Yeah sure, I may be the crusty, old resident crank who opposes privatizing Washington’s lucrative state store system, yet in reporting on the legislature’s latest such bill in this week’s Stranger, I at least attempt to be evenhanded, opening up with a litany of theoretical justifications in favor. Shorter Goldy: there are several reasonable pro-privatization arguments to be made, but enhancing state revenues ain’t one of ’em… a thesis that will surely be borne out once the bill’s fiscal note comes through.
From the consumer’s perspective, there’s absolutely no question that ending the state’s retail liquor monopoly will result in substantially improved convenience and selection. Desperately need a bottle of bourbon at 3 AM? Just head on down to the local Safeway. Crave a pricey, rare, and unpronounceable fifth of single malt scotch? No doubt some specialty retailer will cater to your faddish fetish for smoked-dirt-flavored booze.
As for price, dream on. Liquor and cigarettes are the two items neither party minds taxing, so it’s always going to be relatively expensive here. You may save a few pennies on your half-gallon jug of Kirkland brand rotgut, but Washington will never be a cheap booze state. Never.
But the argument one most frequently hears in favor of privatization—the most emotional and vitriolic argument, and thus by far the most effective—is that government simply doesn’t belong in the liquor business, or as I write in The Stranger, “80 years after the end of Prohibition, it just seems weird for the state to be operating a chain of liquor stores.”
But rhetorically effective or not, that’s not an argument. It’s an excuse. And it’s based on a purely ideological assumption that no one ever, ever challenges.
For example, in its latest pontifical poke at the issue, the Seattle Times editorial board flatly asserts that “privatizing liquor makes sense,” without bothering to explain for whom or why. Does it make sense because it diverts hundreds of millions of dollars in profits from state coffers into the private sector, or because the only way to make up that revenue via taxes would be to dramatically increase consumption, with all the social, economic and governmental costs that entails? If that’s a plus for our state—if they really do believe that Washington would be better off if we all drank more liquor—then the government-doesn’t-belong-in-the-liquor-business crowd needs to explain why. I mean, if government doesn’t belong in the liquor business, there must be some societal good that would be achieved through privatization, right?
No, let’s be honest, the real reason many folks believe that government doesn’t belong in the liquor business is because it’s socialism or something, and that’s uniformly bad, I guess, regardless of the obvious benefits to the state in terms of increased revenue, decreased abuse and lower regulatory costs. More underage drinking? Well, at least it’s not socialism. More DUI’s? Well, at least it’s not socialism. More domestic violence? Well, at least it’s not socialism. And so on.
In other words, it’s a stupid, fucking lazy argument that should have no legitimate place in a policy debate without further and detailed explication, especially at this time of intractable budget crises. We simply don’t have the luxury to shutter state liquor stores just because some people think they look weird.
That said, there’s always convenience and selection, and if you think that’s worth the added human, social, public health, law enforcement, regulatory, and budgetary cost, well then, I guess we’ll just have to agree to disagree. But don’t just spew this “government doesn’t belong in the liquor business” bullshit at me, because it’s exactly that, and I’m not prepared to accept these costs for the sake of a lazy, free market, ideological reflex.

Open the state liquor stores 24 hours a day, and I won’t care about privatization one way or another. Plus, longer hours means more people employed.
The problem with the state liquor stores is they’re not distributed widely enough and have shitty store hours. Being a social democrat, I have no problem with socialism, but I do have a problem with bad service and blue laws.
And I always thought it was our controlling puritanical regulations of liquor that caused our high rates of underage drinking, alcohol abuse, etc. Oh well…
What 1 said. I have no problem with socialism – if anything I wish our country/state were more socialistic – but the state doesn’t belong in the liquor business solely because it has shown that it doesn’t belong in the liquor business. Screw 24 hours a day, I would be happy with being able to buy a bottle of liquor past 7pm on a Friday night on my way to a party. This is perhaps the only government office that makes money for every hour that it’s open (especially evening hours), and they close at 7? (At least the one in my neighborhood does.)
I don’t really care who runs the liquor stores; they should just be run better, and the state doesn’t seem to have any incentive to do that for some reason.
