When my son was in preschool, there was this kid who was convinced he was a train. Actually this child—let’s call him Thomas—believed he was a locomotive. “Train,” I learned from Tommy, is technically the engine plus all its attached cars. One person couldn’t be a whole train, Tommy explained to me. That would just be silly!

And this definitely wasn’t about being silly. This was no one-day play identity for Tommy. As I recall, Tommy spent over a year being a locomotive, day in and day out. And not just any loco. Tommy was—and he seemed convinced he would remain—the type of Union Pacific articulated steam locomotive known as a “Big Boy.”

I had to hand it to Tommy. He made about as convincing a locomotive as a kid could be. He blew his whistle in advance of crossing paths and rang his bell when he came into “stations.” On really cold days, he couldn’t move forward until his firebox had warmed enough to make a good head of steam. Once he could really see his breath, then he’d chug along.

The other preschool parents thought this was so cute. I kept wondering whether, by the time Tommy grew up, there was going to be a surgeon who would offer to transform him physically into an engine. I wasn’t sure what that would look like, but I had already met a surgeon interested in using his craft to provide people with wings. I figured that surgeon, 20 years later, might be willing—given enough cash and a firm liability waiver—to try to approximate a Big Boy, trademark infringement on Union Pacific notwithstanding.

Before I get slaughtered by the trans activist community (again), let me be clear that I don’t think being a transgender adult is like being a child who imagines he is a locomotive. There’s no analogue to the engine-wish among adult humans. Meanwhile, most adult humans do seem to have gender identities, and we know that some people grow up with genders that don’t match their body types. I support the right of people to determine their own genders, and even to change them repeatedly. I don’t see a lot of reason why governments need to keep as close track of our gender identities as they do. And if a person is found by a qualified mental health professional to be likely to be left better off in terms of mental health by “sex change” interventions, then I think those interventions should be paid for by the same insurance systems that pay for treatment of depression and anxiety.

Some will label me anti-trans for opening with my story of Tommy, but I’m not. I just think the way some putative progressives are dealing with trans right now among kids is—well, it’s kind of transphobic.

Changing a kid’s name and gender identification at the age of 5 or 6? This approach takes gender claims of little children so seriously that it’s actually beholden to a ridiculously strict notion of gender. No meaningful trans really allowed.

Fact is, kids don’t always mean what we mean when they make seemingly firm identity claims. Let’s go over some other uncomfortable facts. The great majority of young children who declare they are a gender that doesn’t match their birth sex grow out of the mismatch. Most boys who declare themselves girls or act girly grow up to be ordinary gay men. These men may occasionally crossdress for fun using drag handles like “Helvetica Bold,” but they won’t seek to have their penises and testicles removed and replaced by estrogen and a vulva.

Young girls who declare in word or behavior that they are boys end up all over the place, which at some level proves to me most really are females. (As a general rule, males end up more specific about identities and interests, while females have broader interests and greater flexibility of experience; so we would predict that males would have clearer clusters of outcomes than females do.) Some gender-bending little girls will end up as men—gay, straight, bi—but a fair number will end up as lesbian, bi, and straight women who have no sense of having been “born in the wrong body.”

Sex-changing interventions are nontrivial. They involve substantial physical risk, including major risk to sexual sensation, and a lifelong commitment to trying to manage hormone replacement. Most people seem to get how serious sex-changing interventions are when we’re not talking about transgender. A couple of weeks ago, a man writing into Savage Love mentioned that he had voluntarily been castrated—a fetish, don’t you know—and the commentators went, well, nuts. And most people get that it was wrong for doctors in the past to take baby boys born with small penises and sex-change them with genital surgeries and hormonal interventions.

But somehow if we wrap these major interventions around gender identity, we’re supposed to believe they are not that big a deal in terms of planning for a child’s future? And the clinician who tries to get a gender dysphoric kid to learn to like her or his innate body really is a Nazi? Not buying it.

Look, I am certainly not suggesting we go back to the UCLA Sissy Boy Experiment days of George Rekers and try to metaphorically or literally beat the sissy out of boys and the butch out of girls. But I am also sick and tired of trans-rights advocates acting like a certain current-day endocrinologist is ever-so-progressive because he essentially starts prepping genderqueer kids for surgery the moment they are presented by their distraught parents. Reminds me a little too much of Iran, you know?

So what do we do with these kids?

For over a decade, my friend and colleague Paul Vasey has been studying the fa’afafine people of Samoa. These are biological males who, as the word fa’afafine translates, live “in the manner of women.” These folks were born male typical, but from pretty early on they seemed quite girlish—girl-typical in activities, dress, play, and general self-identity. The Samoans get that this happens. They just give these kids a way to be—they say, “you’re fa’afafine”—without sending any message that their bodies aren’t appropriate to their senses of self.

Paul’s research, comparing the Samoan experience with the North American, indicates that the stress genderqueer kids here feel is not inherent to them. Being genderqueer doesn’t make you distressed. Distress arises from the push and pull of the people around who just can’t deal.

So “What do we do with these kids?” is the wrong question. There’s nothing inherently wrong with them. The problem is us and the way we demand certainty from them, the way we insist on conformation to a two-sex model as early as possible. The problem is the bullies and gender-obsessed adults, not the genderqueer kids.

What if a boy could go to school in a dress and still be a boy? What if a girl could declare she’s going to grow up to be a man without being dragged to a clinic for a cure and/or prep? What if we made the bullies go get mental health interventions first (or, at least, too)?

