That was fast. When I went to Sunday mass last week as St. James Cathedral, their leadership was evasive and downright elusive when asked about the local Catholic Church’s new campaign to oppose a same-sex marriage bill. But this week, the Catholic Church’s position was in black and white.

Inside every bulletin at St. James Cathedral, the laity received marching orders today to begin pressuring their state lawmakers to stop the marriage equality measure in Olympia. In fact, Archbishop J. Peter Sartain disseminated the message to all 175 parishes under his jurisdiction of Western Washington and instructed them to print it in their bulletins. Here’s the entire statement:

ARCHBISHOP SARTAIN HAS ASKED THAT THE FOLLOWING ANNOUNCEMENT BE PUBLISHED IN ALL PARISH BULLETINS THIS WEEKEND

PROTECT MARRIAGE Legislators will be voting soon on whether to the change current law defining marriage. Marriage between a man and a woman is essential for family life and the foundation of any society. Please call, email or write your state Senator and two Representatives urging them to support the current law and defend marriage as the union of one man and one woman.

Call 1-800-562-6000 to leave a message for your legislators. Go to the Washington State Legislature website at http://aps.leg.wa.gov/DistrictFinder/Default.aspx to find your legislator and to write or email a message to them.

That wasn’t all: Copies of a more detailed anti-gay proclamation, issued by Sartain and three other Washington State bishops on January 13, were tucked into the vestibules of St. James. “Upholding the present definition of marriage,” the decree warned, is necessary for the “continuation of the human race.”

This may be the tip of the Catholic iceberg (as gay marriage looks increasingly likely to appear on the statewide November ballot).

If Minnesota is any indication, Archbishop Sartain could impose the Vatican’s agenda on progressive Seattle congregations the same way his colleagues are in Minneapolis: Twin Cities Archbishop John Nienstedt demanded that priests read a “marriage prayer” from the pulpit to advance the church’s agenda to pass a constitutional amendment banning same-sex marriage this fall. Priests were required to get up before their congregations—and laity were expected to recite a prayer—to “proclaim and defend [God’s] plan for marriage, which is the union of one man and one woman…” This effort coincided with a lobbying and fundraising campaign. And just last week, Nienstedt warned clergy there will be no “open dissent.”

In Washington State, we may be witnessing the beginning of a similar crusade to turn pulpits into stages for political rallies. After all, our marriage bill may pass the senate, and then it’s all but destined to appear the November ballot. At that point, Rome may perk up its ears, Washington will likely be declared ground zero for a religious war, and the trickle of cash that usually goes skyward from the local collection plates will instead be blasted back down on our statewide election. (Color me shocked: Sartian and the Archdiocese of Seattle have not returned several calls seeking comment.)

Of course, that may not happen in Washington State. Our bishops may not go that far. Or our priests may refuse to comply.

After all, polls show that the vast majority of Catholics—the Jesus-loving folk who go to church, not the bigot bishops who run the churches—support marriage equality. They’re even more supportive than the electorate at large.

At today’s sermon—which I sat through, yes—Father Michael Ryan made zero mention of the proclamation. The wording in the bulletin was also telling: The announcement was clearly there at the request of bishop, an announcement Father Ryan wasn’t rushing to espouse. But who knows: The bishops could demand churches lead prayers and campaign, and the National Organization for Marriage, which routinely doesn’t report its contributors but is tied closely to the Catholic Church, will have the ears of those bishops.

If that happens, will Seattle’s church leadership like Father Ryan push back? I’d like to hope the answer is yes. But when it came to printing anti-gay lobbying messages in today’s bulletin, his answer was no.

56 replies on “Under Orders, Seattle’s Catholic Churches Instruct Parishioners to Lobby Against Marriage Equality”

  1. There was zero mention of it at Mass last night either. There was, however, a prayer that people who worked in the banking and finance sectors wake up to a fresh steaming cup of integrity and recognize how their business activity affects the poor and needy. Many Catholics if not most believe that this political messaging by a tax-exempt group is wrong. If anything the bulletin made me want to thank my state representatives and my senator for supporting same-sex relationship equality.

  2. Yeah, I think most priests (at least most of the ones I know) are uncomfortable with taking a what amounts to a political stand from the pulpit, even when the politics seem to intersect what they consider to be a moral issue.