Do you think the State should run Gentlemen’s Clubs?
goldy, i go back and forth between being just as angry about this stuff as you are & saying… fuck it, not only are we continuing to follow the ‘do it wrong’ playbook step-by-step, but the very ideas needed to turn this thing around are literally considered anti-american by a (potential) majority of the voting population & concluding that we just need to let this sucker bottom-out & be as ready as we can when it happens to offer up those supposedly ‘un-american’ ideals at that point in time.
So… dismissing out of hand an entire category of legitimate political reasoning (namely, the quaint notion that just because the state can do something, doesn’t necessarily mean that it should) isn’t lazy?
Look, I’m not arguing that just because an idea can be formulated by someone means that it necessarily deserves to be taken seriously (creationism, racism, homophobia come to mind) but we’re not talking about that, here. The idea that the powers of the state are actually limited in *some* sense is not exactly a radical idea, nor is it exclusive to the right or left (who just disagree about what powers of the state should be limited, not whether state powers can be limited.)
Aren’t there laws against selling liquor (including beer and wine at the grocery store) after midnight? If so, is there any reason to suppose that that would go away with liquor privatization?
@5,
Straw man. The state doesn’t run gentlemen’s clubs. It does run liquor stores, and has for 80 years. The question here is: what is the benefit provided by privatization? If folks think convenience and selection is enough of a benefit to outweigh the costs, well I can’t argue. That’s their opinion. And if there’s some other societal or economic benefit I’ve missed, then have it. But if you’re going to bring bullshit like gentlemen’s clubs into the discussion, then I’ll ask, why not just sell of all the state parks, and shutter our public schools?
Just because the argument “but that’s socialism” is stupid doesn’t mean that the state should run retail shops. That’s even stupider.
The state doesn’t restrict sales of beer or wine or cigarettes to special stores. Your argument applies equally well to them.
The state also doesn’t run special stores to sell shoes, or toothpaste, or musical instruments, or books, or cantaloupes, or gasoline, or ballpoint pens, or garden mulch, or computers, or flea powder, or coffee drinks. Your argument applies equally well to all of those as well.
Because your argument really amounts to one thing: “we really need the money”. Which smells a lot more like bullshit to me than “government doesn’t belong in the liquor business” does, because “government doesn’t belong in the liquor business” IS A TRUE STATEMENT.
Government doesn’t belong in ANY kind of retail business. It’s completely ridiculous for the state to be running retail shops, dedicated retail stops with one product that no one else is allowed to sell. There’s your bullshit, end of story.
Besides, the argument that “we need the money” is completely unsupported. I still haven’t seen any proof that their absurdly expensive and poorly run store network and distribution system is as profitable as you make it out to be. Does money flow into state coffers? Yes. Would just as much or more flow into state coffers if they stopped having to pay for rent and staff and trucks and thousands of bureaucrats holed up in their offices? Did I mention, insanely expensive offices? Do you remember the debacle over that fancy new headquarters when it was built?
Tax the booze, sell the licenses, stop paying rent and salaries and let the retail shopkeepers pay them instead: we’ll come out ahead in the long run.
I know you think that’s crazy, but the fact is OTHER STATES DO IT.
I’ll just add that your understanding of what motivates liquor purchases is really offensive and ignorant. In other words, you’re full of shit, Goldy, right up to your eyebrows. I’ll bet your eyes are even brown.
I think @1 has a good point.
We need to realize that we’re a state of diverse living situations, and one size may not fit all.
Perhaps in rural areas we should let any facility permitted to run USPS services and sell tobacco and state MJ also sell alcohol as well, since that’s probably a good and wise co-location efficiency, and rural kids can already steal 24 packs of beer from the back porch anyway or whiskey from the glove compartment of dad’s truck.
But in urban areas, having at least some WSLCB stores located inside grocery stores – with similar operating hours but a glass partition, would work better, and they could sell liquor, tobacco and less-addictive MJ there with a valid ID, during store hours (16 hour, 20 hour, or 24 hour).
Also, for those growing at home or distilling at home, they should sell state 4/20 stamps for MJ and state distillers tax stamps for off sales. Like we used to do when our nation was founded by that great MJ pusher George Washington.
