On my way out of Cauleen Smith’s Give It or Leave It at the Frye Art Museum, a tweet I’d seen recently sprang to mind. Reflecting on something her friend had said, New York journalist and critic Jillian Steinhauer tweeted out to the world, “Just retract all my mixed reviews and replace them with ‘almost kind of a commentary on something.'”
Give It or Leave It is almost, kind of a commentary on something. That doesn’t mean that it’s bad or unenjoyable. I enjoyed myself while ambling around the show—the colored gels over the windows, the projected tableaus, the disco balls. But there’s a murkiness, a jumbledness, an obscure frame of reference that feels untethered and makes the ultimate message of the exhibition unsettled. It’s an “almost, kind of” deeply touching meditation on black generosity and spirituality.
