
I am a twenty-something gay man. Currently in the process of trying to get back together with my ex-boyfriend who is in his late-forties. We previously dated for a two years when we were living in the same city, and then tried a year of long distance when I moved away for a job. He has always earned substantially more money than I do, and provided us with a very comfortable life when we were together, but that power dynamic also bled into creating some issues that ultimately ended the relationship. He and I separately sought therapy to work through these issues, and a month ago we began to entertain the idea of getting back together. We are now communicating on a level that we never were before; the change is incredible, and it really seems like we are both ready to make compromises to make this relationship work. However, during the nine months we were apart he has explored a lot about his sexuality, and I am concerned we may no longer be sexually compatible.
During our original relationship, I allowed us to be open to make the long-distance situation easier for the both of us. We are both on PrEP, but I still asked him to wear condoms outside of the relationship, and to my knowledge he followed this rule. In our recent discussions he has admitted he resented me for making condom use a requirement outside of the relationship, and he does not want to wear them anymore. He says most of his friends do not wear condoms and wearing condoms makes it difficult for him to maintain an erection and achieve an orgasm. He also says he enjoys the “kink” of having sex without them, especially in a group setting. I know he has sex with people I would consider “high-risk,” and it makes me uncomfortable that he not only refuses to wear condoms with these individuals, but also that the idea of STI transmission is not a concern of his when hooking up.
Since we have been apart, he has also been having a lot of group sex both locally and at large international group sex parties/clubs. Recently we have gone on a few trips together, and he has pushed the idea of having a third join us in bed or going to a bathhouse. He also has been asking me to hook up with other people alone so I can tell him about it. We never did this before. I know the idea of sharing me or seeing/hearing about me with someone else is a turn on for him. However, to me, it seems like any group sex or sex outside of the relationship is inappropriate right now, while we are trying to rekindle the flame between us.
I am not a prude. I enjoy a wild sexual relationship. However, I also want to do all of these things in a healthy manner. I feel like he is asking me to compromise on my sexual health to make this relationship work and that concerns me. I also feel like his extreme focus on group sex and me having sex with others diminishes my identity and the romance of our relationship. I love this man, but I am stuck and not sure how to move forward.
Gay Relationship On Upswing Previously
Alone, GROUP, you move forward alone.
Your boyfriend’s interests are valid—some people wanna have a lotta sex with a lotta people—and there’s a large cohort of gay men out there who share his passion for international group sex parties and condom-free sex with anonymous or nearly-anonymous partners. You aren’t one of them. And while the kind of sex your boyfriend is passionate about presents no risk for HIV transmission so long he’s on PrEP, GROUP, it does put your ex at substantial and growing risk for a host of other sexually transmitted infections. As the New York Times reported last week…
The number of combined cases of syphilis, gonorrhea and chlamydia in the United States rose to a record high last year… More than 2.4 million syphilis, gonorrhea and chlamydia infections were reported in the United States in 2018, an increase of more than 100,000 cases from the previous year, the center said in its annual Sexually Transmitted Disease Surveillance Report. It attributed the increase to several factors, including a decline in condom use among young people and men who have sex with men; increased screening among some groups; and cuts to sexual health programs at the state and local level, which led to clinic closures and fewer opportunities for counseling or testing for sexually transmitted diseases.
PrEP is great and “undetectable = untransmittable” and the combo of negative guys on PrEP and positive guys with undetectable viral loads could drive down HIV infection rates—more aggressive campaigns to get sexually active gay and bi men on PrEP (which will now be available over the counter in California) and more positive guys in treatment “could end HIV.” (Please listen to this episode of the New York Times‘ The Daily podcast to learn why PrEP hasn’t ended HIV.) But guys on PrEP forgoing condoms because they’re not concerned about HIV has contributed to risings rates of syphilis, gonorrhea, and chlamydia.
Back to you GROUP: you aren’t comfortable with the risk—the near certainty—that your ex-boyfriend will wind up contracting an STI if he stops using condoms at group sex parties and during hookups with randos… an STI he will likely pass on to you… and your ex-boyfriend has informed you that he fully intends to stop using condoms in your absence… if he was using them consistently or at all… which means he’s placed you in the position of having to choose between compromising on your sexual health or resuming this relationship… and so if the safety/condom thing is non-negotiable for you, GROUP, then it’s obvious you shouldn’t get back together with your ex-boyfriend.
Another thing arguing against getting back together with your boyfriend: the way he’s pressuring you to have sex with other guys. Just as there are people out there who wanna have a lotta sex with a lotta people and that’s fine (but people need to cognizant of the inherent risks and control for them), there are people out there who get off on watching their partners get with other people and/or hearing about their partners getting with (having gotten with?) other people. And that’s fine… so long their partners get off on getting with other people. But the idea does not appeal to you, GROUP, and you don’t think it’s possible—possible for you emotionally—to get with others while attempting to reconnect with your ex. Another sign you aren’t right for each other.
Finally, GROUP, there’s wanting to see your partner with get with others and then there’s wanting your partner to be your sex avatar. If your ex was into you and into you enjoying yourself sexually, he wouldn’t be pressuring you to this thing that only turns him on. He’d be trying to figure out what turns you on and encouraging you to do more of that with or without him. Wanting your sexual adventures to come in the context of a loving, committed, stable relationship—open or not—doesn’t make you a prude. You want to have an amazing sex life with a guy you love, not be some sort of gay sex action figure for your boyfriend to live vicariously through.
Move on, GROUP, alone for now but hopefully not forever.
Impeach the motherfucker already! Get your ITMFA buttons, t-shirts, hats and lapel pins and coffee mugs at www.ITMFA.org!
Tickets to HUMP 2019 are on sale now! Get them here!