I’m going to agree with some of the other posters here so far… the state has shown it’s operating the business poorly.
If the state subcontracted the liquor sales out to a private chain or some other group with proven experience at sales, I wouldn’t care if the state kept the final control. Hell, I think it’s fine to leave final authority with the legislature, so long as it’s not a bunch of people elected on 147 different platforms, most of which have nothing to do with booze, business, or the regulation of either, making day to day policy.
The system right now is not serving anyone well because its policies are cobbled together to serve the interests of electeds and their constituency groups.
I am sure there has to be a balance between not increasing to social ills you’ve described and the horrible experience and system we’ve got in place now.
Do the liquor stores have to look run down and dirty? Do they have to have such restricted hours? Is there a reason they have to be distributed so poorly around the state?
BTW, Goldy, I may have missed it if you provided it in the past, but since you continually assert that privatization is going to come with “added human, social, public health, law enforcement, regulatory, and budgetary cost[s],” do you have any data from privatized states showing that they bear such costs? I’ve lived in both Washington and Colorado, and I’ve been unable to perceive such costs in Colorado.
So Goldy, I’d appreciate your thoughts on this. Are you really arguing that all the states that are blue in this graphic:
http://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/co…
Are drowning in alcohol problems relative to Washington? Because, uh, they aren’t.
@13 exactly. Goldy is usually really good at the research, so I’d love to see some research that shows how Washington is some overwhelming double-digit percentage nirvana of no kids under 21 drinking booze, less DUIs, lower rates of alcohol abuse, less kids with fetal alcohol syndrome and other factors like that, rather than just Stranger-style bolded exhortations.
@7 Washington State has been in the liquor business for 80 years, is surrounded by states that are in the liquor business (and the Pacific, but…) and will continue to be so unless if the laws are changed. Given that, there is a huge difference between arguing that the state shouldn’t be in the liquor business (you know, with arguments) and simply postulating or hand-waving that to be somehow self-evident.
So the point here was to call out the presumption that, in the absence of compelling reasons otherwise, we should rely on the private sector rather than the state to supply any given good or service.
Yes, that is an ideological presumption. A rather widely held one, but a presumption nonetheless. The opposite presumption would be that, in the absence of compelling reasons otherwise, the government should supply any given good or service. Given that this opposite presumption is so rare, and widely considered to have been refuted by the failures of centrally planned economies in the 20th century, I would expect the onus to lie on Goldy to explain why we should accept it, but I don’t see any defense of it in this post.
I see. It’s your contention, which you’ve never proved, that privatization will increase consumption. So how is it, exactly, that with increased alcohol consumption, we wouldn’t have increased tax revenue?
With each and every liquor privatization post you throw up, Goldy, it becomes more and more clear that you are a HACK and a LIAR.
Holy shit. This isn’t fucking Utah like everyone’s making it out to be. Alcohol is a DRUG. A DANGEROUS DRUG. People deal with LIFELONG DEPENDENCY PROBLEMS. THIS IS WHY WE REGULATE IT.
We’ve essentially fucked ourselves EVEN MORE because here we are, even though TWO privatization measure were voted down last year Goldy is taking on the lunatic majority who still say they want to privatize but apparently can’t bother to cast a vote. Plus there was that whole “underage enforcement” nonsense. MORE liquor outlets will IMPROVE enforcement? CRACK DOWN on underage drinking? @3 your point is total bullshit and you’re probably astroturf, but kids are drinking underage because of state liquor stores? Privatizing liquor will help decrease consumption, or change the drinking age?
If you have a problem with the liquor store hours, here’s an earth-shattering idea: STOCK UP ON MORE BOOZE WHEN THEY’RE OPEN, sorry if you have to wait until morning to get, what, your two airplane bottles of Absolut?
I think the presumption should be that drugs, addictive (alcohol, tobacco, gambling) and non-addictive (MJ), should be heavily taxed.
Any proposal to shift the taxes onto the poor (e.g. sales tax) from the rich (e.g. closing WSLCB stores) should be met with a One Tax Dollar Enters If One Tax Dollar Leaves mechanism.
Or fund enforcement with a Surtax For Millionaires (real millionaires, not $250,000 families) on stock transactions, since that causes harm to lots of people.
