The New Yorker has not had a stellar first week of 2011: First they published this blog post, in which Macy Halford misses the point of e-readers and manages to look impossibly stuffy in the process:
When I read a book all the way through to the end, I want the evidence stuffed and mounted on my bookshelf. My suspicion is that people who prefer e-readers use them primarily to read Harlan Coben, and are happy to be able to delete the physical evidence.
What the fuck is wrong with reading Harlan Coben? Are we going to dismiss entire genres of books as unserious, now? I find that hard to believe, since The New Yorker has been lionizing Stephen King for the last decade. The comment section, in which someone proclaims that “Books are for readers. E-readers are for pseudo-readers,” is pretty awesome, too.
And HTMLGiant links to an open letter to The New Yorker about a recent issue being way too man-writer-centric:
I have enclosed the January issue and expect a refund. You may either extend our subscription by one month, or you can replace this issue with a back issue containing a more equitable ratio of male to female voices. I plan to return every issue that contains fewer than five women writers. You tend to publish 13 to 15 writers in each issue; 5 women shouldn’t be that hard.

Since The New Yorker is a weekly, I wonder if this is real.
I also suspect that the power-law curve of ebook purchasing favors the most popular, and most disposable, titles. Regardless of the merits of Dan Brown’s work, how many times does the average purchaser read the tome?
Hate to say it but Halford’s right. My book collection is a prized possession, sitting in multiple bookcases displayed prominently in my living room. Quite apart from the pleasure I get from reading and re-reading the contents, it’s a declaration in large part of who I am, a reader, yes, but also where my loves and interests lie.
Owning a real book is a declaration of self.
If your name were Macy Halford, you’d be impossibly stuffy from an early age.
If somebody wants to read off a screen instead of a paper brick, who cares? Let ’em. If somebody wants to have a home ego-stroking paper mausoleum, that’s their choice. Again, who cares?
Thank you, @3. I haven’t laughed that hard (without shitting myself) in several hours.
@5: That’s a little harsh … Hoarding is a pretty strong human instinct! Served our ancestors well I’m sure. It’s just not very relevant in the age of Walmart and Amazon.com. Okay, it is funny to hear people rationalise themselves 😉
It’s not the Harlan Coben books I wanted to hide, it was when I was reading the Twilight series that I only did it on an e-book. I *really* didn’t want anyone to see I was reading those.
Oh, and if I read Emma Holly or Lauren Dane books on public transportation, those are on some kind of electronic device too, for different reasons. 😉
See, for me, reading is a physical act… it’s not just my eyes scanning words and relaying the meaning. The feel of the page, the physical surroundings all impact my reading experience. I’ve bought ebooks and enjoyed them, but then went back and bought the physical book too. I have a few thousand dollars worth of books lining my walls, and they’re all books I enjoyed and will re-read.
The hard copy books that I bought/received and didn’t enjoy I’ve either donated to libraries or sold to a second hand book seller, and then used the money to buy more books.
So, I can understand the point that possessing the hard copy book matters too… but I’m fairly sure my generation is the last that will really feel that way collectively. The next generation of readers will grow up with as many ebooks as they have hard copy, if not more.
They’re going to learn to read with a whole different set of experiences than the ones I learned to read with.
It’s just different, not bad or wrong.
I really hope the New Yorker completely ignores Anne Hays’s complaint about not enough articles by women, or gives it the type of snide response it deserves. What a totally hollow activist move.
Having a lot of books “displayed” in your living room does not guarantee that you are a reader. . . And if you are a reader, there are other, less self-promoting ways to present yourself. For example, you could be an interesting conversational partner or correspondent.
I will admit to scanning the Table of Contents every time I get an issue of the New Yorker to see if they included a woman writer or not.
Usually they stick one in there somewhere…but it does seem like they tend to follow the general magazine trend of “big important piece” = written by a man and “fun fluffy piece” = written by a woman.
I still enjoy reading it.
