David Schmader—former weed columnist and Stranger associate editor—is the author of the solo plays Straight and Letter to Axl, which he’s performed in Seattle and across the US. His latest...

23 replies on “It’s All in a Name (and by “It” I Mean “The Thing That Destroys My Will to Live”)”

  1. There’s nothing wrong with Katniss Everdeen other than the popularity of the books making it well-known to a lot of people. It’s not the sort of airy-fairy ultra-girly bullshit name that Bella Swan is.

    Reminds me of my sordid, mis-spent youth in the early days of the interwebs, when 90% of girls were picking sexy or princess-y nicknames to use online. Ugh.

  2. I haven’t noticed the omnipresence of Katniss that Bella gets. It’s a popular book series–soon to be film series–but doesn’t have that same la-de-da type of adolescent fap fantasy aura around it that leek@4 mentions.

    Plus, Katniss is a fucking badass and could kill us all.

    (I agree Everdeen sucks, though.)

  3. Katniss? Katniss is “okay”? There’s “nothing wrong” with Katniss? Are you people insane? Bella Swan is twee and horrible, but at least it’s a couple of real names, and at least it doesn’t sound like CAT PISS. Katpiss, er, Katniss is the worst fucking thing I’ve ever heard of. I’d rather be named Litterbox Douche Bladder Prolapse.

    Everdeen, is that like Paula Deen?

  4. Yeah,Katniss is a pretty ridiculous name. For me, there was a bit of a logistical problem with it too. I didn’t know anything about The Hunger Games when I read it, so I spent the first chapter (or most of it, anyways) thinking the main character was a boy. Not saying you always have to have gender-specific names, but at least help a reader out in terms of giving other clues about gender.

    I have no real problem with Bella, but “Swan” is just a lazy/obvious last name to give that character (it’s like she’s a duckling, see, but around Edward she’s transforms into a Swan! Or whatever).

  5. @9 Many parents live in a dream world where no one ever thinks of schoolyard puns on their child’s name. Some live in the world where they take payment for naming their child frivolously, like the father of my old school chum Burma Shaver. (100% serious)

  6. The plot for Hunger Games sounds like The Running Man to me, and I don’t think I’d be able to put that image aside and actually get through reading the damn thing. Also, catnip.

  7. Katniss ain’t so bad, and the books had a sorta Margaret-Atwood-for-kids vibe that I kind of liked.

    Bella Swan, on the other hand, is so banal it comes off as parody, only it isn’t, which is actually a perfect description of the entire Twilight series.

  8. Katniss Everdeen sounds like a scifi redneck name.

    Bella Swan sounds like something an 8th grade girl in current redneck America would name herself on Facebook while pretending to be 18.

  9. I haven’t read either of those books, but does Katniss Everdeen bear any resemblance to Bathsheba Everdene, the protagonist of Hardy’s Far from the Madding Crowd?

  10. Bella Swan. Short for Isabella Swan, or “Is a beautiful swan.”

    Every time I think of it, I want Katniss to shoot me through the head with an arrow.

Comments are closed.