You know what? We don’t have to force our little locomotives to pick one track or the other. They just want love, reasonable-but-not-infinite space to try stuff out, and a nice warm roundhouse to come home to at the end of the day. We can wait to see where they need to go tomorrow. recommended

Alice Dreger, PhD, is professor of clinical medical humanities and bioethics at Northwestern University Feinberg School of Medicine. Her personal website is www.alicedreger.com.

86 replies on “Trans Advocates”

  1. I believe the goal for trans folks is to find comfort in their skin. The social changes you suggest would give trans people greater social ease as they learn about themselves, but I’m not sure it really would provide better end options than we have now.

    To be sure some trans folks can deal with their dysphoria without having to get a “sex change” operation, but not all will be able to do that even if society is much more accepting of gender diversity. Also, even as things are now we trans folks can make those decisions as we see fit.

    Also, the problem with younger folks is that, like it or not, being able to make a decision how to deal with gender dysphoria before our bodies have changed at puberty can be very important to our future well-being. A society that is more accepting is all well and good but it’s not going to make that decision any easier.

    FWIW, I do not need genital surgery. I have, however, had facial feminization surgery. That was the key to ending my dysphoria.

  2. >>>What if a boy could go to school in a dress and still be a boy? What if a girl could declare she’s going to grow up to be a man without being dragged to a clinic for a cure and/or prep? What if we made the bullies go get mental health interventions first (or, at least, too)?<<<

    Right the fuck on. The lesbian community is really getting battered by this ‘you are butch so you must be transitioning’ BS — genderqueer people are being encouraged into the two-gender identity model; instead of pressuring them to conform on the outside, they are being pressured to conform on the INSIDE/physical.
    Not comfortable in a dress? happy in jeans and a mens shirt? well you must be a man, cut off your tits, take T and start acting like a man, dude.

  3. thank you so fucking much!! When I was little I wanted to be a boy, I also wanted to be a dinosaur, a timber wolf, a horse and a sabertooth tiger. I’m 28 now and while I have a very masculine personality and often work in masculine fields I am still very much a woman. Can’t a tomboy just be a fucking tomboy? Again, this article was awesome.

  4. @3 “Can’t a tomboy just be a fucking tomboy?”

    Oh, holy fuck no!

    There are only tomboys if you limit girls to a somewhat arbitrary set of interests and activities . My daughter can have a tea party in the top of a tree she climbed in fancy dress after baseball practice, and frankly you can shove you’re labels.

    That said, she better not damage or dirty that dry-clean-only dress because her mom will kill her.

  5. @3: Right on! I wanted to be a boy when I was little, too, but that was because I could see from a young age that boys got to do the cool stuff and were taken more seriously than girls. I also thought men were more powerful when I was a child, but that’s because a woman’s power is more subtle. But I love being a woman, I love my body, and I wouldn’t change it for anything. I can’t imagine how messed up I would be if my parents had decided my outspoken preference to be a boy was anything more than a childish whim. Therapy? Seriously?! I just wanted to use power tools, is all.

  6. Is this really a problem? Are gender non-conforming children being forced into accommodating “sex changes”. Is anyone saying that a tomboy can’t just be a tomboy? How many tomboys and pinkboys are there in America compared to trans-children? Are we really concerned that acceptance of transgender people will wipe out all gender noncomformists?
    Allay you fears, most of the trans people in this world are with you on this, fuck gender to your hearts delight! I’ll even let you in on a little secret: a lot of trans people don’t conform to strict gender roles after transitioning. Some of us are butch dykes, some of us are flaming queens. We are not the enemy of queer people and feminists, we’re on your side.
    And I’m going out on a limb here and guessing that every trans-person agrees that no one should transition unless they’re sure.
    And I think that every reasonable adult can agree that children should not be used as pawns in grown-up political games.
    That maybe a hundred kids across the country are so sure that they can convince the adults in their lives that it’s real does not seem like a case of ‘Trans Advocates doing it wrong’ as much as it does society slowly accepting that some people are trans and that like being gay, kids can know.

    Dr. Dreger, your article “Gender Identity Disorder in Childhood: Inconclusive Advice to Parents” and the follow up post with Sarah Hoffman’s feedback are (mostly) great, but this article… Do you really think that the Thomas the tank engine anecdote or the wings surgery allusion are appropriate for an honest conversation about the hard facts? Yes, opening an article with a common trope of trans-phobes just might get you labeled as a trans-phobe, being trans is quite different from believing that one is a locomotive, a bird, or a different race and you should know this given your expertise in physical and social gender binary non-conformation. Are you really so dense or are you actively trying anger trans people at this point?

    You have some really, really, wonderful opinions on gender, sex, and society Dr. Dreger. But maybe it’s time to take a look in the mirror and ask why you’ve consistently had a hostile relationship with the trans community for years and why it keeps getting worse.

  7. When I was a child I used to play dress up with my two sisters. I suppose I should be grateful my parents didn’t drag me into the clinic to have my penis chopped off.

  8. When my daughter was between the ages of 5 and 9, she liked to pretend she was a cat. So I let her. Eventually at school some kids started teasing her about it, so I said well, just pretend at home then. She still enjoyed it for a while and then eventually grew out of it when she was ready.

    Kids do things like play pretend and play dress up. When it comes to gender play, I say just let kids do it without putting any significance on it. If necessary to protect them, you might restrict certain activities to home but at least they’ll know they have one safe place to be who they want for the moment. At a young age, you don’t know yet if they are playing or if they are transgender or gay or whatever. They probably don’t know themselves. But if you just let them play with their identities without putting pressure on them to make it permanent, that should be just as comforting to the child no matter what sex or gender identity they finally choose as a teen or adult.

