Two Seattle Police Department officers are on paid administrative leave after shooting and killing a 22-year-old University of Washington student during a confrontation in the early morning hours of January 1.

Just before 2:00 a.m., police were called to the 5200 block of 17th Avenue Northeast after neighbors reported two men firing off rifles and shotguns in an alley.

When officers arrived at the scene, Miles Murphy approached them wearing a German World War II uniform, carrying a rifle affixed with a bayonet.

According to SPD, officers repeatedly ordered Murphy to drop his weapon; when he would not comply, two officers opened fire. Murphy died at Harborview several hours later.

Police say they found a large collection of Nazi regalia inside Murphy’s home. Although initial media reports called Murphy an “apparent neo-Nazi,” his friends say he was a German Studies major and World War II buff who participated in reenactment battles.

“I think the Nazi thing is being blown out of proportion,” says one of Murphy’s friends, who asked not to be identified. “They reenact battles and stuff. [He wasn’t] modeling himself after Hitler.”

Another of the Murphy’s friends, who attended a memorial service for Murphy on New Year’s Day, says she believes the police did not give Murphy adequate time to drop his gun—which she says was filled with blanks—before he was shot. “He was in no way affiliated with Nazis,” she says. “He was the type of guy who … had goofy hobbies. He was a history buff and his interest was shown in the way he dressed.”

Indeed, Murphy was featured in a UW Daily fashion article last summer, where he was described as looking like “a figure straight out of a photo taken from World War II.”

Murphy’s Myspace page is filled with photos of him in German and Russian military uniforms and Scottish costumes. Murphy’s page lists his greatest fears as large dogs, “drug lords,” and the police. In response to a survey question on his page asking what goal he wanted to achieve this year, Murphy answered, “don’t die.”


More in NEWS

Local (and not-so-local) news from your favorite writers.

Jonah Spangenthal-Lee: Proving you wrong since 1983.

82 replies on “Shooting Victim Was a German Studies Major”

  1. I find the majority of these abusive comments meant to demean and dehumanize miles completely offensive. he wasn’t one of my closest friends, but he was a friend. he was an amazing person who had nothing but good intentions.. genuinely nice and very interesting. in fact, he had more original personal style/flair in his fashion and mannerisms than most people I’ve met in my life. it’s unfair to judge someone based on how they look, and taking things at face value from a myspace? jeez. haven’t we learned better?

    somehow the press and the city of seattle have been able to smear and twist this story so that police can wash their hands free of the incident and continue to “protect” (read: power trip). in fact, on this very comment page there is an ad for some website that will earn me my career in “law enforcement and policing.” that process sure makes me feel safe. shame on anybody who chooses to judge this situation from the outside.

    miles was an amazing person and his tragic death will not soon be forgotten.

  2. The cops are in extreme damage control about this shooting. And, I think it is because their explanation doesn’t make sense. Worse, the story keeps changing.

    Every news source seems to have a slightly different description about what was going on. You hear from one source that Miles was pointing the gun at them. Another one says that Miles was pointing the gun in the cops’ direction. A third source says Miles was a lethal threat simply because he was holding a gun with two hands. Yikes! It isn’t against the law to own or carry a gun. And, the cops weren’t responding to bank robbery, just a New Year’s Eve disturbing the peace complaint. When the cops arrived, the noise making was over. It’s surprising that they got out of their car. It is even more surprising that the cops assumed that some college student was going to try to shoot his way out of a firm scolding.

    Most people say that Miles should have known that the cops would shoot him. At what point did Officer Friendly become a member of a death squad? Miles was walking up some stairs, made eye contact with the cops, and then they shot him. He didn’t have a chance to say a word before they shot him down.

    Yes, the cops told him to “drop the gun.” But how easy is it to drop a long gun while you are walking up stairs? The logistics aren’t as straightforward as dropping the gun on a flat surface — especially if you are tipsy. That extra second or two of hesitation gave the cops the “justification” to shoot him down. Sadly, Miles would be alive today if the cops had just stepped away from the stairs and told him to come talk to them without the gun.

  3. @chad
    “The time it takes you to line-up center mass, is about the same time it takes you to aim at the legs and rip off 8-rounds. It’s actually quicker.”

    I sincerely doubt you know this because anyone with firearms training understands center mass is the target. While your are shooting at my legs. I shot you in the face and chest cause I still can. Get it yet? When you are dead. I will crawl away, that is whats real. How is that for an argument?

