Dear Science,

My brother says that a recent article in the Atlantic says
that some of the most methodical research casts doubt on whether the
flu vaccine is very effective, though that is (as my brother puts it) a
“medically unpopular” view. I cannot be bothered to read the article,
but what do you think about this? And since when is medicine a
popularity contest?

Sister

Science, particularly medical science, is often an art of
deriving conclusions from messy information. Any time
experimentation must be done on people to gather an answer, ethical and
practical restraints limit the raw data available. For flu vaccination,
most of the studies in support—claiming that those vaccinated
against influenza have about a 50 percent lower chance of dying during
flu season (of all causes) compared to those not vaccinated—are
indeed flawed. Any time you retrospectively compare two
groups—those who were voluntarily vaccinated compared to those
who opted against—a whole slew of confounders enter in. Perhaps
the same characteristics that make people choose to be vaccinated
also make them more cautious—better hand-washers, better
coughers, more likely to stay home when sick, and so on.

Shannon Brownlee and Jeanne Lenzer’s Atlantic article jumps
off of a clever study done by Group Health researchers. If the previous
studies compared deaths between those vaccinated and not vaccinated
during flu season, why not use those same groups to compare
death rates
outside of flu season? Indeed,
those who opted to vaccinate against flu were 60 percent less likely to
die during months when flu wasn’t around; the reduced risk of death
observed in the previous flu-vaccine studies can be attributed to this
effect rather than the flu vaccine itself.

Is this proof that the flu vaccine doesn’t work? No. It’s evidence
that we don’t have good data on the flu vaccine. (Please don’t
cry right now.) The vaccine might work, or it might not work. We don’t
know. The way to figure it out is to take some of those who volunteer
to receive the vaccine and randomize them to either receive the
vaccine or a placebo shot
—creating a blinded, randomized, and
controlled trial. This sort of prospective study—with the
randomization at its core—is the best tool we have in clinical
medicine to ascertain if the vaccine helps. Science supports such a
study and feels it would be ethical.

With all this said, there is good evidence that the vaccine doesn’t
cause harm and does help provoke an immune response in otherwise
healthy people against the flu virus. Based on the (flawed) available
information, Science still thinks it’s best to get
vaccinated
—in addition to washing your hands, covering your
coughs, and staying home when you feel sick. The latter works
for any virus, not just the flu.

Cohortingly Yours,

Science

Send your science questions to
dearscience@thestranger.com.

Jonathan Golob is an actual doctor.

7 replies on “Dear Science”

  1. I also support a blinded, randomized, controlled trial on the flu vaccine. Weirdly, the only reason you can ethically do such a study is that the evidence for the efficacy of the flu vaccine is so weak. For vaccines whose efficacy is really solidly established, like the one for polio, it would be unethical to do a study in which half the participants got a placebo shot. Science, do you understand NIH/vaccine politics? Why _hasn’t_ such a flu vaccine study been done in recent years?

  2. yeah seriously people, stay the hell home when your sick! especially you service industry folks. lay off the macho and lay on your bed, at home, away from me. thank you.

  3. @2 Newsflash! very few people want to go to work when they’re sick, most of the people who do go to work sick have jobs where unplanned time off is hard to get and sickdays aren’t covered. A lot of us are women and being ‘macho’ isn’t really a part of it.
    As a server it’s not like I want to be at work taking care of people who spout ‘clever’ slogans when I have a fever, but when it’s a choice of losing my job and not being able to pay my bills or maybe getting a stranger sick, well, I’ll do my best to not cough at your table or drip snot into your food.
    If you don’t like it take it up with the owners of your favorite restaurants and support unions.

  4. You are being misleading by saying that we don’t have “good evidence” for the flu vaccine’s effectiveness, since it isn’t quite clear what you mean, but it certainly isn’t the case that placebo controlled double blind trials are epistemologically privileged in any robust way.

    See the seriously intense discussion at Effect Measure:
    http://scienceblogs.com/effectmeasure/20…

  5. @3 I agree that it’s a shitty situation and that you don’t really have a choice, but it doesn’t make you any less of an asshole. Sometimes the only thing you can do is acknowledge your assholery and get on with life rather than try to defend it.

  6. hey 5,
    really? asshole? 3 times?
    OK, I never claimed not to be so here you go: It’s annoying to be told to ‘just stay home when you’re sick’ like that didn’t cross my fucking mind. I really don’t want to go to work sick, I don’t want to make others sick, the whole thing sucks and schmucks that spout stupid half-witty slogans that attempt to sum up real and complicated circumstances can go fuck themselves. If it were up to me sickleave for serviceworkers would be the norm but society’s priorities aren’t my decision, I’m just an asshole with a shitty job right? We have all made the choice for slightly less expensive food in leiu of health benefits for cooks and servers, but yeah, I’m the asshole.
    Sorry I hurt your precious little feelings, that’s what assholes do.

  7. What 6 said. The reality – especially right now – is that most food service is running under labor with no cushion if someone gets sick. And you are also made aware how many thousands of people want your job. If we made a law saying restaurant owners MUST give time off for employees with a fever or cough (as opposed to the current mandate, which only backs us up in case of diaherrea or vomiting) we’d all be better off. Believe me, no one wants to serve your self-righteous ass while we feel miserable.

Comments are closed.