  9. @6, you missed the point entirely. The point is that if a boy who thinks he’s a girl is the same age as other kids who think they are locomotives then maybe his belief is a function of his age and not a function of being transgendered. At that age, there’s no real way to tell.

  10. I agree with Rose DeCastile; Dr. Dreger does bring up some interesting points to be sure. But to me it just sounds like another “authority” on transgender individuals who has no absolutely no idea what it is like to be trans.

    The whole notion that there is a big problem with small children being dragged into the doctor’s office to begin transitioning ASAP sounds dubious at best.

    There is a definite tone of disdain that comes across in Dr. Dreger’s essay. At first, I really did believe that she was a trans ally (though I though that the opening about the locomotive was weak) But as I read on and she kept mentioning that she is perceived as being hostile to the trans community I realized there is a reason why.

    Dr. Dreger: The people you study are not specimens. Your years of education may have left you with a more comprehensive understanding of the trans community than the average bear – but you clearly do not fully understand or support the transgender community.

    As for the Stranger: Shame on you for wasting that valuable space on what could have been a truly informative, POSITIVE discussion on the multitude of ways humans experience and express gender.

  11. There really aren’t a lot of 5 and 6 year olds transitioning. It’s hard enough for an adult to be approved.

    And we should be helping people to transition earlier, not later. Sex reassignment surgery and hormones work better before puberty.

  12. Wow.
    Completely unsurprised that the trans-ignorant Stranger would solicit its only Trans article from a known trans phobe who routinely demonizes trans and intersexed people in order to propel forward her rather pathetic hum drum academic career. Alice loves to stir up shit just to get publicity, in this instance by comparing trans children to children who want to be trains. Great job Alice! You prove yet again you are completely incapable of making a cogent phobic argument on your own without comparing apples and oranges. Yes, Children have wild imaginations, which we love. Yes, some children think they are trains and other inanimate objects.

    However, this has NOTHING to do with the intense distress that children feel about their BODIES, their sex characteristics, their social role as boys and girl, or the way that our culture also forces these children to conform to a strict gender expression based on their genitals. As a Seattle area therapist who has treated literally dozens of extremely distressed young people whose gender identity or expression doesn’t match their birth sex this article is not only asinine, it is also extremely ignorant.

    You make an exceptionally bogus and false notion that there are these ‘magical trans / gay therapists’ out there who are FORCING children to transition. Far from the case. As a person who myself transitioned in my early teens –I sought help from dozens of doctors and therapists with the help of my supportive parents before I could find a single one even willing to listen to me.

    The fact is, that nearly all therapists who treat transgender and gender non-conforming children are already WELL AWARE of the fact that for many gender non-conforming children their gender identity my change over time. And anyone who has attended a World Professional Association of Transgender Health Conference, or any local conferences around the US knows nearly all therapists pursue a ‘small changes first’ and ‘rush slowly’ approach of minimizing permanent changes while emphasizing shifting social gender roles or gender expression to most closely match how children feel most comfortable.

    Unlike Tommy the train, the distress and pain of trans and gender non-conforming children feel is real. You make no mention of the fact that trans and gender non-conforming children attempt suicide at nearly seven times the rate of their straight peers, and tripple that of even their gay and lesbian peers. You make no mention that our culture is MUCH MORE LIKELY to punish, penalize, deny, invisibilize, and victimize gender non conforming and trans children.

    I’m sorry if I have a hard time believing your comparison to Tommy the Train, or to take you even remotely seriously when you make such comparisons. I don’t think you’re a transphobe, I simply think you are an ignorant idiot who probably hasn’t spent more than 10 minutes with a group of trans or gender non-conforming children LISTENING to what they have to stay with an open heart and hearing how dreadfully painful their lives are.

    Shame on The Stranger editorial staff (who I personally find dreadfully ignorant when it comes to trans issues) for giving you yet another podium to espouse your ignorance from. Good for you for making a career out of being a ignoramus with a PhD.

  13. @12 Since Dreger is a bioethicist, which is a career that deals with the implications of ethics in the most marginal, rare, and difficult of situations, it doesn’t make sense to castigate her for critiquing something which does not, perhaps, reflect mainstream practice. She feels, however, that taking kids’ own claims of gender Really Fucking Seriously, Like They Know What They Want Forever And Ever, is a trend which is growing and which is probably inappropriate.

    Also, speaking of inappropriate, how rude of you to say that Dreger doesn’t believe that “the distress and pain of trans and gender non-conforming children is real.” She discusses the source of distress at length in this article, not to mention almost everything else she’s written, and she even offers an alternative cultural model which shows how gender non-conforming kids are supported and therefore do not suffer distress.

    Look, if you can’t critique her without making shit up and willfully misreading what she actually says, maybe your critiques are baseless.

  14. @9 No, I’m quite sure I get the point.
    Currently there are two models to deal with the “problem” of kids who exhibit gender atypical behavior, the Therapeutic model, and the Accommodation model.
    The Therapeutic Model (AKA reparative therapy) which has been shown repeatedly to cause more harm than cure and has been disavaowed by the APA, is unfairly labeled as “Nazism”* by the mean mean Trans Advocates who just can’t accept the hard truths.
    The Accommodation Model which is comparatively new, but has yet to demonstrate psychological damage is dangerous because it takes children at their word and allows social transition, which could lead to physical transition, which is a terrible and hard life.
    Anyway, nowadays the Therapeutic model has been unfairly discarded because Trans Advocates are so powerful in the psychiatry world and every child that does anything that could be considered cross-gendered is dragged off to a gender therapist to be forcibly sex-changed.

