Yeah sure, I may be the crusty, old resident crank who opposes privatizing Washington’s lucrative state store system, yet in reporting on the legislature’s latest such bill in this week’s Stranger, I at least attempt to be evenhanded, opening up with a litany of theoretical justifications in favor. Shorter Goldy: there are several reasonable pro-privatization arguments to be made, but enhancing state revenues ain’t one of ’em… a thesis that will surely be borne out once the bill’s fiscal note comes through.
From the consumer’s perspective, there’s absolutely no question that ending the state’s retail liquor monopoly will result in substantially improved convenience and selection. Desperately need a bottle of bourbon at 3 AM? Just head on down to the local Safeway. Crave a pricey, rare, and unpronounceable fifth of single malt scotch? No doubt some specialty retailer will cater to your faddish fetish for smoked-dirt-flavored booze.
As for price, dream on. Liquor and cigarettes are the two items neither party minds taxing, so it’s always going to be relatively expensive here. You may save a few pennies on your half-gallon jug of Kirkland brand rotgut, but Washington will never be a cheap booze state. Never.
But the argument one most frequently hears in favor of privatization—the most emotional and vitriolic argument, and thus by far the most effective—is that government simply doesn’t belong in the liquor business, or as I write in The Stranger, “80 years after the end of Prohibition, it just seems weird for the state to be operating a chain of liquor stores.”
But rhetorically effective or not, that’s not an argument. It’s an excuse. And it’s based on a purely ideological assumption that no one ever, ever challenges.
For example, in its latest pontifical poke at the issue, the Seattle Times editorial board flatly asserts that “privatizing liquor makes sense,” without bothering to explain for whom or why. Does it make sense because it diverts hundreds of millions of dollars in profits from state coffers into the private sector, or because the only way to make up that revenue via taxes would be to dramatically increase consumption, with all the social, economic and governmental costs that entails? If that’s a plus for our state—if they really do believe that Washington would be better off if we all drank more liquor—then the government-doesn’t-belong-in-the-liquor-business crowd needs to explain why. I mean, if government doesn’t belong in the liquor business, there must be some societal good that would be achieved through privatization, right?
No, let’s be honest, the real reason many folks believe that government doesn’t belong in the liquor business is because it’s socialism or something, and that’s uniformly bad, I guess, regardless of the obvious benefits to the state in terms of increased revenue, decreased abuse and lower regulatory costs. More underage drinking? Well, at least it’s not socialism. More DUI’s? Well, at least it’s not socialism. More domestic violence? Well, at least it’s not socialism. And so on.
In other words, it’s a stupid, fucking lazy argument that should have no legitimate place in a policy debate without further and detailed explication, especially at this time of intractable budget crises. We simply don’t have the luxury to shutter state liquor stores just because some people think they look weird.
That said, there’s always convenience and selection, and if you think that’s worth the added human, social, public health, law enforcement, regulatory, and budgetary cost, well then, I guess we’ll just have to agree to disagree. But don’t just spew this “government doesn’t belong in the liquor business” bullshit at me, because it’s exactly that, and I’m not prepared to accept these costs for the sake of a lazy, free market, ideological reflex.

Why do we necessarily have to have either full privatization or a state monopoly? Why don’t we think about maybe keeping the state-run liquor stores and distribution but also allowing some private permits for, say, stores that want to specialize in obscure scotch or sherry or what-have-you? Or, fuck it, just issue permits to whoever but keep the state stores- that will force them to adopt methods to keep their costs down and ensure efficiency, right? It’s not like we don’t have public services that compete with private companies offering essentially the same thing (USPS v. UPS).
Also, Fnarf brings up a good point about how much money they’re really making right now. I’d love to see numbers, and compare those to private company profits and projected tax earnings in a privatized scenario.
It occurs to me that the Post Office is probably run at a deficit, but I still think it’s a discussion worth having.
I’m dumbstruck by the argument I’ve heard from some people, that they would be willing to pay more and don’t care about the massively increased number of fatalities, DUIs, and health problems, all because they’re willing to “Pay for convenience”. The nearest liquor store? Same distance as the grocery store.
This is America, this is how it works here, I guess.
@51, the Post Office loses money because it is legally obligated to provide services that no other shipping company is — junk mail delivery, RFD, first-class mail for pennies. On their package delivery business, they’re competitive with UPS and FedEx.
But those are SERVICES, not goods. And they are services that no one else would ever provide if they weren’t required to by law — running Sears catalogs out to remote houses in Montana for a buck? No way.
The connection to bottles of spirits is nonexistent.
@53, you’re not very smart, are you? Or honest?
You’ve got “Pay for convenience” in quotes there, but the only one saying that is you. You’re lying, in other words.
If you actually listened to the arguments people are making, you’d hear something very different. But neither you or Goldy have any interest at all in the true story, do you?
Like this: “massively increased fatalities”. Care to back that up? Good luck, because it isn’t true. You’re making it up, and you are FULL OF IT.
@53: You too: Facts to back up that statement or it’s just more bullshit. But of course, you don’t have them, any more than Goldy does. I guess you must just enjoy the smell.
Alright, Goldy, since you’ve admitted you don’t have facts by your silence, let me entreat you to be a man about this and stop posting about liquor privatization.
The “social good” of a free (or freer) market system is lower prices and better selection. You disagree with that scenario simply because you want booze to be high-priced. You are absolutely correct that if you want a system to be costly and inefficient for the consumer, then government is the way to go.
@9 Your argument appealing to tradition is no better than a straw man argument. Learn to debate.
