Screen_shot_2011-02-03_at_1.10.36_PM.png

1. The Penny Arcade panel to the right (full strip here), where a character says he is “raped to sleep by the dickwolves,” has been a consistent source of outrage from feminist sites like Shakespeare’s Sister since August of last year. (A dickwolf is a made-up wolf whose limbs are made out of penises. It has come to stand for rape jokes in general.) In response to the outrage, Penny Arcade made and sold “Dickwolves” t-shirts and pennants. Nerdblogger Courtney Stanton says she was asked to speak at the Penny Arcade-sponsored PAX convention, but turned them down because, as a rape survivor, she felt uncomfortable about the Dickwolves merchandise. Penny Arcade’s cartoonists took down the Dickwolf t-shirts.

This is all pretty standard internet back-and-forth between male and female nerds on the internet. But the response from some Penny Arcade fans since the t-shirts came down has been really repulsive. Via Twitter and e-mail, male Penny Arcade fans have been accusing Stanton of lying about being raped, of not being attractive enough to have been raped, and sending death threats. She has posted photos of common word paths from the threatening e-mails on her TwitPic account. (Recently, the Penny Arcade guys have received threats to their families, too.) A Twitter account named @TeamRAPE (RAPE, here, supposedly stands for Rare Animal PreservE) has been a rallying point for anti-Stanton Penny Arcade fans. And someone else has constructed a Tumblr called Debacle Timeline, which is a seemingly comprehensive account of this entire mess. Back in August, there was a legitimate argument between intelligent parties, but now this whole affair has become an example of how dark and ugly nerd culture can get.

2. Bookshelves of Doom has been all over the weird happenings at Bitch Magazine, which released a list called “The 100 Young Adult Books for the Feminist Reader.” Shortly after launching the list, they removed three books: “We’ve decided to remove these books from the list — Sisters Red because of the victim-blaming scene that was discussed earlier in this post, Tender Morsels because of the way that the book validates (by failing to critique or discuss) characters who use rape as an act of vengeance, and Living Dead Girl because of its triggering nature,” and added three other books. To protest the removal of the three books, five authors asked to be removed from the list. Bitch refused.

Both of these stories are ongoing, and they are both too sad to think about.

92 replies on “Unfortunate Nerd Controversies Come Two at a Time Now”

  1. Ben, they are similar fallacies in terms of relying upon assumptions, but they are not the same, largely for how they rely upon their assumptions. One smuggles the conclusion into the premise, the other relies upon the conclusion for the premise, but does not contain it. If you have to check Wikipedia to back up your use of terms, maybe you shouldn’t be using them in the first place.

    What’s more, causality is not being argued. Reinforcement is.

  2. @50, I know what “begging the question” means. That’s not what I’m doing, as far as I can tell.

    Also, I haven’t said that rape jokes lead to rape culture. In fact, I think I said that they didn’t lead to anything one way or the other, just that they were problematical in light of the way our culture deals with and condones rape. But, hey, thanks for being kind of a dillweed about explaining it to me!

  3. Crap this thread is moving fast!

    @44: I disagree with your comparison of rape with general mayhem. I’ve been beaten, and I’ve been raped and beaten. Personally, given the choice, I’ll take the punch in the face.
    They are not “similar in many ways”. Not at all.
    I think Post Mortem @43 puts it quite well. Censorship isn’t the answer, thoughtful consideration of one’s actions is. And when one chooses to be tasteless, to act as if one is the victim when called out on one’s behavior, is disingenuous. As I said it is interesting that instead of letting it go, Penny Arcade chose to escalate. What, one wonders, is so threatening about one, humor challenged radfem’s opinion?

  4. I’d like to discuss the Bitch thing (even though as a group we don’t seem to care that much?). I’ve basically stopped reading all the Feminist blogs that I used to because inevitably EVERY FUCKING DISCUSSION goes like this: 1.)Author posts 2.) someone says “this triggered me” 3.) someone says “you’re too sensitive” 4.) “you’re not sensitive enough” 5.) author of original post or blog editor apologizes, publicly regrets ever having an opinion, and once again validates our culture of outrage.

    The Penny Arcade thing got out of hand. But Bitch selectively removing some novels and refusing to remove others, is, for lack of a better word, both paternalistic and cowardly.

  5. @55 Maybe I haven’t been exposed to enough of this sort of thing, but if a blogger sets forth a series of harmless recommendations of what to do with leisure time, and then changes it a little, I don’t really see that as something to worry about one way or another.

