Two Seattle Police Department officers are on paid administrative leave after shooting and killing a 22-year-old University of Washington student during a confrontation in the early morning hours of January 1.

Just before 2:00 a.m., police were called to the 5200 block of 17th Avenue Northeast after neighbors reported two men firing off rifles and shotguns in an alley.

When officers arrived at the scene, Miles Murphy approached them wearing a German World War II uniform, carrying a rifle affixed with a bayonet.

According to SPD, officers repeatedly ordered Murphy to drop his weapon; when he would not comply, two officers opened fire. Murphy died at Harborview several hours later.

Police say they found a large collection of Nazi regalia inside Murphy’s home. Although initial media reports called Murphy an “apparent neo-Nazi,” his friends say he was a German Studies major and World War II buff who participated in reenactment battles.

“I think the Nazi thing is being blown out of proportion,” says one of Murphy’s friends, who asked not to be identified. “They reenact battles and stuff. [He wasn’t] modeling himself after Hitler.”

Another of the Murphy’s friends, who attended a memorial service for Murphy on New Year’s Day, says she believes the police did not give Murphy adequate time to drop his gun—which she says was filled with blanks—before he was shot. “He was in no way affiliated with Nazis,” she says. “He was the type of guy who … had goofy hobbies. He was a history buff and his interest was shown in the way he dressed.”

Indeed, Murphy was featured in a UW Daily fashion article last summer, where he was described as looking like “a figure straight out of a photo taken from World War II.”

Murphy’s Myspace page is filled with photos of him in German and Russian military uniforms and Scottish costumes. Murphy’s page lists his greatest fears as large dogs, “drug lords,” and the police. In response to a survey question on his page asking what goal he wanted to achieve this year, Murphy answered, “don’t die.”


More in NEWS

Local (and not-so-local) news from your favorite writers.

Jonah Spangenthal-Lee: Proving you wrong since 1983.

82 replies on “Shooting Victim Was a German Studies Major”

  1. I’m confused about what insult to hurl at the police now, since Nazi and fascist both seem inappropriate. Those Allied… bastards… Then again, you really should know better than to make “don’t die” your New Year’s resolution, every stand up comedian knows New Year’s resolutions never work out.

  2. you should have added that near neighbors heard the police call out to him repeatedly to drop his gun – rifle – and at that point, as we all know, they may decide to shoot first if they feel threatened

    the same self defense standard holds for ordinary folk as well, real fear of deadly threat I think it is called

    sad incident, gun owners take note, they are NEVER play things, NEVER.
    get drunk, have some fun – wear a costume, NO guns pointed at people

  3. Regardless of whether the guy was justly shot or not, he’d be alive if he wasn’t fucking around with his weaponry in the first place.

  4. Yes I understand the police’s fearful POV, and understand that guy with a real gun, blanks or no, is exactly the kind of danger the police should protect the populace from, but…

    Are there no options but death-as-law-enforcement once a gun’s involved????

    Tazers?
    Shoot out his kneecaps?
    Choking/tear gas?
    or otherwise non-lethal defense?

    The police shut down westlake for hours and even called in a firetruck hose because a guy with a ‘samurai’ sword was twitching, but they have to kill this 22yo?
    Can I assume Murphy was under the influence at 2am on New year’s eve?

    I just can’t help but think that stupid drunk fucks with costumes and weapons should also be protected from themselves as part of the whole ‘protect and serve’ law enforcement thing.
    Death by firing squad, regardless of context, seems so 19th century…

  5. What could possibly have been going through the addled brain of Mr. Murphy, that he did not immediately drop his rifle when ordered by police, who were pointing their weapons at him?

    I really cannot comprehend such total cluelessness.

  6. This is amazingly tragic and a horrible story. I have known this family for over a decade and know him personally. I know that he would never hurt a fly and was probably trying to explain exactly what was going on when some trigger happy police decided to shoot. This guy caucused for Wesley Clark in 2004 for god sake, he was by no means a Nazi or anything other than an amazing, eccentric individual.

  7. Two points. I do really feel for this guy, his family and his friends, but…

    1) If you point a gun at a cop, you will most likely get shot, nice guy or not. And for a cop to shoot, they will have to feel authorized to use deadly force. That is, they will attempt to shoot you dead, not shoot out your kneecaps, etc.

    2) This guy had many different ways he could have not gotten shot. Less to drink, don’t play with guns, listen to cops–many different decisions points led to this outcome, only one of them the cops’. Despite the emotional appeal to the contrary, he was living dangerously, and the responsibility lies with him.

    That said, tragic, and I blame it mostly on the alcohol.

