That was fast. When I went to Sunday mass last week as St. James Cathedral, their leadership was evasive and downright elusive when asked about the local Catholic Church’s new campaign to oppose a same-sex marriage bill. But this week, the Catholic Church’s position was in black and white.

Inside every bulletin at St. James Cathedral, the laity received marching orders today to begin pressuring their state lawmakers to stop the marriage equality measure in Olympia. In fact, Archbishop J. Peter Sartain disseminated the message to all 175 parishes under his jurisdiction of Western Washington and instructed them to print it in their bulletins. Here’s the entire statement:

ARCHBISHOP SARTAIN HAS ASKED THAT THE FOLLOWING ANNOUNCEMENT BE PUBLISHED IN ALL PARISH BULLETINS THIS WEEKEND

PROTECT MARRIAGE Legislators will be voting soon on whether to the change current law defining marriage. Marriage between a man and a woman is essential for family life and the foundation of any society. Please call, email or write your state Senator and two Representatives urging them to support the current law and defend marriage as the union of one man and one woman.

Call 1-800-562-6000 to leave a message for your legislators. Go to the Washington State Legislature website at http://aps.leg.wa.gov/DistrictFinder/Default.aspx to find your legislator and to write or email a message to them.

That wasn’t all: Copies of a more detailed anti-gay proclamation, issued by Sartain and three other Washington State bishops on January 13, were tucked into the vestibules of St. James. “Upholding the present definition of marriage,” the decree warned, is necessary for the “continuation of the human race.”

This may be the tip of the Catholic iceberg (as gay marriage looks increasingly likely to appear on the statewide November ballot).

If Minnesota is any indication, Archbishop Sartain could impose the Vatican’s agenda on progressive Seattle congregations the same way his colleagues are in Minneapolis: Twin Cities Archbishop John Nienstedt demanded that priests read a “marriage prayer” from the pulpit to advance the church’s agenda to pass a constitutional amendment banning same-sex marriage this fall. Priests were required to get up before their congregations—and laity were expected to recite a prayer—to “proclaim and defend [God’s] plan for marriage, which is the union of one man and one woman…” This effort coincided with a lobbying and fundraising campaign. And just last week, Nienstedt warned clergy there will be no “open dissent.”

In Washington State, we may be witnessing the beginning of a similar crusade to turn pulpits into stages for political rallies. After all, our marriage bill may pass the senate, and then it’s all but destined to appear the November ballot. At that point, Rome may perk up its ears, Washington will likely be declared ground zero for a religious war, and the trickle of cash that usually goes skyward from the local collection plates will instead be blasted back down on our statewide election. (Color me shocked: Sartian and the Archdiocese of Seattle have not returned several calls seeking comment.)

Of course, that may not happen in Washington State. Our bishops may not go that far. Or our priests may refuse to comply.

After all, polls show that the vast majority of Catholics—the Jesus-loving folk who go to church, not the bigot bishops who run the churches—support marriage equality. They’re even more supportive than the electorate at large.

At today’s sermon—which I sat through, yes—Father Michael Ryan made zero mention of the proclamation. The wording in the bulletin was also telling: The announcement was clearly there at the request of bishop, an announcement Father Ryan wasn’t rushing to espouse. But who knows: The bishops could demand churches lead prayers and campaign, and the National Organization for Marriage, which routinely doesn’t report its contributors but is tied closely to the Catholic Church, will have the ears of those bishops.

If that happens, will Seattle’s church leadership like Father Ryan push back? I’d like to hope the answer is yes. But when it came to printing anti-gay lobbying messages in today’s bulletin, his answer was no.

56 replies on “Under Orders, Seattle’s Catholic Churches Instruct Parishioners to Lobby Against Marriage Equality”

  1. Archbishop Sartain is an ambitious guy, who is clearly kissing up to the Vatican for his own self-promotion, rather than tending to the flock. If he continues these extreme measures, they’ll be closing Catholic Churches in Western Washington, just like they have been in cities like New York and Chicago. St. James Cathedral still has the liberal imprint of Archbishop Hunthausen, but I expect it’s just a matter of time before the pews are empty–the faithful driven away by leaders who are drunk with their own power.

  2. This saddens me so much. About 2 years ago I started a group on FB called “Not All Catholics Are Roman” because as an Old Catholic, I was fed up with the way the press takes everything the Roman officials say and act like it is the only Catholic position. My group now has over 300 members, and they run the spectrum from very conservative to very liberal, using rites from eastern Orthodox to Anglican to Gnostic. They have parishes as large as 225 members and communities like mine with 7. My Bishop is a wonderful homilist who happens to be married and female and gay. One of the Old Catholic theologians I trust the most is from Germany’s Old Catholic Church and the Utrecht Union.

    Then there are the Independent Catholics, in such a wide variety! There is no reason for progressive Romans to be so passive. I lived near Boston when Voice of the Faithful was taking over parishes and occupying them 24 hours a day! There is simply no reason for progressive Romans to just sit there passively (they already stopped donating. They put a $5 bill in the plate and that’s it).

    As to those Papists who do sincerely believe that Benedict is God’s representative on earth, infallible, and divinely selected, well this is a free country, and they have that right. BUT they are such a very small percentage of the Catholic world, that any press attempting to provide balanced reporting should at least file the press releases on the religion page – you know, page 28 or whatever. And when counting church membership, especially when making claims about how many members you have, and what they believe it can be pretty misleading when you include people who left the parish year ago, every infant you baptize whether they attend or not, and all the converts who can’t even read your doctrine for themselves! If you counted only active, attending, donating members a whole lot of those Roman parishes would look so much smaller, because they are!

    Progressive Romans have options: stay and join forces with groups like VOTF, or let God lead them to one of the many open an inclusive faith filled Catholic Churches not affiliated with Rome. The press has options: give the Vatican as little front page as they give the Seventh Day Adventists and the corner Baptist church or get several statements from a cross section of Catholic denominations on a political issue. The GLBT community has options to: Seek out and solicit comments from your local non-roman Catholics for your stories. Invite them to your parade. My parish was the first to have a Catholic Bishop march in a gay pride parade in New England a few years ago. It was amazing to hear the comments as people assumed we were episcopal, and we reminded them we were Catholic.

    Praying hard that your elected folks pay attention to who’s talking, and that the GLBT community actively supports those Romans who do protest, especially the clergy who do resist the Vatican call to what is wrong.

  3. @53

    You seem to be using a lot of odd terms to refer to Protestants, like “Independent Catholics,” “Progressive Romans,” and “Catholic Churches not affiliated with Rome.”

    Go ahead and do that, if that’s your thing, but please realize that other people are going to notice what you’re up to, and may not be inclined to go along with your attempts to redefine the word “Catholic.”

  4. 35

    Most of it did.

    But don’t waste your breath explaining it to slog.

    They are very fond of the House Bigotries……

  5. 12

    So True.

    Which is why dipping your dick in the shit pie is such a brilliant idea.

Comments are closed.