The Eleventh Doctor, making another weird face.
The Eleventh Doctor, making another weird face.
  • The Eleventh Doctor, making another weird face.

First, yes, I’m only discussing the new series… and if you have no interest in Doctor Who you probably should stop reading… or you probably already have…

Anyway: I’ve been trying. I really have. But I do not like him, Doctor Eleven.

Doctor Nine (Christopher Eccleston) took my heart. And I was wary of Doctor Ten (David Tennant), but he won me over by the end of his first full episode (“The Christmas Invasion”). Especially when he said, after killing the Sycorax Leader, “No second chances. I’m that sort of a man.”

But Doctor Eleven (Matt Smith) is… I can’t even put my finger on it… his weirdness is an affectation instead of being truly eccentric. He’s lacking in passion. He’s not as good an actor as either Eccleston or Tennant. He makes weird faces.

Am I missing something? Does anyone else agree with me? I want to be won over.

In other news, did you know Mary Poppins is a Time Lord?! This apparently popular meme was brought to my attention by a friend. Evidence includes Mary Poppins’ TARDIS-like bag (bigger on the inside), her Time Lord-like arrogance (practically perfect in every way), and the possibility that Bert is one of her former traveling companions since he can sense her coming. Google it. There’s even a Facebook group for it.

66 replies on “Apropos of Nothing: I Want to Discuss the Eleventh Doctor”

  1. Leela? Leela was a stiff block of wood…

    I rewatched “Ark in Space” (one of many Doctor Who offerings on Netflix Watch Instantly right now) this week and was surprised at what an insufferable dick Tom Baker’s version of the character was. I don’t remember him so openly mocking everyone around him, from his companions Sarah Jane Smith (the only true Doctor Who companion) and Harry to whichever characters they encountered in their travels…

  2. Awww I love the Eleventh Doctor and I want him to take me on wacky adventures through time and space and questionable culinary decisions 🙁 I also admit his run was the first Doctor Who I’ve watched and I’ve just started watching the first season with the Tenth Doctor and I am having a hard time getting into it because Rose feels like an annoying MarySue from someone’s fanfiction–and all that probably invalidates my opinion!

  3. I quite like Matt Smith, and Amy is by far the best companion of the new series. I haven’t completely made up my mind on whether or not I prefer him to Tennant, but he is in my mind far better than Eccleston. Eccleston just doesn’t make me laugh like Tennant and Smith do. It’s the camp and humor that make the show good, and Eccleston just never delivered in my opinion. Also, Eccleston is ugly.

  4. From Roger Ebert:

    At the Edinburgh International Television Festival, Steven Moffat, the creative force behind Doctor Who and the BBC’s new series Sherlock, revealed that the upcoming 13-episode season of Doctor Who would be split down the middle.

    “Looking at the next series I thought what this show needs is a big event in the middle. I kept referring to a mid-season finale. So we are going to make it two series – seven episodes at Easter building to an earth-shattering climax, a cliffhanger we could never normally do because it would be too long before it came back. An enormous game-changing cliffhanger that will change everything. The wrong expression would be to say we are splitting it in two. We are making it two separate series. With an Easter series, an autumn series and a Christmas special, you are never going to be more than few months from the new series of Doctor Who. Tart that I am, we will now have two first nights and two finales, twice as many event episodes as we had before.” – Steven Moffat.

  5. @55 — So does that mean we’ll have a shorter Series 6 and Series 7 next year?

    @54 — Give the man a break. I’ve only seen a handful of the Eccleston episodes, but I’m sure he would’ve been a fine Doctor had he stayed on a bit longer.

    @Mary — Thank you for making my day by mentioning Doctor Who on Slog and allowing the mob to geek out. My inner nerd is most pleased.

    In general — I can’t pass judgment on Smith without having watched any of his episodes (shameful, I know), but I was impressed by the half of ‘The Eleventh Hour’ I’ve watched. After all the Tenth’s emotional trauma, Smith’s weirdness makes the series refreshingly light-hearted again, just like Tennant’s energy did after Eccleston’s gravitas. Then we saw the Tenth grow up over the course of four years, and heartbreaking as it was, it made for a hell of a story. Let’s just hope Smith can handle the transition as competently as Tennant did.

    Writing-wise, Steven Moffat has had a great track record, so even if Matt Smith never was and never becomes David Tennant, at least most of the stories are up to snuff. (More than I can say for RTD’s run.)