  8. Just how does one reenact a WW2 battle?? I can understand Cival War reenactments in terms of the actual warfare and weapons used, but for WWII, do you sit around and design concentration camps and dig trenches? While his fetish with Nazi memorabilia is nuts and sad, thats not why he is dead now. It sounds like alcholism and insanity may have been the culprit.

  9. In fairness to the police, if someone aims a gun at me and I am armed, my first goal is self-preservation. I’m not going to try to shoot him in the kneecap, or the shoulder, or give him a warm blanket, a teddy bear and a hug. I’m going to take this guy out.

  10. LSD – not Jack Daniels….

    sad, only one person made major mistakes, the dead guy

    his friends are idiots, too polite to read him the riot act about his behavior, shit on those phony feel good friends – he was a trinket on the trinket shelf – not a human with some behavior problems

    the new American middle class way of dealing

    and this guy was no kid, SENIOR in college is a bit beyond childhood, smart student, stupid in real life

    sad, he was cute, and as someone commented, looks VERY queer to me – maybe that was the driving force behind his depression – his true queer self with, so he thought, no path to come out ???

    by the way that old rifle with live ammo will kill a moose quite nicely

    sad, RIP dear Sojournner, perhaps, all is finally well in your current dimension

  11. It’s a pity he died, but you can’t expect cops to shoot someone in the knee cap. Standard procedure for cops and anyone else like that is to shoot the torso. (It’s an easier shot that’s more likely to stop someone.) Thinking the cops are a little trigger-happy is one thing, but you really can’t fault them for following procedure.

  12. I personally know the family and your judgments should be withheld here, you weren’t there. What if people dress up as cops, oh that’s right they do.
    Things aren’t always as a appear.

  13. Huey: it sounds like you don’t know what the fuck you’re talking about. Just commenting speculation and hearsay, huh? All posters: Know that the only people that know what happened the morning of January 1st are the police officers that were at Miles’ house and Miles. And Miles can’t exactly tell his side of the story, can’t he?

  14. Questions & some facts to add:
    Where are/were the other 2 men firing shots in the alley and why didn’t SPD apprehend them, too?
    Inflated recon data: Neighbors overhead the police referring to this as a possible hostage situation.
    Miles’ Mauser Kar (with bayonet) was being held in both hands as he stepped out from his apartment. This is a) a 3.5 footlong rifle PLUS 10″ blade of bayonet b) a bolt-action rifle: very slow to fire c) a 70 year old, heavy bulky gun that would make a rather mean spear if thrown (in fact the bayonet was added by design to address the rifle’s lack of worth in short-range situations) d) no longer loaded as witnesses/neighbors reported he spent his ammo
    or e) all of the above.

    Murphy pointed the weapon at the officers, Kerlikowske said, then lowered it, then pointed it at them again “while taking a step forward.” The officers said they had direct eye contact…and that Murphy did not utter a word, the police chief said.

    The officers are Kirk Waldorf and Adam Elias. There were two others that reponded. They’ve never been involved in an on-the-job shooting before.
    They fired a total of seven rounds at Murphy.
    SPDCOP Kerlikowske says that aiming for anything other than torso is pure TV-bred “Myth”.

    I’ve taken self-defense / anti-home invasion classes – in these classes they are quite honest about how to use a gun for defense: “dead men can’t sue you” is an actual candid quote. Action Before Reaction is the other quote. These classes are often taught by police: mine was.

    SPD’s police chief says there’s no other choice than to meet lethal force with lethal force.
    M26 or X26 tasers have caused 245 deaths.

    Daniel Ray, a resident of the complex, said he had talked to the three men about half an hour before Murphy was shot. “They were totally lucid and cooperative, not belligerent and not swaying,” Ray said.
    Concerned, Ray and his brother approached.
    Ray said Murphy and his friends were “sort of embarrassed — like kids,” when Ray pointed out that their actions could be dangerous.
    Ray said he believed Murphy “was kind of re-enacting a New Year’s celebration, when it was very common to shoot rifles into the air.”
    When he last saw Murphy, Ray said, the young man was holding the gun “safely, with one hand on the barrel and one hand on the stock, slightly pointed up.”
    Ray was at his computer in his hallway, directly above the basement stairwell, when he heard officers identify themselves and order Murphy to drop the weapon.
    He then heard shots.
    “It seemed to happen super, super fast,” Ray said.

  15. Gun play, sorry to say but simple. you don’t play with guns. On a stage or event where it is know to be used, but not a alley or just out walking around.