    But wait! Alice Dreger, PhD has a better totally original idea that no one in America has ever thought of before! What if we just made a space for a third gender, for boys who mistakenly think they’re girls!?! They do it in Samoa so it should totally work here! We could call them, oh I don’t know…She-males?!?
    Oh, but what about the FTMs?

    Look, I don’t claim to know what’s best for every queer child, but I do know this article is bullshit and here’s why:

    The article opens with the scare of a person “transitioning” into a locomotive, or the closest surgical simulacrum, there might even be a doctor willing to do it!
    Do I even really need to explain the insanity of this comparison?
    Then, hey! Alice Dreger is not a transphobe, in fact anyone who calls her out as a transphobe is the actual transphobe because transitioning as a child erases (somehow) the act of transitioning.
    Then reparative therapists are unfairly called Nazis by Trans Advocates.
    Then there’s a link where a famous reparative therapist is cited, but it’s different because if the reparative therapy doesn’t work he thinks it’s ok to be gay or transgender, he also likens being transgendered to believing that one is a different race.
    Then, why can’t gender atypical people just be happy being gender atypical, can’t boys just do girl things and girls do boy things and everyone is happy?

    These are all the reasons people try to use to persuade trans people not to transition, it doesn’t work on adults and to bust this shit out using children is just fucked up.

    The Stranger, I’m so disappointed that you published this, if you don’t agree with me on anything else I hope you can at least appreciate that you published an article that broke Godwin’s law while defending reparative therapy.
    Fuck dudes, I thought you were cool.

  15. @16 – I skimmed your very long link, and all I could find was anger at semantics, specifically the use of the term “disorder.”

    Is that it?

    Is there anything beyond terminology that should lead me to believe she’s anti-trans?

  16. I’m with @17, I honestly do not read this article as trans-phobic at all, and feel that the criticisms are largely over semantics. Trans issues are close to my heart in many ways – transphobia is just the kind of thing that gets my vitriol going, but I just don’t see it here.

  17. @17 Well, I think semantics around the use and meaning of the word disorder are pretty loaded. Don’t you?

    Let’s change the context a little bit. Should being black be labelled a disorder or not? Should being gay be labelled a disorder or not?

    It’s all just semantics and terminology right?

  18. @19: Well, gender dysphoria can be seen as a type of ‘disorder’ in the sense that it’s often extremely uncomfortable to live with, and can be treated with medicine (hormones and surgery). It’s useful at least for insurance purposes.

    @15: What first-hand experience are you talking about? A 5 year old transitioning into a locomotive?

  19. YES. SO YES. Growing up, I went to a private all girls high school that was very much the (not so) modern equivalent to a finishing school. I came out of their convinced I must be trans, but still very confused because I didn’t want a penis or to get rid of my tits. I now identify as generally queer and see that I have no issue with my body, only that having this body doesn’t mean what society seems to think it must mean.

  20. Dr. Dreger. As a fellow academic, I ask you to please list your sources. I ask because what you describe bears little resemblance to the requests of trans advocates in my experience. I am curious as to the roots of this discrepancy.

    Most trans advocates that I’ve worked with would support allowing kids to explore gender however the heck they feel like it. Butch girl one day, sissy boy the next, whatever. Just have fun and we’ll try to make sure you get treated like a human being. If the child experiences gender-related bodily dysphoria *come puberty,* which is usually several years *after* the “pretending to be a tank engine” phase passes, then most trans advocates think it would be nice if a child has the option of *delaying* puberty, so as not to experience physical changes from their intrinsic endocrine set – physical changes that can only be mitigated through surgery or medication. (how would you like to be a 10-year-old child who knows she is a girl, but who is growing a beard and watching her voice drop, and knowing that fixing this is going to be slow, difficult and/or expensive?) Once the kid’s older, they can decide what hormonal and/or surgical course is right for them. If any. Regardless of their gender identities.

    Also: many (not all) “third gendered” people in cultures with more than two genders are second-class citizens even within their own culture and many (not all) experience bodily dysphoria and will seek some form of medical transition if accessable.

    So please, what are your sources on this article? As a PhD, I assume you have a list.

  21. Where Alice Dreger goes wrong is to suggest that the involvement of mental health professionals is in any way helpful. At best is causes needless delay. Usually it causes positive harm.

    Queer kids just need to be let be and given some slack. Chose their own daytime name if they wish, choose their own clothes as long as they are practical and frugal, and most likely unisex.

    As to adult transsexualism, that is somatic. Mental health involvement again causes only harm. It is time for the psychiatrists and psychologists to butt out, just as they did for homosexuality generations ago.

  22. @23: LGBT kids deal with depression and suicidal thoughts, and other mental health problems, just like straight kids do (in fact, at a much higher rate). Having a psychiatrist or some kind of therapist can be literally life-saving.

  23. @24 Of course being queer does not immunize a person against mental illness.

    But the mental illness has nothing whatever to do with being queer (including genderqueer). Certainly transsexual people should be able to access psychiatry if they wish. But presently they are obliged to because somatic medical assistance is held hostage to mental health diagnosis; and most go the mental health “services” unwillingly and resentfully.

    It is fine to diagnose a queer person with depression if that fits. It is NOT fine to diagnose a queer person with Gender Identity Disorder or Gender Dysphoria or anything like that. Doing so is damaging and iatrogenic. Doing it to a child is just prurience on the part of the mental health professional.