    Back in my Catholic days, though, had I been forced to say that prayer, that might have been the last straw (rather than the raging hypocracy that finally broke my back…although I guess that would have all fallen under that umbrella, considering the number of gay priests I know…). I’m glad I landed in a denomination that generally stays out of people’s bedrooms and reproductive choices.

  3. Oh, and on the bulletin thing…if the bishop tells you to print something, you print it. Every parish sends copies of their bulletins to the diocesan office, and somebody there reads every single one of them. The church is hierarchical enough that pushback on something like that would be unlikely.

    With the giant step to the right the church has taken under Benedict, I would think pushback of any kind wouldn’t be tolerated.

  4. This is great news. It will help the Catholic church continue its long term trend of becoming smaller and smaller, as people with integrity, true compassion and intelligence finally recognize the cost of associating with this corrupt organization masquerading as representatives of god.

  5. @ 6 not really, plenty of Catholics don’t agree with this and yet will remain Catholics because they agree with the larger message of the Church if not for one or two issues.

  6. I thought of going to St. James to light a candle for someone I lost. After reading this I decided not to. Neither I not my lost one would want to be honored in a place that corrupts the meaning of love and God so grossly.

  7. @7 exactly; the fight for justice takes many fronts. Or they’ll move to a country with a more progressive Catholic Church–the Canadian equivalent of the USCCB is far more progressive and liberal-minded, and you don’t hear Catholic priests campaigning against marriage equality here…

    @9 Go read any of the five hundred other posts on this subject and the answer there. Really, stop being lazy. (The answer: they can’t openly endorse candidates, but can take positions. How do I know this? Because it’s asked and answered in every single post.)

  8. I can’t wait for one of these bigots to debate marriage equality in a public forum…like maybe Town Hall, with say Dave Ross as a moderator.

    I’m so SURE something like that will happen really really soon!

  9. Father Ryan is a good man. I imagine he is struggling with this. The Pastor at Fr. Ryan’s old church in Tacoma is probably also. I wonder how they will handle it. I would hope they’d both push back but I doubt they will.

  10. Father Ryan cannot be considered a “good man” if he continues to serve in this Church which discriminates against women and gays and threatens the principle of free speech. This Church is the Western equivalent of the Taliban.

  11. @9:

    The restriction only applies to a specific endorsement of a political candidate, not to discussion of – or in this case – advocation of a political opinion or point-of-view.

  12. Sartain is relatively young and ambitious and wants to climb upwards within the hierarchy beyond the Pacific Northwest. He won’t be in Seattle more than a few years, so the priests and deacons and involved laity who are opposed to his agenda are of little concern.

  13. @17 Sartain is secretary-elect to the US Conference of Catholic Bishops, so there’s no way he’s going to not follow orders 110%. Especially after seeing the current USCCB secretary get promoted to cardinal. Red hat fever will keep Sartain putting the welfare of Washingtonians behind his own.

  14. @16 is right. Churches and other religious tax-exempt groups can lobby for causes, just not for candidates. From the pulpit of my progressive church this morning, we were encouraged to go to Olympia tomorrow to lobby FOR marriage equality.

  15. @12: Absolutely! Now that you mention it, a huge number of laws laid down in the Pentateuch are about sanitation. What determines what meats are acceptable? Whether the animal is clean. What does the Cohen Gadol do before going before the Holiest of Holies? He prays…and he takes a bath. Why might an individual be temporarily excluded from certain aspects of the community? Whether from a wet dream, menstruation, a skin condition, or even just touching something icky, that person is unclean and needs to be purified.
    Abrahamic religions especially should recognize the importance of sanitation.

  16. Thank God I’m a Progressive Protestant! Gay folks are plenty welcome at my church and not in that “love this sinner hate the sin” way either. We believe God created Gay folks Gay on purpose and that this is a good thing.

  17. @10, 16, 19: Where are you getting your information on the prohibition of political activity by churches? According to the IRS’ Publication 1828 (Tax Guide for Churches and Religious Organizations):

    “In general, no organization, including a church, may
    qualify for IRC section 501(c)(3) status if a substantial
    part of its activities is attempting to influence legislation
    (commonly known as lobbying). An IRC section 501(c)
    (3) organization may engage in some lobbying, but too
    much lobbying activity risks loss of tax-exempt status.

