This video introduction to the upcoming DC Universe Online Game has been making the rounds since San Diego Comic Con:

About this trailer, io9 says:

That’s as epic a battle between dudes with capes as I’ve ever seen. Wonder Woman, especially, comes off like the hero no one’s willing to make a feature film about. Makes you wonder why videogame cinematics can achieve a level of pure drama and sheer cool that movies rarely approach.

Now I don’t want to be misinterpreted as an Ebert-style video-games-can’t-be-art grump, but there’s a reason why a comic book or a comic book movie can’t equal the “cool” of a video game trailer or cut scene: They have to worry about a story. Most video game adaptations of comics* don’t have to worry about things like characterization (the characters have been established by dozens of years of comics). When video game adaptations try to introduce new characters to the pre-established ones, the result is usually underwhelming.

The above clip might have a shit-ton of fan service, but it’s not a story. It’s a scenario. But if you were coming into this clip without any frame of reference, you couldn’t tell anything about Superman as a character except for the fact that he sulks a lot, screams in a deep ragged voice, and punches things (which sounds more like the Hulk to me). A good Superman story is about doing what’s right. A Superman video game trailer is about flying really fast, using different powers, and breaking shit. And that’s fine, you know? But don’t pretend that you could make a two hour movie out of this kind of teeth-baring, posing, and ‘splosions.

* Again, because I know people on the internets get touchy about this sort of thing: I am not saying that video games in general have no story. I believe that video games are a storytelling medium. I’m directly addressing io9’s claim here.

16 replies on “Endless Battle of the Screaming Muscle-Men”

  1. @4. Two things.

    1. The character you are thinking of is Captain Marvel. Shazam (S, for the wisdom of Solomon. H, for the strength of Hercules. A,for the stamina of Atlas. Z, for the power of Zeus.
    A, for the courage of Achilles.M,for the speed of Mercury) is his magic word to bring about (or remove) his powers not his name.
    http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Captain_Mar…

    2. The character seen here is Black Adam. He is the sometimes good, sometimes bad, sometimes middle of the road version of Captain Marvel. He too uses the magic word Shazam but his is based on ancient Egyptian mythos
    S,for the stamina of Shu.
    H,for the swiftness of Heru.
    A,for the strength of Amon.
    Z,for the wisdom of Zehuti.
    A,for the power of Aton.
    M,for the courage of Mehen)

    http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Black_Adam

  2. Just too much crash-bang. But I think that’s the point. I do like the CGI and it would make an attractive game. But it’s still too cartoony.

  3. OMG THIS LOOKS AWESOME! Also it seems set up for a story… Lex Luthor and various super villainy are successful in taking out the JLA so Braniac swoops in and destroys Earth leaving Luthor the sole survivor. So… he goes back in time and warns the big 3 about what is going to happen and that they have to stop it… obviously there would need to be a shit-ton more for a movie premise but for a video game it’s pretty sweet. I also think the grittiness of it makes the heroes look less cartoony.
    Honestly though if they bring back the Justice League animated universe I wouldn’t care or need a live-action movie.

  4. It’s cool but it’s hardly movie quality animation or voice acting. I also think video games have a hard time rising to art because not only do they rarely have to invest much in characterization (and rarely do they have consistent characters). “Game play” causes inherent pacing problems for “art.” But that’s not a say they aren’t artistic. To demonstrate a point, Cyborg has no personality. In Deathstroke’s hands the golden lasso just ghosts through Batman’s arms. And since when does Batman call down artillery? Or Superman laser people in the face?

    Any, what’s really annoying is that they tell you next to nothing about the game. Yeah, trailers cool, but whats the game play going to be like (besides physics based)? What character options are there? Etc?

  5. Paul,

    You should be fucking fired.

    That trailer is AMAZING. And you know what? It’s the beginning of an epic, sprawling story. You moron.

    Seriously, this trailer is such an epic, amazing, jaw-dropping, wonderful and fun story of DC universe. And it’s only the beginning.

    Lex Luthor’s character says something like, “Brainiac was stealing the powers of superheroes over a number of years.” I believe that would address Superman’s situation, his anger, his red eyes, his growling.

    You just have no patience for anything good, do you, Paul?

    Fire yourself and go get a job where you make an honest living, not your bullshit, uneducated opinion.

  6. The real problem with the game is that you won’t be playing anyone in that trailer; you’ll be creating, effectively, a sidekick.

  7. @12 – Thats video games for you. VG companies want to delay actual gameplay trailers as long as possible. Game play is one of the FEW things VG “reporters” will actually criticize.

    PROBLEMS:
    1) You cant hear someone scream on earth from space superman…
    2) The flash looks SO BAD, like Cyborg bad.
    3) Voice work, they clearly spent the voice budget on batman and company, I wish they had turned to talents like Amy Acker and Nathan Fillion.
    4) Says nothing of the way the MMORPG is going to be AT ALL PLAYABLE. All MMORPGs need to be better than WOW, you need to tout that shit.

    City of Heroes and Champions Online were fantastic superhero games that could not get people away from WOW. (Well COH was fun but pretty shitty)

Comments are closed.