  24. I see what you mean, but I do think that having some sort of counseling or guidance as you transition would be very helpful. Especially with hormones, which can have all sorts of negative side effects. I think the solution is to provide better mental health services by trans-friendly professionals, not to decouple them completely from somatic assistance.

    As far as diagnoses go, would you prefer it if the diagnosis were just called “transsexuality”? The way payment for medical care works now is largely based on insurance companies billing specific rates for specific diagnoses, so without having some sort of label, it could be difficult to get insurance coverage.

  25. @26 >> As far as diagnoses go, would you prefer it if the diagnosis were just called “transsexuality”?

    There is already a diagnosis called Transsexualism, it is ICD-10 F64.0 It is a classified as a disorder of adult personality (even when found in a child). Though it beggars belief how psychiatrists can think they have the clairvoyance to diagnose a CHILD with an disorder of the child’s ADULT personality!? But then their whole trade is mumbo-jumbo psychobabble.

    Anyway there is no need for new diagnoses, existing diagnoses work just fine. For example a transman who needs top surgery could get it under a diagnosis of ICD-10 N62.0 Gynaecomastia (excessive breast growth). A transwoman under a diagnosis of ICD-10 Q52.4 and so on.

    The only thing that stops such diagnoses being used is the existence of mental illness diagnoses such as DSM-IV 302.85 GID.

    Counseling and guidance would be fine, but ONLY after Gender Dysphoria etc has been purged from the DSM and ICD. Until then mental health professionals cannot be trusted not to use those diagnoses. In practice they do use them and that is the problem.

  26. Look, isn’t she just trying to say we should be more like Samoa? Where the stress and the horror and the mental illness surrounding the trans state in the US doesn’t exist? Where a boy acting like a girl or a girl like a boy is regarded with just as much bemusement and accomodation as Tommy the Train? It should be the hope of everyone that one day future trans kids won’t need mental health care to get through childhood simply because the society they live in doesn’t handle things well. All she’s saying it is is possible to go too far in the other direction, and overtreat what doesn’t inherently need treatment.

  27. As the father of a gender non-conforming child, a boy who chose to present as female full time from age 3 or 4 to 8 or 9, I can tell you about the world where a boy can go to school in a skirt. At puberty, he began to norm his own behaviors and appear more gender neutral, which is a common path for those who will one day affirm a gay identity. He was never dysphoric. Outside of visits to a school counselor to check in on peer responses, he never saw a therapist. He’s fine. There were supportive professionals who think we went too far in allowing him to present as female outside the home, robbing him of his chance to socialize as conventionally male; there are trans activists who think we have missed the early intervention boat because we didn’t push him into therapy, didn’t push him to insist on female pronouns. And there are people in both camps who think we did the right things and my son is fine. By and large, the fear that trans activists will hormonally exterminate the gender queer with the unwitting aid of panicky reflexively homophobic parents who suddenly become un-transphobic, is overblown, in my opinion. Nobody makes these decisions lightly. In my experience, several kids whose parents have gotten ahead of them have been able to move back towards a gender queer / pre-gay identity. Suppression of non-conformity is still the dominant form of treatment, and the dominant problem in the culture. Too quick classification as ‘born in the wrong body’ is still a largely theoretical issue. We have yet to have a single child who has transitioned early recant their identity. When that starts happening, we can take this theoretical danger more seriously.

  28. This reminds me of Bill O’Riley being sure that gay marriage will lead to people marrying ducks. Allowing trans children to transition before puberty is not the same as a smoke-stack-ectomy. Sorry this has to be explained to you…

  29. As a parent of a gender queer child who is not well versed on all the correct “labels” and terminology that many of you use, I can share with you this in my simple terms. The emotions that my child faces are real. They are hard. They are dangerous if not listened to and supported through thoughtful parenting and whatever resources may be necessary.

    The many, many families and professionals that I have talked to, met and gotten to know over the past several years are not predetermining their child’s destiny, they are helping them find whatever it may be. The parents and professionals are making cautious steps toward a new way to help children transition, if and when, it may be the next step for their child to take.

    I may “only” be a parent of a gender queer child and shucks, just have my lowly Bachelor degree to go off of, but Ms. Dreger needs a refresher course in Child Development 101. At the age that parents and children are now talking about blockers to DELAY the onset of natural puberty and give precious time to make this decision, children are no longer pretending to be whatever they whimsically fancy at the moment. That is done at a much younger age and I have encountered no one in the medical, psychological or familial communities that is pushing any child this young to physically transition.

    We don’t live in Samoa, not even close. Comparisons of that nature are irrelevant for my child because that is not my child’s reality. To simply allow my child to “be” and ignore the very real distress and emotions that accompany living in our society as a gender queer child is in itself whimsical and misguided. Do we as parents seek out help, medical and psychological, for our children and ourselves? Yes. Does this mean we accept our children less? No. It means we are doing our job as parents by caring for them.

  30. As the parent of a transgender child and the executive director of TransYouth Family Allies I find the information presented here to be inaccurate at best and harmful at worst. One should not judge the decisions our parents are making based on what they assume our, and our children’s experience of their gender is. Prior to implying that we are imposing a rigid binary outcome on our children I would suggest that someone take up the task of actually studying what is going on. I’d like to see some real research done. Unless and until we see that research we will continue to do what we must to ensure that our children are happy and above all else…WE WILL DO WHAT WE MUST TO KEEP THEM ALIVE, HEALTHY AND WHOLE IN MIND, BODY AND SPIRIT!