  6. @51: I’m not sure what you’re saying. My best guess is that you think people should already know everything that they don’t know.

    @52: I actually wasn’t trying to be a dillweed, and I wasn’t directing that comment at you (you can tell by the part at the beginning of it, where I said @47, by which I meant that my comment was directed at comment number 47, which was written by someone who is not you [now I am trying to be a dillweed]). But since we’re breaking out the ad hominems now, I’ll just say check ya later and be done with this thread.

  7. @54 I’m not saying they are the same exact thing. Nor is one instance of rape like another or one instance of assault like another. They are both crimes that can be committed against a person with similarly traumatizing results and they both involve coercion and humiliation. It could even be said that rape is a specific form of violent assault. My reason for comparing the two was that both can be equally as horrible in the eyes of the victim but no one seems to give people who claim that violent jokes cause violence much credence.

    I would claim that the language that actually trivializes rape and violence is usually much more clear (“so and so should be beat and raped,” “the lady deserved to be raped, the politician deserved to be shot,” etc.

  8. @28 No one said rape was funny… but a mythological creature whose every limb is an erect phallus? That’s funny. That’s shirtworthy.

    Hell, now I’ve got my cosplay idea for PAX.

  9. That strip was hilarious IMO because it highlights–as one commenter already explained–how devoid of real morality games can be. Sure, you found another dozen captives along the way, but the quest is already complete when you find five, so the game considers that enough and the others are left to their fate. There’s no way you can help them, hence the punchline. In this case, their fate is the most ridiculous scenario the PA guys could come up with.

    I think of this sort of stuff all the time when I play RPGs; how the denizens of these fictional realms would react if they were real and lived in such a weird place. I think of how the room full of dead orcs will be received by the dwarven scouting party that follows, or what the residents of Novac will think when they find that hotel room completely covered in teddy bears. This strip was written with that mindset, one that Gabe has written about as having, I believe.

    As to the creation of the shirt itself, it’s not in good taste, but then they make a lot of products that their fans clamor for, based on their strips. It’s how they make a living; making products off the strips that people will buy. They wouldn’t have made it if their fans were not wishing to purchase them. I have yet to see the outrage regarding the strip about Gabe sucking off 100 horses because Duke Nukem Forever is going to be made. (“Animal cruelty is not as prevalent in our culture as rape is,” “false equivalency” etc, etc.) I’m with those who call “thought police” on this.

  10. @56: It just seems hypocritical that some titles were removed due to complaints from “radicals” but authors specifically asking to be removed from the list was told that it wasn’t their prerogative…

    This whole Penny Arcade rape joke argument is actually pretty old news. Maybe I’m just burnt out on it already.

  11. @55: It can get that way, yeah. I mean love Shakesville, but I do end up doing a lot of eye rolling from time to time. Less so on Tiger Beatdown and Feministe, and I do love me some Blag Hag. As far as Radfem blogs, I like Rage Against the Man-chine, because 92 isn’t a big baby about dissenting opinions. I’ve taken it to the mat with some of her regulars on porn and BDSM, and she has never once pulled one of my comments.
    Regarding the Bitch kerfuffle, do I agree with how they handled it? No. But it’s their space and it’s their job to deal with the heat their decision draws down on them.

  12. @62 The comic, and the complaint against it is old news. The shirt issue, however, is new.

    The shirt recently disappeared from the PA store without comment. They kept quiet on the matter until they were flooded with e-mails, asking where the shirt went. At that point, Gabe posted a short note saying it was taken down because someone said they wouldn’t speak at Pax if they were selling it.

  13. @59: I, for one, do not argue causality regarding rape jokes and the act of rape. It’s not that explicit. And again, I was not offended by the strip in question. But I think it is useful to examine one’s attitudes on the subject and consider how a pervasive diminishment of an appalling act can lead to it seeming less appalling.
    And I’m afraid we are just going to have to disagree as to whether or not being beaten is as horrifying as being raped.

  14. @58 I was suggesting people shouldn’t use terms they are not familiar with. Lissa in @47 pleasantly pointed out that more people than just you and Wikipedia consider ‘circular argument’ and ‘begging the question’ to be synonyms, and so I apologize for implying you were ignorant of the words you were using. I still don’t think the guy you were referring to was begging the question, but I was incorrect in saying your terms were confused.