  4. Perhaps one fitting memorial would be for Miles’ many college-age friends to fill those open positions at the SPD when they graduate. They are hiring a lot of officers now; I’m sure you’ve noticed the ads everywhere. You could reform the police from within, because they will listen to one of their own far more than any outsider. Even if you can’t do much at first, you can rise in the ranks and become a leader with the power to turn the whole force around. Or perhaps after a while, switch to politics, like Tim Burgess. People will listen to what a former cop has to say about police reform.

    It’s easy for anyone to sit and complain, but what if you yourself are one of the people with the power to change things? In fact, you are.

  5. Why the heck couldn’t the SPD have told him: “You don’t drop the gun in 5 seconds, you get tazed – if at any point you raise the gun at us, you will have more holes than a prairie dog – care to drop the gun now?”

    Hoping whoever delivered the fatal shot will somehow pay. Rather doubt it.

  6. Why didn’t they just shoot the guys kneecaps?

    Because if you shoot a suspect in the kneecaps, and the suspect then shoots your partner in the head, the other cops won’t be your friend any more. And isn’t friendship what it’s all about?

  7. A tazer uses electricty. When the body receives an electric charge, it causes the muscels to CONSTRICT. If the person’s finger were on the trigger or anywhere near the trigger, it might potentially cause that person to fire the weapon. As for shooting out knee caps, do the math. Measure your knee caps. Then at 10-15 yards, in poor light/darkness looking down at a point, try to accurately shoot that same measurement. The only deescalation technique that should have been used, was. It’s when a Cop tells you to DROP THE WEAPON, you drop it. The cops in this case did everything that they should have done. This kid made very poor choices that ultimately led to his death. What I find odd, is the outcry for the kid that pointed a gun at cops. What about the cops who had to take a life? Their lives will forever be changed.

  8. If you own a firearm in an urban area, don’t EVER take it outside and shoot it in the alley next to your apartment. In point of fact, when it does leave your home, carry it in a secured case with the ammunition locked in a seperate container. Put any such items in the trunk of your car and don’t remove them until you reach the range or hunting location.

    Any other behavior is irresponsible and incredibly ignorant. Firearms are weapons designed to kill people and animals. That is the full extent of their use.

    Playing with a large caliber battle rifle with an affixed bayonet at two o’clock in the morning on New Year’s Eve is an almost guaranteed way to have a confrontation with police officers. Add a dark alley, para-military costume, etc. into the mix, and that confrontation has a great deal of potential for violence.

    I’m not sure how many people are maligning this young man. I’m certainly not. He sounds like someone I would have liked to have met. I am, however, saddened by the exceptionally poor decisions that he made that night. From every account (including what I’ve been able to read about his neghbors’ statements) the police had very few choices available to them when they arrived in that alley. With every second of non-compliance, those choices diminished. Sad. Very sad.

    To the movie quoters and advocates of tazers or kneecap/arm shots – I hope that you make better choices than the ones ennumerated here. Your apparent lack of understanding of the dangers in the world around you leads me to fear for your safety.

  9. Why don’t cops learn to shoot the gun out of the suspects hands?

    They gunned this guy down because they didn’t want to work on New Years Eve.

    I hate cops. Never there to protect you when you need it. The only thing they’re good at is killing innocent people. Bunch of high school cowboys.

  10. I love how all you assholes give the criminals such John Wayne accuracy.

    “Oh, if you shoot them in the leg then your partner gets shot in the face.”

    You know what happens when .45 Hollowpoints hit your legs? They blow your fuckin legs out from underneath you.

    Is it too much to ask the police to grow a brain? Yeah, it probably is.

  11. How much time did they give this drunken ‘WWII enthusiast’ to drop his gun?

    And it was pointed at the police officers? I’m sure that was the case.

  12. Is there one single police force anywhere in the world that teaches police to shoot suspects in the hand or the kneed or tries to shoot guns out of their hands? Is there a single one? Why is that?

  13. It’s regrettable. It sounds like both sides are guilty of foolishness but only the police caused a death. If the Seattle Police Officers’ Guild hadn’t protested the police department’s trial of individually-worn cameras we might now be able to look at objective video evidence in this case. As it is now, we have to take the officers at their word.

  14. In England, the police don’t carry guns. Why is that?

    Also, I think the correct procedure should be to approach the suspect without a shirt, making sure your firearm is taped to your back.