    Kim Pearson
    Executive Director
    TransYouth Family Allies

  31. As the parent of a transgender child and the executive director of TransYouth Family Allies I find the information presented here to be inaccurate at best and harmful at worst. One should not judge the decisions our parents are making based on what they assume our, and our children’s experience of their gender is. Prior to implying that we are imposing a rigid binary outcome on our children I would suggest that someone take up the task of actually studying what is going on. I’d like to see some real research done. Unless and until we see that research we will continue to do what we must to ensure that our children are happy and above all else…WE WILL DO WHAT WE MUST TO KEEP THEM ALIVE, HEALTHY AND WHOLE IN MIND, BODY AND SPIRIT!

    Kim Pearson
    Executive Director
    TransYouth Family Allies

  32. Until you become the parent of a transgender child you never know what we go through and our children go through! Our children are trying to grow up and live happy normal lives just like anyone else. So until you do the research and actually see how wonderful these children are, then please be respectful and stop the hate and discrimination.

  33. Ah yes, Alice Dreger.

    Debate resumes on methods of psych professor’s research
    by Michael Gsovski
    Daily Northwestern
    February 27, 2008
    (http://tinyurl.com/349cbx)

    Excerpt:

    Last month, Robin Mathy filed ethics complaints against both Dreger and Bailey with the American Psychological Association, which accredits NU’s psychology department. Unlike the most vocal opponents of Dreger and Bailey’s work, Mathy is an accredited psychologist and a clinical research fellow at the University of Minnesota’s Medical School. She also filed a charge with the Illinois Board of Examiners of Psychology for Bailey’s alleged misrepresentation of himself as psychologist.

    Mathy’s charges focus on the professional connections between the board of the Archives of Sexual Behavior and Bailey. In the article, Bailey and Dreger both expressed that having sex with a research subject is not inherently wrong.

    Mathy said Dreger was wrong to submit her article to the ASB, which is edited by Kenneth Zucker, who has had contact with Bailey and has similar views on transsexuality. By doing this, she said Dreger sought to bypass the peer review process, which ensures research remains unbiased.

    “This is a blatant conflict of interest,” Mathy said. “(Dreger) exploited a key network friendship with Michael Bailey to get a truly horrible paper published.”

    Also: ‘Alice Dreger: The unethical ethicist?’ at http://tinyurl.com/3vuyfa7

  34. Ah yes, Alice Dreger.

    Debate resumes on methods of psych professor’s research
    by Michael Gsovski
    Daily Northwestern
    February 27, 2008
    (http://tinyurl.com/349cbx)

    Excerpt:

    Last month, Robin Mathy filed ethics complaints against both Dreger and Bailey with the American Psychological Association, which accredits NU’s psychology department. Unlike the most vocal opponents of Dreger and Bailey’s work, Mathy is an accredited psychologist and a clinical research fellow at the University of Minnesota’s Medical School. She also filed a charge with the Illinois Board of Examiners of Psychology for Bailey’s alleged misrepresentation of himself as psychologist.

    Mathy’s charges focus on the professional connections between the board of the Archives of Sexual Behavior and Bailey. In the article, Bailey and Dreger both expressed that having sex with a research subject is not inherently wrong.

    Mathy said Dreger was wrong to submit her article to the ASB, which is edited by Kenneth Zucker, who has had contact with Bailey and has similar views on transsexuality. By doing this, she said Dreger sought to bypass the peer review process, which ensures research remains unbiased.

    “This is a blatant conflict of interest,” Mathy said. “(Dreger) exploited a key network friendship with Michael Bailey to get a truly horrible paper published.”

    Also: ‘Alice Dreger: The unethical ethicist?’ at http://tinyurl.com/3vuyfa7

  35. Or perhaps this Alice Dreger:

    “In 2007, Hontas was the most prolific contributor to the transkids.us forum, posing as a “homosexual transsexual” in efforts to prop up Blanchard’s theory of transsexualism. The transkids.us website was created by Alice Dreger’s associate Kiira Triea, and at the time Dreger was extolling transkids.us in her defense of Bailey, Blanchard and Lawrence.

    Unfortunately for Dreger, the transkids.us website has since been exposed as a hoax. Nevertheless, Hontas was lavished with attention by the Clarke/Northwestern crowd for her contributions to that hoax, even though it didn’t work out for Dreger and Bailey.

    Hontas’ activities now appear aimed at supporting the overall “DSD movement” in sexology – i.e., the medicalization and pathologization of intersex and transgender identities being pushed by Zucker, Dreger and Cantor. For background on that movement, see the open letter by OII to WPATH.

  36. The article is pointing out that the research suggests most children will grow out of childhood gender dysphoria, and therefore allowing a child to live transgender at a young age (5 or 6) may not be the best idea if the child can live otherwise.
    The trans advocates seem to be hostile to the very IDEA of desistance of childhood GID. Hopefully the therapists involved are looking for the signs of desistance because from my experience the parents once the child transitions are not.

  37. The Intersex people are not happy with the way Dreger “advocated” for them:

    “Alice Dreger, the DSD activist and self proclaimed advocate, who bills herself as a bioethicist has over the past few years become mired by one ethical scandal after another. Just to mention a few of her scandals, let me start with what will be one of the major setbacks in intersex history. It was Alice Dreger who was one of the prime movers of the shift from “intersex” to DSD, “disorders of sex development”. She did this by consulting with doctors and determining what worked for them and consulted the intersex community after the change had been made. Quite unethical for an ethicist because there is practically no support for this replacement of the term “intersex” with “disorders of sex development” and the ensuing Consensus Statement (1) which approved this change of terminology which elaborated a set of protocols that are a major setback for intersex people with surgery being recommended between two and six months of age. (2) This was a scandal of historical proportions.