  15. @64: Some of the regulars there are pretty far out on the fringe just FYI. There is a cadre that’s of the opinion that all vaginal penetration of ANY kind is inherently not only patriarchal, but harmful if not out right deadly to women. So, no dick, no dildos, no nuthin’. They make me laugh, but it’s a great place to kick around ideas, and there are a lot of very smart and passionate women who post there.

  16. 42: A basic variation on “dog humping leg”. Which makes the point that rape jokes is only funny if they end up with the rapist being (at least) humiliated.
    Which sort of leads back toward a dick wolf,,,

    59: I think the point of comparing rape to violent assault (rather than murder) is that, like rape cases, there seem to be seen to be “mitigating circumstances” in some cases where (for whatever reason), the attacker is less culperable than in other cases. That’s probably also true in murder cases, but the mitigating circumstances tend to be less clear cut.
    We (in Australia, and the USA) certainly have violent cultures (especially in certain circumstances); whether we have rape cultures I do not know, but I don’t see it publically ritualised and celebrated like I do with (for example) violent contact sports.

  17. I had the impression that at least some people got the point of the original comic and agreed it was an interesting point and was funny, but then didn’t like the “dickwolves” bit being taken out of context and put on T-shirts and stuff. I mean, earlier today someone posted the bit from the daily show where they made jokes about rape in order to make fun of the senator who wanted to define “forcible rape” as different than regular rape. And those jokes made sense and made an important point in the context, and were funny. But if I took just one line of that bit out of context and put it on a Tshirt, it would no longer make sense, and it would seem offensive.

  18. @71: I understand why he compared rape to assault rather than murder. That part makes sense. As far as not seeing rape culture, that might be partly due to gender. There are things as a man (and I am assuming from your picture that you are a man) that you never have to think about and might never even notice.

  19. What I’m surprised nobody here has pointed out is that…well, this isn’t the first time. A response from PA in regards to criticism is generally ALWAYS escalation, because they tend to keep poking fun at the original parts of the problem. Check out their history with that video-game-hating former? lawyer, Jack Thompson.

    I am also vaguely puzzled that a comic strip featuring a robot that by its own definition rapes fruit is somehow okay to read (fruit can’t consent!), until they make a rape joke about rape being a bad thing? Something seems backwards here.

    Also, I am female and I thought the strips were hilarious, but that’s because I also have friends who do MMORPGs and yeah, the quests do seem a little questionable when taken on their own outside the context of the game.

  20. 73: I will grant you that women SHOULD be more aware than men of the possibility of rape (if only on statistical grounds), but that doesn’t mean men (even straight men) NEVER have to think about it or notice it. Nor does the unliklihood of its occurance necessarily preclude the consideration of the act and its place (if it has one) in our culture.
    And really, I still don’t see any culturally sanctioned rape (except maybe of child molesters in prison). I see slut culture, and bimbo culture, and whore culture, and model body image culture, and diet culture, and violence culture, and sport culture, and gun culture, and even S&M or B&D culture, but not rape culture.
    If we had a culture of rape (or even any sub-culture that seriously considers rape to be acceptable (as opposed to any sub-culture that might consider rape play acceptable)), I would expect to see it (at least in sublimated form) used commonly in advertising, promoted by celebrities, or at least see the merits debated openly within our society (especially among men, who do most of the raping).
    So, sure, we have rape in our societies. Some individuals (mostly men) think that rape is acceptable. But the fact that very, very few of those people seriously and openly advocate rape suggests to me that, as a culture, we DO NOT support rape.

  21. Here’s the mistake that radicals on the left and right always make regarding to artists.

    ARTIST: *joke*
    RADICAL: I’m offended!
    ARTIST: serious business
    RADICAL: Very serious! Artists should always serve my agenda.
    ARTIST: *starts throwing feces*
    RADICAL: Why can’t we have an intellectual discussion about this?
    ARTIST: *drowns the radical with more feces*

  22. ARTIST: *joke*
    anyone else: that joke isn’t funny
    ARTIST: YOU DON’T GET IT I’M TOO EDGY FOR YOU STOP OPPRESSING ME HELP HELP FIRST AMENDMENT RIGHTS!!!!!
    a third individual: but you’re not funny, just sayin’
    ARTIST: THOUGHT POLICE AAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAA

    Congratulations, you just might be Carlos Mencia

  23. I would like to point out that the fragile and childish egos of the “nerds” that did this is present in this thread too. Look at all these posts by the same couple of people trying to e-convince other assholes of their opinions. Its in this desire to be right that people stoop to things like inter-death threats and aspergers-esque fixation.

