CHEERS: Seattle Art Museum toasts the opening of Seattle Art Fair last week at the booth of New York gallery Sapar Contemporary. The small sculptures on the wall, by Shinji Turner-Yamamoto, were a hit, appreciated by Seattle Art Museum curator of modern and contemporary art Catharina Manchanda and others. Credit: Malcolm Smith
CHEERS: Seattle Art Museum toasts the opening of Seattle Art Fair last week at the booth of New York gallery Sapar Contemporary. The small sculptures on the wall, by Shinji Turner-Yamamoto, were a hit, appreciated by Seattle Art Museum curator of modern and contemporary art Catharina Manchanda and others.
CHEERS: Seattle Art Museum curator Catharina Manchanda, left, toasts the opening of Seattle Art Fair last week at the booth of New York gallery Sapar Contemporary. The small sculptures on the wall, by Shinji Turner-Yamamoto, were a hit, appreciated by SAM director Kimerly Rorschach (not pictured) and others. Malcolm Smith

Just like last year, when the announcement came over the loudspeaker at 6 p.m. on Sunday that the Seattle Art Fair was closed, people applauded. But this time, the applause was a little more sparse, a little more nervous. Fair organizer Max Fishko said people clap only in Seattle. The desire for success is so strong.

It’s strong in me. It’s why I did more listening than looking at the fair last weekend, even though I like looking at art about 11 times more than talking to random strangers. I’m trying to crack the code of this thing. Who were these 18,000 people who showed up during the fair’s four days? Why did they stand in an opening-night line that stretched two football fields long? Can Seattle Art Fair, which just finished its second year, survive in the long term? Can it be good for art and culture in Seattle in general?

I patrolled the CenturyLink Field Event Center on Thursday, Friday, Saturday, and Sunday, pulling people over on any minor pretext, especially for breaches of the normal social order that offered hope that the art fair might cross over and catch on. Kathy Creahan and David Funke’s breach was that they showed up wearing Mariners gear and looked like they were in the neighborhood primarily to go to the baseball game. How’d they get in here? With a $20-a-day entrance fee, they had to be here on purpose.

Jen Graves (The Stranger’s former arts critic) mostly writes about things you approach with your eyeballs. But she’s also a history nerd interested in anything that needs more talking about, from male...