    Throw the suspect off by making a funny quip and then PULL!

    BAM motherfucker, your dead. Slowly cool your gun-barrel by blowing gently on the tip. Then, slowly cool your partner by blowing his tip.

  15. In England, Miles Murphy wouldn’t have a prayer of getting permission to keep that gun. Hmmmm.

    2 + 2 = ???

  16. I’m not a fan of the SPD. That being said, they are trained and paid to use DEADLY FORCE! When I cop yells at you to “DROP YOUR WEAPON” even if you think he/she is a dick, THAT”S WHAT YOU NEED TO BE DOING!

  17. “To the movie quoters and advocates of tazers or kneecap/arm shots – I hope that you make better choices than the ones ennumerated here. Your apparent lack of understanding of the dangers in the world around you leads me to fear for your safety. “

    Just for clearzies, I’m not an “advocate” of tazing.
    And “more holes than a prairie dog” is not from a movie, rather my own imagination, Precious.

  18. A “German history buff” worthy of the name would know that the rifle and cartridge in question here, a Mauser 98k in 8×57, are powerful enough to kill a horse, wreck an engine block or tear a man in two at ranges out to a half-mile. He would also know that a 98k bayonet has a twelve-inch blade, and when affixed to a nine-pound rifle, it will punch through both sides of a police officer’s body armor without a lot of effort.

    Point that at a cop and you get what you pay for.

    Just sayin’.

  19. actually, huey, it’s the blitzkrieg’s that really take some imagination to stage. sadly, we can’t restore kenmore to what it once wa…what? it’s always been like that? never mind…

  20. it was the guy protrayed from the movie “The Battle of Shaker Heights” it would seem , a real life Shia labeouf’s character got killed packing a bolt action rifle. sad

  21. Suicide by cop. The man wanted to die. He said on his MySpace he didn’t expect to be alive in a year. Suicide by cop. Clearly.

    Speaking of which, I’ve go some houses and apartments to rent to students with a good payment record. Red Door Realty. Google me.

  22. Lesson(s) learned here.

    1) Don’t answer your door when the cops are knocking holding a gun.

    2) Dont’t drink and hold/play/shoot weapons.

    3) When cops tell you to drop your gun. Drop your gun.

    4) No matter how stupid or how dumb your actions are there will always be someone out there who will defend you and attempt to blame others for your ignorance.

    You gotta love America.

  23. “Yes I understand the police’s fearful POV”

    It isn’t fearful. It’s realistic. There are very real dangers in police work. It is only through training, vigilence, and understanding the fine balance between protecting the rights of suspects and protecting our own lives that we get to come home to our families. Then we go back out the next day and do it again.

    “and understand that guy with a real gun, blanks or no, is exactly the kind of danger the police should protect the populace from, but…”

    But what? You ask us to protect you. When you call 911 because someone is waving a weapon around, you want *us* to respond. You want trained professionals who will try to deal with whatever the situation is. Not you. Us. You ask us to handle it. What but?

    “Are there no options but death-as-law-enforcement once a gun’s involved????”

    Yes. You contain the situation as much as possible, protecting innocent civilians from the danger of either the suspects actions or your own. Then you try to get the suspect to surrender without violence while protecting your life and the lives of others.

    “Tazers?”

    A Tazer’d man can still fire a rifle.

    “Shoot out his kneecaps?”

    A man with shot out kneecaps can still operate a rifle. His hands and eyes still work.

    “Choking/tear gas?”

    A person under the influence of pepper spray or tear gas can still fight. I was trained in it’s use and part of that training is being exposed to it. Part of the advanced training I received was being able to still fight. It was easier (though painful and unpleasant) than one would think. I have lost fights to people who have been pepper sprayed. The aggressor just has to be determined.

    “or otherwise non-lethal defense?”

    Scientists are currently working on many forms of non-lethal defense. Some of those technologies may reach our police departments. Until then, we use a reasonable escalating series of steps to deal with possibly violent individuals, culminating in the sometimes tragic but necessary use of deadly force.

    It’s what you pay us to do. We are the ones you call when someone is waving a gun and sometimes, sometimes, we have to, in the words of Washington state law, “use deadly force to protect ourselves or others from the imminent threat of grave bodily injury or death.”

    We aren’t super heroes. We are human beings, like you, with bills, and families and homes. We are people who you ask to walk into dangerous situations because someone dialed 911.