  24. Seriously: Thanks for keeping it thoughtful and relatively civil, everyone. Slog certainly is a different place than it was two years ago.

  25. @41

    Yeah, I keep muttering “someone whose primary communication style is edgy humor probably shouldn’t do PR.”

    Nerds R smart, yet they never thought of this. Web comics are serious bizness. Get a pro. Don’t open your own mouth and wedge in your own foot.

  26. I have yet to see the outrage regarding the strip about Gabe sucking off 100 horses because Duke Nukem Forever is going to be made.

    I stopped reading Penny Arcade many years ago because of stuff like this. I don’t find them very funny. Their occasional success at observational humor is totally overshadowed by their reliance (and “Nerd culture” in general shares this reliance) on and lust for two weak humor crutches: in jokes and pushing the envelope of the offensive.

    There are plenty of other, funnier webcomics out there. They tend to be less successful, because they aren’t engaged in near-continuous fanservice, but in my opinion they’re smarter, better written, and less reliant on hackery.

    I also found this comment, from the Penny Arcade post linked above, to be rich with irony:

    The fact of the matter is that the strip that started all this is about how empty, amoral, and borderline vile electronic heroism actually is.

    If you replace “electronic heroism” with “Nerd culture,” you have an excellent summation of this entire story. I’d argue that Penny Arcade has become a mecca for fans of the empty, amoral and vile, and that they’ve abdicated responsibility for that.

  27. I’m glad somebody mentioned The Aristocrats because the catalyzing moment for that movie was Gilbert Gottfried’s telling the joke at Hef’s roast in response to people booing his 9/11 jokes. The point is that in terms of expression and humor, nothing should be off-limits. Penny Arcade weren’t endorsing rape with the Dickwolves T-shirt, they were needling those who would click their tongues and censor them. As for the other item, removing Living Dead Girl from your list because of its “triggering nature”?! Are you serious?! Ugh.

  28. @60 – If my niece and I see dickwolf costumes at PAX, we are going to play dumb, walk right up to them, and ask them to explain the costume to us. Should be fun to see them talk through it.

  29. @73: Sorry it took so long to get back to you. I think we have a misunderstanding here. The term rape culture is used to describe a pervasive attitude which demeans women, reducing them to parts and holes, thus facilitating and reinforcing the idea that rape is acceptable and that men cannot be expected NOT to rape. Many of the things you listed are part of what defines rape culture.

    Rape culture often likes to call itself “Common Sense”. This is why we even have the terms “date rape” or “gray rape” and why rape victims have their lives and behavior scrutinized so minutely.
    Did she have a drink?
    Was her skirt short?
    Did she walk home alone? Then what did she expect?
    It’s only common sense.

    Was her assailant drunk?
    Was he some one she knew?
    Had she flirted/kissed/ had sex with him before? Then how could he be blamed?
    It’s only common sense.

    No. No, it’s not.

  30. @86: As a male, I have to point out that I have never before heard the term “gray rape.” And I live in the USA, which apparently has a pervasive “rape culture”, so I don’t see how that’s possible. I actually had to google that phrase to realize that your second scenario is an illustration of it.

  31. I quit reading Penny Arcade the day that Gabe drew a comic that implied his own wife was about to be assaulted by a lech who wanted to drink her breast milk. Disheartening to know that it’s continued downhill every since.

    Keep it classy, guys.

  32. @75 – you kinda just gave examples of rape culture. What are “slut culture, and bimbo culture, and whore culture, and model body image culture” but other words to say she’s asking for it by putting herself out there. What’s a boy to do with all these women being sluts and bimbos?

    It’s not blatant as in no guy who thinks himself a good guy would say “I’m going to rape” they say “She wore that short skirt, made out with me, what did she think would happen when we were alone?”. That way, he gets sympathy for being “mistaken”, but she’s still raped.

  33. I know less than nothing about any of this, but anyone making threats of violence against someone on either side of this controversy should be found, arrested, and sent to jail.

  34. @ 88 Fair enough that you’d never heard of that term before (I actually hadn’t, either). The more important question is: have you ever heard either of the arguments Lissa presented before?

Comments are closed.