
The Obama administration has all but confirmed that it views Seattle as a national model for police reform by picking police chief Kathleen O’Toole to join First Lady Michelle Obama in her seating section at the State of the Union tonight, along with thirteen others.
O’Toole has said she’s “shocked” and humbled by the invitation. In a statement, the White House said “her focus on improving officer morale, implementing new policies and optimizing department resources has received national attention.”
By many measures, the department is making substantial progress under O’Toole’s leadership. As of October, according to the city, crime was on the decline, including substantial reductions in South Seattle. A recent survey shows that 64 percent of the Seattle public approves of the department, while disapproval ratings are down nine percentage points compared with 2013.
She has brought new blood to the department brass, and her firing of Officer Cynthia Whitlatch reportedly marked the first time in the department’s modern history that it terminated an officer for biased policing.
But there’s also a self-fulfilling prophecy at play here.
Much of the “national attention” on the SPD has come from the Obama administration itself, which wants to be seen as showing leadership on issues of police brutality. Last year, SPD officials were invited to a White House summit on transparency. The attorney general chose to visit Seattle in September and praise the department (while the city’s own Community Police Commission complained they were being marginalized by the Department of Justice-led reform process). The New York Times wrote positively about the department’s new de-escalation training regimen, which other departments are studying.
At the same time, Black Lives Matter activists have drawn another kind of attention to Seattle. Five years after the feds began their investigation into the SPD, the activists recently rated the department’s contract with the Seattle Police Officers Guild (SPOG) as one of the worst in the country, because it delays questioning after officer-involved shootings, purges data about officer misconduct, disqualifies certain kinds of complaints, and limits civilian oversight.
That contract, which is currently being re-negotiated in secret, is still in place.
SPOG, for its part, claimed it was “under attack” by the activists. And this week, the union is claiming a good portion of the credit for O’Toole’s invitation in a post on Facebook (and pretty much all the credit in a post on Twitter). In the past year, the union’s president has retrenched himself in the union’s conservative culture, after briefly speaking out in February against officers who refuse to adapt the city’s progressive political climate. In August, Mayor Ed Murray was concerned about the union president’s view that the Obama administration had created a “war on cops,” and acknowledged he needed to find a way to “bring this union along.“
Writing for Crosscut today, David Kroman notes that if Obama gives the impression that Seattle has reached the promised land of a reformed police department, many locals will disagree.
Late last year, nearly fifty community leaders—preachers, activists, nonprofit leaders, and more—wrote to the federally-appointed monitor and questioned why key reforms to the department’s accountability system have been delayed for nearly two years under his watch.
And those aforementioned surveys showed that while overall confidence in SPD is slightly up, African-Americans are still more likely to strongly disapprove of SPD than strongly approve, with approval ratings virtually unchanged since 2013.
All of which means that if Seattle is indeed being held up by Obama as a “national model,” it’s a model that still needs to be seriously improved upon before we can call it all good.