  6. You’re kidding me, right? Tennant was awesome in the first couple of seasons he was in, but then the scripts got hijacked by RTD and RTD’s ego, an entity with sufficient mass to have its own gravitational force. And Ten, whom I’d enjoyed massively until then (though not as much as Nine – Nine wins) turned into a complex mess of entitled brat, all-powerful overlord and hormonal mopey teenager that couldn’t have been more irritating if he’d tried. I couldn’t finish watching s3 and s4, although I stuck it out through more of s4 because of Donna.

    OTOH, the latest series has been pure love. A smart, sexy companion who has issues and is flawed and a little geeky and generally all-around awesome; Rory’s the first Other Guy I’ve enjoyed (fuck, but Mickey was a whiner); and if you think Matt Smith makes more weird faces than Tennant, you need to get your eyes checked.

    And the weirdness…I think that’s a solid case of Fridge Brilliance. It is an affectation, yes, but speaking from the point of view of one who’s pulled a very similar facade in the past – it’s easier to pretend (badly) to be something unlike you (affected, geeky human), so that people don’t notice what you’re *actually* pretending not to be (human at all). I really enjoyed that about the way he played the Doctor.

  7. The writing on the shows isn’t that good. That surprised me as Moffet wrote “Blink” the episode I’ve like the most out of all the new Dr Who shows.

  8. Loved Tennant, miss him loads. He was “my” Doctor. Matt Smith is growing into the role, I think – his performance got more nuanced as the season went on – but I haven’t yet found anything I can relate to in him. In each of the previous Doctors, I found at least one or two things that were relateable… but Eleven, so far, is wacky and unpredictable and cocky and distant and *fun*, and often *watchable*…. but not relateable (to me).

    I think that’s why Eleven seems to be one of the love-him-or-hate-him Doctors. If you want a doctor that’s *watchable*, as in “interesting to watch, because he loves the unexpected,” Eleven is that… but if you’re the kind of viewer who needs to be able to relate to the character to enjoy the story – even in a small way – Eleven is, by design, harder to do that with than Ten (or even Nine, who was less “human” than Ten but still had pathos going for him).

  9. This is the reason why this show has lasted for 50 years. The cast, writers, and whole vibe of the show changes with each incarnation of the doctor. Change can be scary, and uncomfortable. Every person I’ve introduced to the show has had a tough time getting over the loss of their ‘Doctor’. I’m going to try to walk you through accepting Matt Smith, Mary. Because this is a very very serious problem you have, Mary. You need help.

    David Tennant’s Doctor was a grand Shakespearian tragic figure. He carted around humans to keep him from going all megalomaniac all over the place, and to distract him from his survivors guilt and post traumatic stress. And here’s the conscious choice of the writers: Those companions helped him, and now he’s warmer, more human, and less traumatized.

    In addition to being less trajic, he’s also older. And Smith is playing a bit of senility. He’s actually playing it older than Tennant did. And everyone on Earth is too young to play a 907 year old alien by the way.

    As for Matt Smith’s acting, where you see affectations, I see creative detail. He’s one of the more inventive actors I’ve seen on film. He makes interesting choices with every move. He’s playing a character that’s the smartest person in the universe. I think he’s doing it convincingly.

    (spoilers)

    Check out the moment in the where he meets himself that’s been shot by a Dalek or when he tells his story to a sleeping Amy Pond. Check out the three hundred-seventy-five emotions that cross his face. Or if you think he lacks gravitas, watch the scene where he says ‘Nobody human has anything to say to me today’ from the space whale episode.

    (end spoilers)

    Tennant is a stage actor. He’s big and bold and melodramatic. Smith is a screen actor. Those ticks you see are every single thought playing out on the guy’s face. I had the exact opposite reaction when I first watched Smith, and I think it was because I resolved not to judge harshly based on my feelings of losing Tennant.

    To sum up, Matt Smith is a fantastic actor. You must love him. It’s the most important thing ever, Mary. You must embrace Matt Smith as the Doctor!

  10. Tennant was and will forever be My Doctor, but Smith is doing well, I think.

    Though….He’s no John Barrowman. Captain Jack is the MAN.

    Doctorwho=Torchwood

    Can’t wait till Torchwood comes back!

Comments are closed.