    I have carried a gun for 40 years and never tried to shoot out a knee cap. A 4″ target, or a torso, 16″ X 16″ Training says to take the shot that stops the action. A rifle can shot a round that can go threw a few walls and kill people in other homes. There was no safe place with this rifle being displayed. Look a box of anmo, deadly in 5 miles! Also, no one can tell if a blank round is loaded into the rifle or not. The cops did what they are charged with doing in this case, protect the lives of the public. Mr. Murphy, used poor judgement, if only for a moment and he paid the highest price for that mistake. I’m sorry for his loss, he may have learned a lot about war and been able to help prevent some if his talent had only been put to good use.

  16. I was drawn to this story because I too collect WWII memorabelia and at first thought this guy was a loony nazi lover as the press is making it sound. But I was quick to find a cached version of his myspace page via google and read it. He was just like me into the facination eith the history of it all but by no means a nazi lover. It sounded from his myspace page that he was depressed.
    Depression + alcohol could have led to “suicide by cop”. One ironic answer to a poll question on his myspace page was “soon” to the question “How do you want to die?”
    While I didn’t know him, it is clear if you read his myspace, he was the gentle man his friends are trying to tell the world. Sad and tragic event.

  17. Uh, if a dude is walking down my street with an apparently loaded rifle and bayonet and won’t drop his weapon after repeated requests by the police I am NOT on his side… Its unfortunate but the police are just doing their job. There are enough nutjobs out there, and the way I see it if guns are going to be legal for weirdos to own, they should see it as a serious responsibility.

  18. VERY credible kiRO TV interviw with a sad yong guy neighbor who heard the cops repeated tell him to drop the gun, over and over.

    end of speculation

    the kid was stoned and drunk, maybe special New Years stone. Too bad.

    Cops win this one.

    Friends would should have never let him play with his old but dangerous rifle. Live ammo in the house, wow, that is not cool.

    For years I had an antique shotgun for show, chap at a yard sale, no shells at all. It got swiped in a house break in, guns always do get taken.

    Sad, we all can learn from this. NEVER play with guns, NEVER no do exactly what cops ask, NEVER.

    Silly friends need a shout back from others.

  19. as a jewboy, this clueless fuck and clueless fucks like him, glorify the murdering and suffering of over 6 million Jews, not to mention, gypsies, gays, communists, and lefty’s (like most of you). Fuck him! And fuck all of those Nazi memorabilia whores (who glorify Hitler’s “golden” years). They are just Neo-Nazis disguised with high-brow intentions.

    Now, pass the fucking lox and bagels!

    I’ve said my peace!

    L’Chaim

  20. So…

    Where were his “friends?”

    Why did they not accompany him outdoors to help?

    – tell the cops “it’s only blanks”

    – encourage Miles to drop the weapon??

    Some “friends.”

    They are just as much to blame for this tragedy.

  21. Expecting the cops to precision-shoot someone in the kneecaps when a realistic weapon is being pointed at them is crazy. Non-lethal means definitely have a place, but not when someone has a potentially live weapon in a crowded area and is not responding to commands. The problem with being under the influence is that it makes it very difficult for either cops or bystanders to feel confident in reading the intentions of someone, hence tragic incidents like this.

  22. Another Darwin award. I don’t think much of Chief Gil ever since the Mardi Gras riots, but he is so correct in this case. This kid was practically begging for it, and his parents were certainly not helping. I don’t think any college town has a pro-rifle attitude, but considering what happened at Virginia Tech . . . Good god, what bad judgement. It’s hard to believe there is someone that stupid, that would fire off a lethal weapon for kicks in a crowded urban neighborhood, then actually level it at police instead of dropping it immediately.

  23. Mr. Murphy wasn’t at a firing range, he was in an alley way.
    In this context, he appeared very dangerous to both the public and the police.
    It’s terrible that his lack of discretion or non-cognizance of the foolishness of his actions lead to his own death.

  24. as a jewboy, this clueless fuck and clueless fucks like him, glorify the murdering and suffering of over 6 million Jews, not to mention, gypsies, gays, communists, and lefty’s (like most of you). Fuck him! And fuck all of those Nazi memorabilia whores (who glorify Hitler’s “golden” years). They are just Neo-Nazis disguised with high-brow intentions. Now, pass the fucking lox and bagels! I’ve said my peace! L’Chaim

    Actually, I am one of those collectors and find Hitler and his atrocities unspeakably twisted…However if you are Jewish, it would seem to me that you would want the world to remember the reality that DID happen. I am in no way a supporter of Hitler’s views or murderous ways, in fact, I devote much of my own money and spare time so that the world will never forget WWII. don’t judge a person because of things they collect. You are the one who is narrow minded and cannot understand that collecting WWII memorabilia and glorifying Hitler are two different things. I understand the police shooting him, I too own a K98 Mauser and it is hanging on the wall with the bayonet. If I ever pointed it at police, I would expect to be shot.