    After controlling intersex activism for over a decade and leaving it in shambles, she decided to move on to transgender activism. And already she is becoming the same divisive “activist” in the transgender movement that she was in the intersex movement. She has begun by taking sides with the gatekeepers of the trans movement, just as she placed herself with the gatekeepers of the intersex community and then left us with a more pathological terminology and set of protocols based on intersex being a genetic defect. (3)

    As she started her trans activism, many of us in the intersex movement saw the same pattern slowly emerge that had been her hallmark within the intersex movement – siding with proponents of a highly problematic, pathological definition of transsexualism and attacking any opponents who resisted the academic and discursive control she was usurping over their own right to self definition and in determining their own sociopolitical agenda without having to contend with another interloper who had no experiential understanding of trans issues.”

  38. @41 Alice Dreger may indeed be an unethical academic; but to attack her as a person rather than debunking her theories is counterproductive.

    @40 >> therefore allowing a child to live transgender at a young age (5 or 6) may not be the best idea if the child can live otherwise.
    The trans advocates seem to be hostile to the very IDEA of desistance of childhood GID.

    Queer kids of 5 or 6 just need to be let be. If they want to tell the world that they are a boy or a girl or for that matter a railway locomotive it should be OK.

    I’m not sure what desistance means metaphorically; literally it means choosing not to eat something, such as a psychotropic mushroom.

    Certainly the very idea of GIDC is wrong at its core and opposed by most transgender adults. It is a mental illness and queer kids are not mentally ill in regards to their queerness. They might perhaps be anxious as a result of gender bullying, so diagnose them with an anxiety disorder if you must. But not a gender disorder for their gender is not the problem.

    In the same way a person who has cancer or hare lip may be depressed or anxious about their cancer or hare lip – but you don’t diagnose them with a Hare Identity Disorder or some money grubbing such nonsense.

  39. @40, @42:

    First, my posts were not meant to be used as an ad hominem fallacy in regard to Dreger’s theories. They were meant as a warning regarding her character and her history of ‘advocacy’. There is a subtle but real difference when you are parenting a child and have to make decisions based not only on theory but also on the character and history of the person pushing certain treatments.

    Now, on to the heart of the matter. I am the parent of a trans kid. I’ve met dozens of trans kids and parents, and worked with people who have met hundreds. Given the prevalence, it’s a statistically significant sample. Let me make this perfectly clear: I have never met or heard of a parent that pushes their child to become or remain, trans. We enable them to be themselves, with whatever identity they require and it has proven to be the most healthy and productive choice of any. Tragic history has shown that even if someone tried otherwise, they fail.

    To the person, the parents I have encountered want to minimize damage done to their children. They respect their child’s determination of Self and still remain responsible parents. They also recognize that many if not most gender variant children turn out to be gay once they hit puberty, specifically those that enjoy cross gender play behaviors but do not proclaim that they actually are the sex opposite the one assigned at birth. Ms. Dreger, Bailey and Zucker on the other hand, still push the ideas and treatments used by John Money and George Rekers in the 1970’s. You know, the ones that result in the suicide of the patients years later. The ones that feel any outcome is better than a child growing up to be transsexual. We have chosen not to follow that path for our kids.

    Alice Dreger, like her cohorts in the DSM working group, attempt to erase the existence of what have classically been called, ‘transsexuals’ in favor of those that are genderqueer and or gay-but-conforming. The tactic used is a common one today, that of accusing the opposition of exactly the same behavior. But they ignore the history of their own failures to effect cure. They also conveniently ignore all research and the knowledge gained in the more rigorous disciplines such as neurology and endocrinology. You know, the ones that show conclusively that trans people really *do* have the neural features that match their proclaimed identity. 15 years of built-upon knowledge, ignored. But that’s okay, ’cause real science is *hard*.

    What I would like to see from Ms. Dreger is an acknowledgment that a percentage of trans kids actually *do* have body dysphoria and actually *do* need to be respected in their declaration of who they are. And that those kids as a group do not revert to their assigned gender. Nowhere does she even give them a chance, instead preferring to concentrate solely on this imaginary group of children that are virtually forced into transition by their parents. It’s a falsehood and it’s unethical.

    I’d also like to see some sources, studies other than Zucker and Bailey, et all, and even more so, these unidentified parents that she seems to see everywhere that seemingly wish to squash their child’s identity rather than foster it, whatever it may turn out to be someday.

    We parents of trans kids cherish our children in whatever form, expression or social role they decide to grow into. Ms. Dreger on the other hand, seeks to rile up both the conservatives and the genderqueer among us not realizing that some of both groups *are* us.

    -Sara

  40. Background (some readers are unfamiliar with it) –

    A guy named Ray Blanchard in Toronto proposed that there are two types of male-to-female transsexuals: the “homosexual” type, feminine boys who transition young rather than face the fact that they’re gay, and “autogynephilics”, men who are erotically obsessed with the idea of themselves as female, who are allegedly not feminine, transition late, prefer female partners, and are not, in Blanchard’s view, women in any sense (even if Blanchard et al. are ok with physical treatments).

    In short – if you’re an mtf trans person, you’re either in denial or have an autoerotic paraphilia.

    J Michael Bailey is a Blanchard acolyte at Northwestern in Illinois, who has based his “research” on anecdotes about people he met while hanging out in gay bars.