Shorter Goldy redux: “Washington will never be a cheap booze state, therefore the state might as well remain in the liquor business.”
Show me a policy that dedicates sin taxes to offsetting the social costs of the sin, and I’ll get behind it. Otherwise, the state should GTFO the way and let people buy liquor from licensed sellers. And all those tax dollars will stay in the pockets of liquor consumers, where they can be put to whatever alternative purpose those liquor consumers desire.
“Desperately need a bottle of bourbon at 3 AM? Just head on down to the local Safeway.”
Wait, are they planning to change the law about buying alcohol at the supermarket after 2am? Because if so: woo hoo! And if not: great journalism, dipshit.
Fact:
• Most states aren’t in the liquor business. (Mine isn’t; it isn’t even in the medical marijuana business).
• Most states – maybe even all of them – don’t have any additional problems as a result of that.
• While we’re talking about facts here, where are yours? Because there aren’t any. You can’t prove loss of revenue, you can’t prove increased drunkenness or problems because of privatization. In fact, the only thing you can prove is that convenience to the customer (and most likely price) would improve with privatization.
Stupid argument. It’s not like it’s never been done before in the world.
@ 15, what I would like to know is whether any now-privatized state was ever one that controlled liquor the way Washington does now. That would give us a good idea if any of Goldy’s fears have a rational basis.
I haven’t followed every one of these posts, so I hope Goldy can show if he’s posted data that backs up his case before. But if he hasn’t and if he can’t, I’d say that his case fails, largely because of what @ 17 says – that if this is a case of one set of ideological assumptions vs. another, the ones for privatization win out based on real world experience.
Still gotta think that Goldy’s been badly scarred by alcoholism in the family somewhere along the way. It’s distorted his normally clear thinking on this matter.
The argument isn’t about “Can we afford it right now?”. It’s “What is the proper role of government, and is this situation WRONG?” The situation is clearly wrong, and has been for decades.
Let’s remember, the argument against DADT repeal was that, “This isn’t the right time: we’re fighting 2 wars.” It was regressive bullshit, and we all knew it. Right & Wrong shouldn’t be decided by a balance sheet or fiscal calendar.
As usual, Fnarf has it dead on with this subject. Goldy apparently isn’t aware that some of us have large collections of top shelf liquor at home, and aren’t alcoholics because of it.
I just don’t get why Goldy isn’t arguing for state-run tobacco stores, state-run pharmacies, or even state-run gas stations and gun stores. If your argument is “socializing potentially dangerous goods is a good thing,” why not extend that argument to other potentially dangerous goods?
Look, I’m probably more of a socialist than the next guy, but that means that I want progressive taxation, not regressive sales taxes and state-mandated profit margins. Privatize liquor, and do away with sales tax, but also enforce our existing business taxes on our largest businesses, and tax the shit out of rich people’s income. We have embarrassingly regressive taxation in this state, and state-run liquor stores are part of that problem.
@19, I don’t know who you are, cuntbreath, but you’re getting on my nerves, you and all of you assholes who feel so free to decide for me what kind of things I buy at the store and when. I’m not buying airplane bottles of Absolut, shitwipe, and even if I was, it’s none of your fucking business.
No one is suggesting that liquor should not be regulated. Cigarettes are regulated — and sold around the clock in private stores. Beer is regulated — and sold twenty hours a day in private stores. Your argument isn’t any more attractive than your attitude.
Just answer this, Goldy; why do we not sell cigarettes in state stores?
I go on vacation for one day and look what happens…
@19, so the big lesson the morality police are trying to teach drunks with inconvenient store hours is “plan ahead”? Thanks for saving society.
@29,
Like I warned you Dom, the mice will play….
@ Goldy, there you are. Will you at least acknowledge my questions? Do you have any data to back up your arguments, or not?
No answer will be taken to mean “no,” and it’s your credibility that will suffer for it.
Goldy…
I’d respect your opinion on this a lot more if you stopped relying on the 100% BULLSHIT arguments used to defeat the ballot initiatives. (You know, the one that MANDATED the legislature re-set taxes and fees to make it revenue neutral.)