    Legislation includes action by Congress, any state legis-
    lature, any local council, or similar governing body, with
    respect to acts, bills, resolutions, or similar items (such as legislative confirmation of appointive offices), or by the public in a referendum, ballot initiative, constitutional amendment, or similar procedure. It does not include actions by executive, judicial, or administrative bodies.

    A church or religious organization will be regarded as
    attempting to influence legislation if it contacts, or urges
    the public to contact, members or employees of a legislative body for the purpose of proposing, supporting, or opposing legislation, or if the organization advocates the adoption or rejection of legislation.”

    Basically, whether a specific candidate is mentioned isn’t the issue here–lobbying for or against legislation can also threaten a church’s tax-exempt status. The question is how the IRS defines whether the church’s political activities represent a substantial part of its purpose.

  18. The Catholic Church picked the wrong state to pick this fight. This is not fascist Italy, Spain or Portugal. Article I, Section 11 of our State Constitution provides:

    Absolute freedom of conscience in all matters of religious sentiment, belief and worship, shall be guaranteed to every individual, and no one shall be molested or disturbed in person or property on account of religion; but the liberty of conscience hereby secured shall not be so construed as to excuse acts of licentiousness or justify practices inconsistent with the peace and safety of the state. No public money or property shall be appropriated for or applied to any religious worship, exercise or instruction, or the support of any religious establishment.

  19. @24: the key word is “substantial”. I’ve taken several workshops given by lawyers on 501(c)(3)s held by religious organizations and it’s always emphasized that the mission and preponderant practice of religious organizations (i.e., religion, not politics) pretty much exempts them from censure when they lobby for issues.

    Except, of course, fundamentalists like the megachurches were allowed to tell their parishioners to vote for Bush. The IRS had to keep its hands off them.

  20. Wake up, love. Groups that have agendas have voter guides and bulletin announcements that inform memembers who to lobby, who to boycott, who to vote for… It is a fact. This is not just the RC, Evangelical Protestants do it to, heck the NRA does it with their memembers. There are people paid to do the thinking for a group’s memembership, these individuals sift through and tell the people how to vote. Sadly some people like it this way and they do as they are told. Keep your eyes open.

  21. @25, I think that means that the state can’t bother you because of your religion, not that religionistas can’t bother you.

    And yes, Sarah70, that ‘substantial part’ is really, really vague and also a double-edged sword. It’s pretty hard to get your 501c3 yoinked and I think I fall on the side of keeping it that way. I think.

  22. If you are a progressive Catholic in Washington State, prove it. Start by refusing to put money into the till during Sunday service.

  23. One of the four signers of the bishops’ letter was Bishop Joseph Tyson of Yakima. My reliable gaydar suggests he is a closet case. That would be a good scoop Dominic.

  24. @35, some of the organization in the civil rights era came from the Jewish community also. Several rabbis were in the Birmingham jail with MLK. So what does any of that have to do with the case at hand?

    If you’re a progressive Catholic in Washington, talk to your priest and bishop about this. Tell them you’ll leave the Church. If you can’t say that to them, you’re not a progressive Catholic.

  25. @22: I’m all about not offering gifts or taking food with the left hand.

    @37/38: An interesting bit from Bishop Tyson’s Wikipedia entry [emphasis mine]:

    In 2007, Tyson testified at a state legislative hearing on a proposed Washington initiative to offer domestic partnership benefits to same-sex couples; he promoted broadening its provisions, a controversial strategy used elsewhere by the Catholic Church, extending the definition of partnership to relationships beyond that of unmarried couples, to prevent discrimination against an elderly parent, a sibling, housemate or another in residence thus limiting its potential affirmative impact for gay rights, consistent with the Catholic Church’s long-standing position.[5]

    (That reference link at the end of the blockquote works too.)

  26. @34: Back on the day, when “The Church” was the biggest single power in Western Europe (or especially when struggling to remain so). Pretty Talibanesque group at times.

    Today, that’s a laughable claim…. but it isn’t the largest single power any more either.

  27. There isn’t much that the state can do to revoke tax exempt status for the Catholic Church, except perhaps roll back the property tax exemption on church owned property. Does anyone know if that can be done by statute, or would it require a change in the state constitution?

Comments are closed.