Now at Seattle Art Museum: Antoine Vollon, Mound of Butter, 1875/1885.
Now at Seattle Art Museum: Antoine Vollon, Mound of Butter, 1875/1885. Courtesy of the National Gallery of Art

Antoine Vollon is a name I’d never heard before when a Seattle Art Museum spokeswoman whispered to me about one of his paintings.

“You have to see Mound of Butter,” she said. We were at the press preview for the traveling exhibition Intimate Impressionism from the National Gallery of Art. “It’s the entire staff’s favorite.”

I had my doubts, but the title was mildly suggestive and syllabically perverse, which seemed promising. Just roll that gluttonous cud of words around in your mouth: Mound of Butter, Mound of Butter.

And then I saw it.

The painting is small, just two feet tall. But the butter, set off by the eggs, is monumental. One hundred and forty years after it was painted, the strokes of yellow-brown paint still glisten with seeming wetness. And what an anxiety-inducing glistening wetness!

The realism is so visceral, the butter so tempting, that this is the definition of mouth-watering painting. It wants you to eat it, and you want to eat it. This art is biological. We are wired for it.

But that’s disturbing, because when butter glistens like this, it may be rancid. This quivering, enticing mound of butter is a vector for disease, for flies and insects and rats, and it won’t be kept fresh by that meringue of cheesecloth, which is nothing but a wispy veil, a passing whir of cirrus clouds.

Maybe you’re being paranoid. Maybe the butter is fresh, just fine to eat. It’s a real possibility, given that innocent patch of cleaner, lighter yellow right in the center of the mound.

But even if the butter is fresh, you think, it’s still a glut, a glop, a nauseating heap. Have I ever seen that much butter in one hunk? It’s just too much butter for one person to consider. I can imagine how much I’d have to eat to use it all. Or, a horror of luxury—I imagine having to eat the butter by itself, in gobs that just slide down the throat and slither around inside.

When Vollon made Mound of Butter, was he using an actual mound of butter as his model? Did it smell worse every day?

This is a zoomed-in view of the painting on the National Gallery of Arts web site. Look more closely at the buttery paint for yourself.
This is a zoomed-in view of the painting on the National Gallery of Art’s web site. Look more closely at the buttery paint for yourself. Courtesy of the National Gallery of Art

“I don’t know anything about him, either,” says SAM curator Chiyo Ishikawa, and her specialty is European painting.

She sits down on a bench facing Mound of Butter to admire it in all its perverse glory.

Mound of Butter is legendary—to those who know about it.

Offhandedly one day recently, I started to recommend Mound of Butter to the artist Jeffry Mitchell. He interrupted me. “I saw that painting in a newspaper years ago, and cut it out!”

Can anyone possibly miss the dick joke of the painting? You see it, right? Now you will never be able to un-see it; sorry/not sorry? Mound of Butter is a whole treasure trove of interpretive possibilities. Let me give you a few others to cleanse the palate, as it were. One writer compares the butter to a mountain, a glacier, and a severed head with the knife still at its throat, calling it a possible commentary on everything from revolution to food-storage technology to Salome to the disequilibrium of France’s nationalistic cuisine (given the precarity of the egg that looks like it may roll off the table).

A few fun facts about Vollon: Manet once insulted him (if Wikipedia is to be believed). He was the subject of a 2004 New York gallery exhibition meant to rescue him from obscurity—an exhibition involving a few also-strange paintings of monkeys, one monkey frying some eggs—but Grace Glueck for the New York Times declared him not “Truly Important.”

Ouch, Grace Glueck. But nevermind the rest of Vollon’s works. We’ll always have Mound of Butter.

Jen Graves (The Stranger’s former arts critic) mostly writes about things you approach with your eyeballs. But she’s also a history nerd interested in anything that needs more talking about, from male...