It’s disappointing and baffling to me that as yet, no
reality-TV-show producers have taken me up on my previously published
concept for America’s Next Top Dominatrix, a femme-domme
competition show; too edgy for them, apparently. Jon &
Kate Plus Hateโthat’s the kind of wholesome family
entertainment the networks like.
Clearly, I must look to the community that always pushes the
cultural envelope: porn. My new concept is for a webcast show,
sponsored by some large, well-known BDSM porn producer (cough,
Kink.com, cough). It’s a
competition for straight male dominants who want to work in porn.
The winner gets the dream job: He gets his own website, where he’ll
direct and perform in elaborate BDSM scenes with hot fetish
models.
But this is no Stand & Model party. There can be only one, so
the masters have to prove themselves in a series of tough challenges.
The judges? A panel of experienced female submissives. Don’t be
fooled by the term “submissive.” These women like dominant men, but
they’ve been around the dungeon. They won’t standโmuch less
kneelโfor any poseurs. Their weekly you-are-eliminated line to
the losers? “Safe word!“
In the first episode, the ladies would test the creative thinking of
the would-be kinky auteurs. Here’s a Seattle BDSM-community classic:
the Archie McPhee scene. Using only gear from this toy
store, whoever creates the most escape-resistant bondage and the most
squealing, bruise-inducing pain, wins. (Hint: Rubber snakes are useful
for both restraint and impact, and the “Fairy Fly Swatter” stings
mortals like hell.)
The next challenge tests pervy engineering skills: Come up
with a design for a fucking machine that hasn’t already been
done. (That means anything incorporating a reciprocating saw will
get you laughed off the set.) After that, take a budget of $300 and
build a sexy set for a BDSM photo shootโin a 10-by-10-foot
storage unit.
The contestants who MacGyver their way through those tests will then
receive a different sort of challenge. One doesn’t necessarily
have to have bottomed to make a good top, although it helps. But
remember, anything Fred Astaire did, Ginger Rogers did backward and in
heels. Thus, the masters will have to do an intense BDSM
sceneโwhile dressed in drag. Yep, get out of those leather pants,
guys, and be a badass in a dress and a pair of spike heels.
But all previous challenges pale beside the big one: talent
management! Take a prima-donna bondage model, famed for her
beauty, her physical flexibility, her high pain thresholdโand for
her willingness to throw on-set temper tantrums if the scene isn’t to
her liking. Add a kink-celebrity rope rigger, whose feats of shibari are indeed amazing but who turns out to have
terrible body odor and a mild case of Asperger’s syndrome. Now,
successfully direct these two people in a hot bondage scene that people
would pay money to see. Good luck! ![]()

I’d donate money to see that show produced. Heck, I’d even hold/attend a fundraiser!
I’m sure you know about the Iron Dom competitions that The Citadel here in SF does, yes? Top scene doms (including pro dom/mes, but I think others are allowed as well) are given a set of weird ingredients (a la Iron Chef) and a willing sub. Whoever crafts the best scene using the objects at hand wins.
hell, im completely turned off by straight male dominants and i would watch this!
Sounds like a great idea. Rumor has it Dan has some connections with HBO – maybe you should have a word with him.
I’d call it “Top Top”.
+1 for “Top Top”.
And yes, I’d watch this.
Oh – Hell yes. I’d sub!
America’s Next Top Top!
i’d watch that. let’s not rip on folks w/ aspergers as lovers/kinksters though…my partner has a mild case and perchance it is that neurological tendancy towards obsessiveness/detail that makes them such a great dom
I would totally watch this (and actually set up a paid subscription to kink.com or some other sponsoring website to do it). It would be great publicity for the site, for the participants, and for kink in general – if nothing else, just to show that not everyone is turned on by the same things!
I don’t want to win such a thing. I like my job, and I like my scenes to be focused more on me and my playmates and less on my audience, but being a contestant sounds like a fun and educational experience.
The one thing I will say, if you did dress me in heels before a scene, I would take them off asap and use them as implements instead. I’m not enough of a masochist to actually do anything while wearing them.
fun column, must have taken 15 minutes to write.
I like the idea of Next Top Dominatrix much better though as the male doms i’ve met have almost exclusively been assholes.
@12 Well isn’t that the point? Only a decent human being who is also a good Dom would be able to win America’s Next Top Top.
Oh hell yeah I’d watch this! And if Kink.com did it I’d buy a subscription.