    He has pissed off many mtf trans women because he insists that if they say they don’t fit either of the Blanchard models, they’re lying. Trans men (ftm) are not dreamt of in Bailey’s philosophy. Maybe they would complicate matters too much.

    Dreger has been a diligent defender of Bailey. Given the Blanchard/Bailey/Dreger assumption that the experts (them, it turns out) know you better than you know yourself, to start off with the Tommy the locomotive story reads to me like a deliberate, condescending provocation. Certainly let’s not put kids on an irreversible path when they’re less than 10 years old, but everyone I know with a trans identity (male or female) says they were aware of it by that age. We need to listen to these kids, to let them teach us about themselves.

    I can agree that in a better world people could claim whatever gender identity they felt was right for them, without a need for surgery or hormones. But I’m not sure that would entirely eliminate everyone’s need for physical modification.
    ———–

    @7 – being a woman is not just a matter of not having a penis.

    @21 – clear thinking, well expressed. thank you. (recognizing of course that what works for you might not work for some others.)

  41. I am a transman and totally agree to give kids room to explore and that a decision to physically and chemically alter ones body should not be taken lightly. I knew when I was very young but coming from the south did not have the language to express it or any trans example. I began my official transition in my 40’s.
    I also appauld you for saying and agree with the fact that it is the push and pull of our bianary gender stuck society that pressures people into feeling like they have to alter their bodies.

    Great article

  42. As a MTF transsexual, anyone affiliated with Blanchard as closely as Dreger is automatically has no credence. Surely you must know that.
    Any debate The Stranger tries to enflame by giving Dreger a platform is just angels dancing on the head of a pin to us … just intellectual fascination for straight folks with no connection to the real world.
    And those of us who are living this, and the parents of transsexuals, are just laughing at you all.

  43. @44, I totally believe that most/all folks (especially MTF) who identify as trans as adults report having known that they had that gender identity at a young age. What that doesn’t address is how many people who would have had that gender identity at a young age went on to later identify with the sex assigned them at birth. I would agree that giving everyone space to live as they wish without requiring strict adherence would be the best idea. Certainly I can see how puberty and the naturally irreversible sex-identifying consequences thereof force everyone’s hand. What I’m not sure is what parents of potentially-trans kids want between the ages of 4 and puberty that is different than what Alice Dreger is advocating. What else is needed byond some room, some understanding and perhaps letting kids know that feeling uncomfortable in one’s body or identifying as the other gender happens sometimes and if it continues there will be ways to deal with that down the road.

  44. You know – the problem really is with society. Just look at the Two Spirit people who have been on our continent since long before the Europeans got here.

    When there was no surgery available, there was no need for it. People just accepted, as is made clear in the film “Two Spirits” that there are boys in boy’s bodies, boys in girl’s bodies, girls in girl’s bodies, and girls in boy’s bodies.

    The real problem comes from a world view that says everything is one thing or the other – and there is no room for anything else. Something is good, or it is bad. A person is a girl, or a boy. A person is either homosexual, or they are a pervert.

    In this world view, a boy who knows they are a girl is condemned from the word go. We have come a long way from the days when 50% of transsexuals were dead by the age of 30, but we haven’t come as far as we need. Just look at the bathroom bills, the struggles to get proper identification, the marriage laws based on “birth sex”. Look at people being arrested and charged with trespassing or other offenses for the “crime” of needing to pee.

    This is still an exceptionally difficult world to live in as a transgendered person. As long as we live in an “either-or” world, it will remain so. We need to move forward and catch up with the societies that existed when the White man first came to this continent.

  45. Wow, so The Stranger, under the tutelage of transphobe Dan Savage, invites Alice Dreger to be the sole voice of trans issues in a queer-themed issue. How positively progressive of them! I guess actual intelligent TRANS people (we even have our own Ph.D.’s now! Imagine that?) were just totally unavailable, eh? Even a cursory Google search will quickly reveal that Alice has a long history of exploiting intersex and trans people, and that the communities she is supposedly advocating on behalf of find her views repugnant, offensive, and dangerous. Alice thrives on controversy and loves coming to the defense of the boys, like Zucker, Bailey and Blanchard, to curry favor with the gender oppressors. This article, comparing trans kids existential struggles to being a train, is beneath comment. It is yet another pathetic attempt to milk controversy out of a horribly oppressed community to move her own dreary academic career forward. Luckily, right-leaning straight cis people are the only ones to give Dreger any attention any more. Any person with a shred of progressive values in the queer and trans communities view her as the shrill bigot that she is.

  46. You know – the problem really is with society. Just look at the Two Spirit people who have been on our continent since long before the Europeans got here.

    When there was no surgery available, there was no need for it. People just accepted, as is made clear in the film “Two Spirits” that there are boys in boy’s bodies, boys in girl’s bodies, girls in girl’s bodies, and girls in boy’s bodies.

    The real problem comes from a world view that says everything is one thing or the other – and there is no room for anything else. Something is good, or it is bad. A person is a girl, or a boy. A person is either homosexual, or they are a pervert.

    In this world view, a boy who knows they are a girl is condemned from the word go. We have come a long way from the days when 50% of transsexuals were dead by the age of 30, but we haven’t come as far as we need. Just look at the bathroom bills, the struggles to get proper identification, the marriage laws based on “birth sex”. Look at people being arrested and charged with trespassing or other offenses for the “crime” of needing to pee.

    This is still an exceptionally difficult world to live in as a transgendered person. As long as we live in an “either-or” world, it will remain so. We need to move forward and catch up with the societies that existed when the White man first came to this continent.

Comments are closed.