I find this argument interesting, as I just received an unsolicited or wanted Kindle for Christmas. First book purchase made by me: total throwaway book that I knew I didn’t really care to own, ever. I was very suspicious that I would really like the e-book experience, and hedged my bet for my first book purchased. The second book I bought? A book I very much wanted to own in print. After reading my throwaway book I realized how much I liked the overall experience of reading a book electronically. Was it the tremendous ability to highlight, record and bookmark parts of the “book” that I can then easily reference later? Yes. Was it my spiffy new pink cover with a built in light? Yes, I will admit. Do I miss beautiful or interesting covers and book jackets I can easily reference? Yes. But after only one book I’m a true believer. I get it now.
I’ve gotten to miss the Kindle app on my phone when I’m reading a paper book. My old eyes can read a back-lit screen on the darkest bus, and besides, it’s hard to read a physical book with one hand, and impossible to turn a page in one single-handed.
(No, no. I’m a smoker, and I like to read on my smoke breaks.)
I don’t have a trophy rack of books at home because I give the ones I like to others to read.
Real readers only read books the way real audiophiles only listen to vinyl.
A book has a tactile sensation to it, a look, a feel, that makes it unique.
I have a copy of The Hobbit that I first read in first grade (1992 or so). It’s a copy from 1973, and it is kicked to shit. Cover half torn off, edges worn thin, pages creased and re-creased.
Every few years, I’ll pull it out and reread it. Now, I could go buy a Kindle and download a copy of The Hobbit for a few bucks, and it’s the same story. But The Kindle – or any E-Reader – is a dead thing, a lump of plastic and metal. If I ever bought one – and I might, at some point – it will just be another gadget cluttering up my desk. Convenient and functional, maybe, but it has no soul to it.
Now, I will say this. If they start putting college textbooks on Kindles, and drop the price accordingly, I will gladly buy one and make sweet, sweet love to that dead hunk of plastic.
@15, actually, college textbooks are a freaking nightmare on a Kindle. It really only works for straight narrative, no notes, no index, no charts or graphs, no nothing except stream of paragraphs. Which is why it is, in fact, most popular for genre fiction (romance, mystery, fantasy, airport thrillers). I’ll bet there are thousands of people who have read more than 500 romance novels on theirs in the last year, for instance.
“Are we going to dismiss entire genres of books as unserious now?”
Well, yeah, they’ve been doing that for ages! Just try and seriously discuss any fantasy or sci-fi novel.
Constant is dead on here, on both of the New Yorker things. I often take issue with stuff he says, so when I actually agree, I like to highlight this. :3
Oh, god[dess][e][s] save me from the ‘Book is a taaaactile expeeerience you guys don’t understand us REAL READERS’ argument. *Please*.
I like books! I like them a lot. Sometimes I like to sit at a café or in my living room chair and read a book.
I also, quite often, travel for a few days or a week at a time. I enjoy reading then, too! But I don’t enjoy carrying four or five books around in order to do so. I take public transit everywhere; often times it can be quite full, because people in my city actually use transit! And while I can do the “one hand holds the bar while the other holds the book” thing, it’s far more comfortable to hold my nook at this point.
I had surgery this morning, and am in bed for a day or two except for when I really have to get up — moving my body hurts like hell. But, from my laptop, I can go to my city’s public library, browse for ebooks, check them out, download them, and put them on my ereader, all without going out of bed.
There are advantages to both. Can we stop acting like it’s some kind of binary switch or all out war, where once you so much as look at a nook or Kindle, you’re banned from ever touching a physical book again?
And finally: “When I read a book all the way through to the end, I want the evidence stuffed and mounted on my bookshelf.” That doesn’t make you a Real Reader™® — that makes you a packrat. I keep books of serious sentimental value, research books/books I need to refer back to, or books I am likely to read again (less than 1% of what I read). The rest get given away, donated, or sold to used bookstores. If I kept everything I read, I wouldn’t have space for anything else.
dd
@16: I got a kindle for xmas, and I see exactly what you mean! I really hope that can be solved, cos giant engineering and reference books are exactly the sort of thing I would love to see the back of. The industry I work in evolves constantly, and to stay fresh you need to buy a couple of these monsters a year. I have a wall of the things now. So many times I’ve been at someone else’s desk, or thinking over a problem at home, and wished I could access a particular page on a particular book.