    “The police shut down westlake for hours and even called in a firetruck hose because a guy with a ‘samurai’ sword was twitching, but they have to kill this 22yo?”

    SPD were heroes that day. They didn’t have to kill anyone in the line of duty. The man with the sword was properly contained. He lived because the efforts of the police, and their incredible patience, paid off. He did not have a firearm. If he did, it likely would have turned out differently.

    “Can I assume Murphy was under the influence at 2am on New year’s eve?”

    He may have been. We won’t know until all the facts are unveiled.

    “I just can’t help but think that stupid drunk fucks with costumes and weapons should also be protected from themselves as part of the whole ‘protect and serve’ law enforcement thing.”

    The officers who responded likely did everything they could to protect bystanders, the suspect and themselves. The suspect did not comply with their orders and pointed a *weapon* at them. What would you have them do in that situation; die? Die for $50,000 a year?

    “Death by firing squad, regardless of context, seems so 19th century…”

    This was not a firing squad. They were trained officers who responded to a 911 call — because you want them to respond to 911 calls.

  24. Its sucks this man had to die and my condolences go out to his friends and family but come on man. We already know the Seattle police like to shoot people for no reason so what the fu#k are you thinking shooting guns off (blanks or not) in an alley in the U-District?!?!
    And in response, shooting someones knee caps out would be considered cruel and unusual punishment not to mention hit knees aren’t the joints that work to pull triggers. A samurai sword is a bit different than a rifle that can kill multiple people from a significant distance.

  25. The neighborhood in which the incident took place is just three blocks from the U.W. campus and densely populated. Most houses in the area are literally spitting distance from one another. The Mauser 98K fires a bullet at 2,493 ft/s and has an effective range of 800+ yards. Murphy clearly represented a potential danger to his neighbors and the police were responding to two 911 calls. The police were doing their job to protect the people in the area from harm.

    For the cop bashers out there, you may be interested to know that police involved in shootings are often deeply affected by the experience and suffer emotional scars as a result.

    Murphy made some stupid choices. First by firing off a weapon in a crowded residential area and then by not obeying a simple order to drop the weapon.

  26. Not to defend the cops, but I’m going to.

    Police are trained to use deadly force. A sudden movement (IE Reaching for a Taser) could trigger the suspect to fire.

    Shooting him in the kneecaps; he can still fire.

    Shoulder shots trigger the muscles in the hands and arms to spasm, which can cause fire.

    Every weapon is assumed to be fully loaded, fully functional. If a person is seen holding a weapon; they are then considered armed and dangerous.

    In this instance; deadly force is used, if necessary.

    The fact that the gun was loaded with blanks was post-incident information, and we all know hindsight is 20/20.

  27. All you people saying that the fuzz should have shot Herr Murphy’s kneecaps have got it all wrong. As previously stated, even kneecapped he would still conceivably be able to fire.

    The po-lice should have SHOT THE GUN OUT OF HIS HANDS. Why, I watched Gene Wilder do that in Blazing Saddles just the other day.

  28. Good, one less weird fucker on the streets of seattle that has a gun. freedom to express strage obsessive hobbies doesnt usually involve a symbolic figure that tried to persecute a religion. I guess i should feel sorry for the next asshole that decides to dress up as a suicide bomber and tries to get on the bus, purely as a joke

  29. I happen to like the look of German Uniforms, especially the 1937 Allemande SS all black uniforms of the hated SS.

    I have it all here, but in fetish latex. Duh,,,not gay, just love the best damed dressed army ever.

    I’d have dropped the rifle, know they’d kill me in a heart beat. Gently set the war piece on the pavement, and do as told. Hit the cement.

    Not know what got into his head, but seems? reasons untold, maybe by the cops lips won’t either, what can cause a white boi to be gunned down without a outcry,

    Because he was wearing a German uniform, and is saying and under cry of society?

    Seems there is no white, that’s a bad word, in fact an “embarrassment”

    Better to be gay, a lesbian, black, but hell no, a white. (one of those whites that actually works, ya know, in a factory, where most WORK, not in the restaurants and coffee shops, seems we build all that you need to make your money.) You know, machinists, welders, mold makers, ship wrights, plumbers, steel workers, masons. On and on, what your ass is resting on was designed and built by us.

    There is a 2 Americas, and I know which one went color blind, and forgot the Kings speech.

Comments are closed.