According to a recent in-depth review of the City budget, council central staff attributes 79% of the City of Seattle’s increased spending between 2019 and 2024 to inflation and the rising cost of labor associated with it.
One would think that such a finding would challenge some of the new conservative council members’ assumptions that the previous City Council ripped the projected $241 million hole in the 2025 budget by reckless spending and, in turn, would bolster the argument for new, progressive revenue to pay workers and expand social services. So far that’s not the case.
No one in the committee meeting gave a clear indication of whether the audit has swayed them one way or the other on taxes in last week’s meeting. But there’s plenty of time before the fall budgeting process when the council will have to balance the budget. For now, the council will meet once a month this summer to continue examining the 224-page report in what Budget Chair Dan Strauss calls his “Select Summer Budget Series.” Strauss says the council will go through the budget trends department by department to inform which of their limited levers they should pull to balance the budget—lay off staff, cut services, take from already-earmarked funds, or increase revenues.
Council Members Rob Saka, Joy Hollingsworth, Maritza Rivera, Cathy Moore, Bob Kettle, Tanya Woo, and Sara Nelson did not respond to The Stranger’s request for comment about the audit.
I’m used to it, but this is especially frustrating because the council newbies avoided questions about the budget deficit during their 2023 campaign by calling for a budget audit before they took a stance on new revenue or major cuts. The promise of an audit served as a bat signal to their supporters at the Metropolitan Chamber of Commerce and Downtown Seattle Association because it endorsed an underlying assumption that the previous council suffered from a “spending problem” and detracted from the ongoing conversation about new streams of revenue the City could use to fill its looming budget shortfall.
The council quickly realized they could not conduct as thorough an audit as they would like, but Strauss thinks that the central staff’s analysis fits the dictionary definition of an audit.
Some of the council newbs seem satisfied, others not so much. Kettle said he “loves” the report in the committee last week. But Rivera said she and Strauss will have to “agree to disagree” on the definition of an audit in a council briefing Monday.
Whether this achieves their campaign promise or not, every council member knows the report is as close to an audit as they are getting this year. They can still punt the conversation by saying they need to wait until the council finishes the Select Summer Budget Series.
That’s kind of what Strauss did on the phone with The Stranger when he avoided advocating for more revenue or specific cuts based on the high-level presentation of the audit that central staff gave last week. He said, so far, the audit provides “no obvious decisions anywhere” for solving the looming deficit because the council is still “looking under every couch cushion and under every rock.”
That’s sort of his style, annoying as it is to journalists, voters, and the girls who love the gossip. But he did praise JumpStart, a payroll tax on the biggest businesses in Seattle, for saving the budget and countless City jobs. And he ran on a loudly pro-progressive revenue platform in 2023, so he may start making more noise for taxation when the real budget negotiations begin in the fall.
But the austerity has already started. Last month Seattle Public Libraries announced 1,500 hours of service cuts between April 12 and June 2 because of staffing shortages exacerbated by the Mayor’s hiring freeze. Instead of jumping to save the public amenity by taxing the rich or corporations, Libraries, Education, and Neighborhoods Committee Chair Rivera blamed the unions and the markup on ebooks. Expect more of those kinds of arguments as the Select Summer Budget Series continues.
Unsurprisingly, the only council member to take the audit’s findings as a sign of the City’s need for new progressive taxes is Council Member Tammy Morales, the only reliable progressive in the bunch. In an email statement, Morales said, “We need to pass new progressive revenue that ensures corporations are paying their fair share. Cuts to working-class services like libraries, community centers, and food assistance are not the answer.”

I think it’s funny when they blame the unions for costs. After all, it takes two to enter into an agreement – labor and management. And it’s not like the city hasn’t played hardball with the unions before. During the City Light strikes in the 70’s, the city basically locked the workers out and depended on the supervisors to do the basic maintenance work for several months.
One thing that was lurking in the city’s announcement about the hiring freeze was a line that basically said “we want to be careful in hiring this years to minimize curtailments next year”. That could mean anything from layoffs to unpaid furlough days, as we saw during the real estate crash.
First, cut all HSD contracts immediately. They are making the problem they pretend they are trying to solve worse. Spending nothing in that area would improve over what we are and have been doing for the last decade.
There. No additional revenue needed.
We need to audit the audit! Then audit that! If we audit enough something is due to materialize that will fix our budget woes without making any changes. It’s the only sensible thing to do. Well, that and give SPD another $96M in exchange for doing less.
Comments like this are simply false “Last month Seattle Public Libraries announced 1,500 hours of service cuts between April 12 and June 2 because of staffing shortages exacerbated by the Mayor’s hiring freeze”
The SPL is not impacted by the mayor’s hiring freeze – they are simply using it as an excuse to create a crisis (similar to the cops not doing their jobs leading to crimes going unsolved / unpunished). And to be clear, SPL is spending more on ebooks (because publishers can extract additional revenues from that format) and SPL staff are too often de facto social workers which requires elevated staffing levels to keep everyone safe.
@5: “Comments like this are simply false…”
Thank you, I came here just to say that.
Spending more on ebooks means less money for the far-less-expensive paper kind, less money for Library employees, and fewer hours for everyone to use the Library. Why the Stranger isn’t hollering about these equity issues, I really can’t say.
Here’s what I don’t get about the library situation: While they may not be subject to the hiring freeze, they are still bound by the constraints of their budget. If they go over budget, they have to go to the council for supplemental funding, don’t they?
Hannah, in what world are ANY of the current members of the Seattle City Council “conservative”? With two exceptions, they are all bog-standard, moderate to center-left Democrats. Your constant characterization of them as “conservative” shows your bias, and explains why you will never be a true journalist.
The libraries are hit because the Stranger Lefties have turned them into de-facto junkie flops and clinics. The bathroom at the Ballard Library is basically a junkie/tweaker wash basin and rest facility. As a result, the staff has to be more than needed to do the library function. That’s it in a nutshell. So roust the junkies and let the library go back to it’s core function.
To be fair, aramis dear, libraries have always been a locus for problem people, including homeless people and people with substance problems. That’s pretty much baked into the cake. While I agree that Covid and the homeless crisis has been a disaster for the libraries, I also think that the library system is saddled with a fleet of buildings that require much more maintenance than they should, which is very Seattle.
It’s like our schools: All the money that we have put into the school buildings over the last two decades, and now the board is considering closing 20% of the elementary schools because of budget issues and declining enrollment.
This article is a great example of why so many people are frustrated with the city’s elected officials and political culture. Essential services are being left to wither on the vine while all kinds of dumb shit is being funded.
https://www.seattletimes.com/seattle-news/politics/seattle-fire-truck-fleet-deteriorating-faster-than-repairs-can-keep-up/
Maybe the city should get basic services like maintaining fire apparatus squared away before they start trying to generate more revenue to do a bunch of new stuff?