved and if she went through with the pregnancy she might have died. I don’t know why they decided to let me live, but I do know that my fetushood was full of medical complications and problems.

    It’s strange to think that I may owe my existence to abortion.

  27. @34: Hang in there. I’ve got a friend who’s going through something similar as a result of having been raped (and then blamed for it by her parents). It’s sad that there are people out there who choose not to understand the stories of people like you and her. Best wishes, Survivor.

  28. The best argument I’ve ever read (as seen somewhere on Atrios’s site) to anti-choicers: your house is on fire and you only have time to save yourself plus a) the 2 year old child in the bedroom nearby *or* yourself plus b) the fetus in the test tube in another bedroom nearby. Who / What gets the save?

    Right, the child.

  29. Um, anonymous troll, most of us do support comprehensive sex education that encourages abstinence, especially during the teenage years. But the truth is that most kids will have sex before they turn 18, regardless of what kind of sex ed they get, and it’s only responsible to tell them how to avoid pregnancy and STDs should they choose to have sex. Lessons in protection, testing, and honesty are not only useful when unwed teenagers, but also as adults. Particularly because most people will have sex before they’re married or in a long-term relationship, and most will have sex before they’re 18 (when they’re an immature, hormonal teenager), it’s extremely important to teach kids to have honest conversations and know when and how to protect themselves, even if they choose to wait, because their partner may not have chosen to wait or may not have been as smart in their youth.

    Unlike your ass, who’s probably out protesting health clinics (I know for a fact that my local planned parenthood spends at least 5/6 of their time providing healthcare, since they only offer abortions 1 day a week and are packed each of the 6 days a week they’re open), I actually spend some of my free time working with at-risk youth. While my job is not teaching them about sex (it’s teaching them to dance), we’ve had some conversations, and they’ve helped. The pregnancy rate of the kids in our organization is 1/5 the pregnancy rate of young minorities in the city. We don’t have *official* stats on the STD rate, but anecdotal evidence suggests it’s lower, since these kids talk to us, and very few share concerns about STDs (and they know they’re welcome to since I think every one of the teachers, including me, has taken a student to PP for testing and treatment and held their hand through it all). I feel that I’m lucky to live in a city where it’s perfectly okay to leave a bowl of condoms in the bathroom, no questions asked, and talk frankly with my young charges about the choices they make and how they might impact their life. Honestly, probably because most of our students are young ladies, just talking through things is usually enough to convince them that they don’t need to “run with the trend” of being a “baby mama” at 16…even if they ultimately choose to sleep with the guy, they’re much, much smarter about using protection. Ultimately, simply giving kids something to look forward to goes miles towards promoting abstinence, or at least very safe sex, and lowering pregnancy rates. Even if that something is just an awesome dance recital/competition. And so that’s how I help. You? Oh, preaching from on high? Yeah, kids totally react well to that.

Comments are closed.