The state has not been marrying men to each other for longer than 80 years yet we can all agree here that is where we need to go in the future. It is the right thing to do in line with our ideology. History is full of states starting and stopping all kinds of activities as we decide what is right and wrong. It is time we ditch monopolizing liquor sales to the state. This is a classic example of why the fundies call “big spender liberals” addicted to taxes. They know that once the revenue flows we won’t ever want to let go.
@54: That was just one (admittedly poor) example. Though I guess it’s all moot because, hey, we’re just a couple of assholes on the internet.
It’s a lazy argument either way. Let me pose a question back to you. Why aren’t cigarettes sold only in state-run stores? How about diet pills? How about cough medicine? These substances and drugs sold in state stores would increase revenues, decrease abuse, and lower regulatory costs. Why is booze special and requiring the state to be our Moms to make sure it is controlled?
Also keep in mind that every single study on this has shown that privatizing alcohol sales increases alcohol outlets and availability, which in turn increases social and health care costs for the state. Which in turn means taxes have to go up again. No way does this ever end up saving the state any money — never found a single study supporting that.
This brief, put out by the Alcohol & Drug Abuse Institute librarians at the UW summarizes the current research on privatization and its impact on crime, society, health, etc. costs: http://lib.adai.washington.edu/resourceb….
I’m glad we’re at least not going to be dumb enough to just give the whole damn thing away for FREE this time, but it’s still going to cost the state more money in the long-run if it increases availability. That’s just a fact.
Goldy, Meg @ 62 did what you should have done.
Thank, Meg, for that info. It looks like there may be something to Goldy’s arguments after all.
Here’s something to chew over:
Washington, of course, has a monopoly over spirits only. That does tend to weaken the argument about how much greater alcohol consumption will be in privatization comes about.
I don’t see how that weakens the argument, @64. If you lower availability of both types, you get larger consumption reductions than if you just lower availability of one type — that’s common sense. Also common sense: the opposite.
@62, the UW is a full-on prohibitionist organization and always has been one. The righties want to take away our condoms and the lefty boffins want to take away our booze. SCREW YOU BOTH.
Your magic studies don’t have an answer for the question, why would states that lift restrictions suffer huge increases in these social problems far above and beyond the states that never had them in the first place? Or why Washington’s alcohol problem rate is so much higher than other states even with these restrictions in place?
There is absolutely no evidence that the restrictions themselves are causes of the absence of harm. There is, however, a very good possibility that the restrictions themselves — and thus the absence of the development of adult responsibility — cause harm. Maybe we’re all drunks because we have never had to learn how to be trusted.
That’s the real message of the Seattle way. Notice that every fully civilized city in the world allows drinking in public, at the zoo, in parks, at festivals, in open and comfortable circumstances, without any harm whatsoever and in fact the opposite of harm, the wide appreciation of human happiness: BUT NOT THIS ONE.
Your puritanical bent is ruining the happiness of everyone, because happiness and pleasure are the enemies of shame, and shame is your currency and your control measure. Screw you people.
@ 65, it means that privatization in Washington won’t lead to as large an increase in consumption as it would if your state also had a monopoly on beer, and thus won’t lead to as great an increase in the costs associated with increased consumption.
Basically, it comes down to how much of a trade off Washington citizens will be willing to make. A smaller tradeoff is a weaker argument than a larger tradeoff.
@64 I’m pretty sure Washington state still has a monopoly over wholesale purchases of wine and beer like many other states that don’t have state-run stores.
@ 68, maybe so. I read that statement to mean that some states allow sales of beer and wine only through state-run stores, and that’s definitely not the case in WA.
@66 In fact, I don’t have a puritanical bent on this at all and neither does the institute I work for at the UW (man, you could not be more far-off in that regard — some of us are pro-legalization for all drugs, for pity’s sake! And we certainly don’t demonize substance use. You obviously have no idea what we do here.).
My job as a librarian is to present the research without bias, and that’s what I did in that brief. I didn’t find any research articles that supported the opposite point of view — if I had, I would’ve included them. If you find any, let me know and I’ll add them to the brief if they’re valid.
As for this sentence: “There is absolutely no evidence that the restrictions themselves are causes of the absence of harm” — that’s absolutely false, sir. Read the research. The connection is direct, not coincidental.
As for your question about why Washington has higher rates of alcohol use than states that have privatized liquor sales, I don’t know. Northern states tend overall to have higher rates of alcohol use than Southern states. I’m not sure what accounts for that. Haven’t looked into it.
But all I’m trying to say here is that if you think privatization is going to save the state money, you’re wrong — you’re not factoring in increased social and health care costs. Personally, I’d be happy to be able to buy tequila in my grocery store. I’m just not expecting it to be any cheaper, and I’m expecting my taxes to go up down the line as crime, DUI/DWI, and alcohol-related health issues increase. Will they increase massively? Probably not. But they’ll increase enough to impact the state’s finances. Just keep that in mind, is all I’m saying.
By the way, here’s what the CDC has to say about alcohol privatization, based on their own research: http://www.thecommunityguide.org/alcohol…
Is it bad that I don’t trust studies on topics that directly relate to the funding of the people doing the studies?
@70 I’m going to go out on a limb and say that the increase in alcoholism *might* be tied to the soul-crushing cold weather we deal with for a majority of the year.
@62,
A significant number of links in that brief claim the exact opposite. Most don’t even mention the supposed costs of privatizing liquor sales.
@73: There is some truth to that. There is a strong positive correlation between cold weather and alcohol use.
This whole thread has pissed me off so much that I’m going home and drink gin and tonics all night long. Which, fortunately, I purchased in Las Vegas before I left there, at a convenience store, at an odd hour of the night, for about $10 less than the same bottle would be here.