“Desperately need a bottle of bourbon at 3 AM? Just head on down to the local Safeway.”
You know full well that liquor sales in the state end at 2am. It could even be strengthened so no open containers are sold after 12am if you’re worried about people rushing from bar to liquor store just before last call.
But either you are flat out stupid (which you are not) or you are LYING when you suggest that people could purchase liquor at 3am.
The stupid thing is, if you dipshits had your way booze would be completely illegal. We tried that. IT DOESN’T WORK.
Neither does a distribution system designed in 1933.
@ above…
That should have read closed containers. Bars could keep serving ’til 2, but bottleshops would stop earlier. D’Oh!
Dominic’s comment makes it seem like he tries to stop the staff from trolling when he’s in.
@35, bars should be able to stay open until 4.
Don’t bother, guys. Goldy is apparently just trolling us on this issue now for cheap page hits to generate ad revenue. You paid by the hit, Goldy? Waste of time if there is no acknowledgment and discourse, and these personal anti-liquor screeds are pretty lame for someone who can normally argue exceptionally well.
@38, well he does have to pay for that hurt ankle some way so I guess I can’t blame him. Altho the irony of an alcoholic analgesic being more convenient for him to get is not lost on me.
@34 oh come on, the same argument could be made for MJ and …
oh.
never mind.
4/20 ftw!
@39 I speak from experience in saying that smoked-dirt-flavored booze does wonders for a sore ankle and also for any faddish fetish against inebriation.
No, kids aren’t drinking because of state liquor stores, they’re binge drinking, sometimes to the point of alcohol poisoning, because of our bullshit Puritanical handling of liquor. In CIVILIZED countries, kids are not taught the dangers of the demon liquor and are *gasp* even allowed to have a tipple of wine at dinner or on special occasions. Many of those countries don’t have remotely the same kinds of drinking-related problems that we do.
By the way, thanks for reaffirming that you’re wrong about everything.
@19 Nope, not astroturf. And slightly less anonymous now.
Most states aren’t in the liquor business…but most states also have a state income tax. So if you can propose an initiative that both eliminates the state liquor system AND creates some type of an income tax structure to offset the potential loss of revenue, I’d be all for it. Until then, late nighters will have to suffer through bars and cheap bottles of riesling at Bartell and QFC.
Goldy, you claim that privatizing liquor sales would lead to decreased state revenue, increased underage drinking, DUIs, domestic violence and alcohol abuse.
I assume you have hard data to back up those claims, right? That you aren’t just making up shit out of your own fears, right?
*crickets chirping*
This seems like a rather trivial policy issue, the fervent attitudes of both sides notwithstanding (isn’t there something else to do–like drinking?) There’s other states beside Utah that do something like this in some form. I don’t care. A nice thing to do would be to sell liquor later…and sale pot and LSD at these state run stores. Again, beside that I have hard time caring either way? The more urgent thing in this state is to make people realize that a narrow, constitutionally restricted income tax is necessary.
So, basically the argument can be summed up as follows:
Commenters: Goldy, where are the facts and figures to back up your claims of increased alcoholism, drunk driving, underage drinking?
Goldy: WAAAAAAAAA!! BUT THINK OF THE CHIIIIIILDREN!!!!!!
(So… perhaps if you scream louder we’ll all forget that your claims are completely baseless and that you completely transition into “hack” every time the conversation turns to alcohol.)
@41 will take that under advisement.
dirac – you’re never going to get anything past the ballot box if women think it endangers kids, no matter how libertarian you think they are. adapt or die.
@48 are you talking about my tax proposal, keeping the store open for longer hours, or the tongue-in-cheek pot/LSD initiative? Cuz really–I think they’re all doomed to failure in the next couple of years. Even the soccer moms don’t see the sense in taxing the rich, I guess.
@45
Actually, Goldy doesn’t. In fact, as has been pointed out here and on Horses Ass when Goldy was hell-bent on defeating the initiatives on his own blog, California has a lower rate of DUI arrests per capita and a FAR LOWER rate of alcohol related traffic fatality per capita than Washington.
But he still clings to his “fact” that things will be far worse for Washingtonians on the roads. He’s nearly republican in his belief on this issue in the total absence of evidence.