    Like I said earlier, it’s a tragic incident for all involved

    my website is http://WWW.ww2remembered.com

  25. To quote Danny Glover in Leathal Weapon:

    “You know you can wound them. Just aim for the leg, then we can talk to them.”

    Let this be a lesson to all you kids out there. Don’t fuck w/ the Po-lease! They’re often uneducated and itchin’ to cap a fool. That way they can sit around, purse their lips and say, “I shot a man once.”

    You fuckin’ cops are NOT Clint Eastwood. Grow a fuckin brain!!!

  26. The problem with non-lethal defenses is that they don’t always work. In fact tasers have to get into your skin to work, so if he’s wearing a heavy coat it wouldn’t have worked.
    Tear gas? The guy is standing 20 feet from them and you want them to go get tear gas and throw it at him? Are you really that stupid?

    The general attitude seems to be that police should never shoot unless someone shots first. Is that really a reasonable standard, let the perp get off a shot before firing?

  27. It’s really strange for people to be arguing as if it is some immutable law of physics that if you don’t drop your gun, then you die!
    There is an alternative here. The cops try to reason with him as they would a hostage taker or someone trying to kill himself. Of course, the alternative would work only if we didn’t vest the police with military powers and live such a life of fear.

  28. Shoot out his kneecaps? Are you being serious? Try firing a pistol some time and hitting a stationary object that size from thirty feet away. If you can do it more than one time in five tries, you’re a step above most cops. Meanwhile, quit watching movies until you learn to filter out a little B.S. People don’t really shoot out tires on moving vehicles while they steer with the other hand.

  29. for those who wanted this kid’s kneecaps shot, tazers, used, or teargas fired, remember that when a gun is pointed at you, it is but a fraction of a second before you (the police guy) is dead if the perp wants it that way. They cannot fiddle with alternatives to bullets in such a confrontation, nor can they shoot a kneecap because 1) that doesn’t end the threat and 2) the aim for centermass because sharp shooting and fine motor skills go out the window with your life is on the line.

  30. note: Insanity NOT a psychological term accepted by professionals in the field; it’s strictly legal and found only in courtrooms.

    How about instead of pointing fingers, throwing around labels like “stupid” and “insane”, etc. we give this kid a bit of dignity? This twenty two year old is dead, fault can be found on both sides, and it’s incredibly sad. You most likely weren’t there, you don’t know the truth. Let’s move attention away from juicy situational details out of context and get on with it.

  31. why believe every word the police say? They broke the window out of my car and blamed it on a ‘suspect’, then I watched them chase a ‘suspect’ with dogs in Discovery Park for two hours, which turned out to be a coyote. They lie, cheat, and steal, and assume the worst about everyone. And who deosn’t know that shooting guns on New Years is a common tradition. The cops said in the paper that they thought that he had hostages. Really? Why??!!!! bullshit.
    Nice smear by the press with that neo-nazi story. I hope that cop is proud, now maybe he can go find his nuts and stop shooting everything thing that goes boo. Seattle has always been a gun town, the cops and the mayor need to read some damn history books themselves already

  32. The Seattle police are incompetent and abusive. I witnessed an arrest on Capitol Hill a year ago where I tried to give an arrestee my name and phone number as a witness, and they began shoving me and threatening to arrest me. They are a danger. The people they arrrested had done nothing wrong, they were parked in a private parking lot and had beer in their car, and somehow 10-12 armed police arrived and chose to arrest them, claiming they were minors in possession. The Seattle police have killed way too many innocent poeple in the past few years, particularly minorities. Kerlikowki should go, as should Greg Nickels, for that and many other reasons.

  33. I got no great love for the police. We know that half of them come from the military and are imbued with a know-it-all attitude seldom matched by their actual intelligence. That said, I’ve seen many chill Seattle police, especially compared with the yokel County goons. I wore some military regalia when I was this age, and I guess I fired CO2 pistols at birds when I was 12. I also researched war, but it more or less scared me away from firearms. Anybody who takes a military hobby to the point of putting a bayonet on a rifle and actually acquiring blanks to shoot is on the road to gun nutdom and we all know where that can lead. Ironic that many cops are also gun-nuts. The fact is that rifle bullet could’ve killed anyone, including innocents, and if it had, then the police would’ve been faulted. Blanks? Please.

    That said, its nonsense that they couldn’t blow his arm off, and why is it that EVERYONE who gets shot by the police dies? and why is it that NOONE ever gets prosecuted in these cases, including the bellevue assclown who shot someone for taking out their wallet? Some cops are nuts. But they do occasionally get killed by some quickdraw, but you would think so called PROFESSIONALS could tell the difference. However, drunk and not putting down your WAR weapon is definitely a bonehead manoever. Cops prob dont see someone brandishing that kind of weapon everyday, and I bet you that bayonet was sharp and shiny…

    Killing white college boys is a definite no-no, though, coppas.

  34. You have to cut the cops some slack here. They met an apparent lethal threat with a lethal response. No time for second thoughts or coddling. Early front-runner for 2009 Darwin Award for worst judgment in the world. Very sad, it sounds like Miles was a pretty decent guy.

  35. You have to cut the cops some slack here. They met an apparent lethal threat with a lethal response. Early front-runner for 2009 Darwin Award for worst judgment in the world. I also wonder why his dad gave him the subject weapon back after the cops confiscated it last year. Very sad, it sounds like this guy was a decent person and should have known better.

  36. The kid took all Nazi patches off of his garb. He was down with the history but didn’t want to be associated with the Nazis. He was super nice and harmless. In general, the SPD is horrible and there is something to say about a person who wants to be an officer in the first place. The story I’ve been getting is that the police told Miles to drop the weapon and in the process of him doing so, shot the hell out of him. Being told that there were blanks in the rifle, doesn’t mean that the police shouldn’t be aware, but what it does mean is that they should be careful in handling the situation in a way that gets them brandished bad guys. Sounds like the amount of talking was minimal and questions weren’t even asked. It seems so amateur and thoughtless.

  37. Miles was a good guy and a good friend. He was most definitly not a neo nazi. Whoever “angry jew boy” is, you have the right to your bagles and matzo balls and Miles had the right to collect WW2 militaria.
    If you don’t like US law, move to Israel and serve in the Gaza strip where you can surely get your aggressions out.

  38. Remember, cops have families/loved ones to go home to as well as us. Shooting knee caps..ridiculous. You’re trained for body mass targeting ie. torso/chest. This is because in a high stress situation you want to be sure of your effectiveness in hitting the target when required…Not chancing bystanders or missing and giving the perp time to return fire and hit you. It sounds like in this situation, unfortunately, it was required.

    My condolensces to the family/friends of the young man but it didn’t seem he was acting in his best interest of survival. I don’t care if he was wearing a german uniform or was maybe eccentric. It has nothing to do with it as we have the right to wear what we like and be eccentric, but when you’re carrying a firearm that can’t be discerned to be non threatening and the police tell you to drop it or they will fire….

  39. If they train cops to shoot center-mass, then why don’t they train them to shoot at the legs?

    The time it takes you to line-up center mass, is about the same time it takes you to aim at the legs and rip off 8-rounds. It’s actually quicker.

    If you can’t handle the stress, then don’t be a fuckin cop!

    It’s a bullshit pussy argument and lots of innocent people get killed with something shiney and harmless in their hands. And all the cops have to say is, “But I thought it was real.”

  40. I live less than two blocks away…this is an area with a lot of dumb, drunk young college students, and the police should have taken that into consideration. with that said, go huskys! wooo

    Why is it, on 18th and 17th, that the police are never around to prevent any of the stabbings/attacks/crimes that happen all the time, but are always around to meddle in stupid bullcrap like this? I think cops need to worry less about us dumbass kids and more about all the sex offenders and sketchy old people who live around here. for once, i would like to turn on the tv and hear something positive about the uw and my nieghborhood, you know, something other than kids falling out of frat windows and history lovers getting shot by the police.

  41. I’m not sure I understand the point of shooting somebody in the leg when if they have a gun pointed at you they can still shoot you back. And who knows, maybe they’re smart enough to shoot you in the chest. Who are all these citizen sharp shooters in Seattle that complain about how bad and poorly trained our cops are? If we have so many honest, well-intentioned crack shots among our Seattle population, then why don’t we have the best police force in the United States? Point your finger of blame at the cops all you want, but remember that you have three more pointing back at yourself. Childish, but true. For all the complaints I’ve read, I expect to see those who could do better out there actually doing better. It’s our responsibility to make this city a better place. If you believe you can, then it’s your obligation to do so.

  42. This is so sad all the way around. I agree with others, the young man was playing with fire by pointing a gun at cops. Sad for him, sad for the cops.

Comments are closed.