
This week’s Savage Love Letters of the Day: If she didn’t want to fuck him… why did she eat his pizza and sit on his bed? Bisexual girl wonders why available bisexual girls don’t magically appear in her bedroom. This lesbian’s younger sister flipped out when she told her she wanted to be a mom. And this recently divorced straight dude wonders why the women he’s dating think he’s interested in dating them. And, of course, this week’s Savage Love and this week’s Savage Lovecast…
Regarding What’s Up With Her…
Bravo on your response to this guy, but I feel you may have left out two important things that he needed to hear. First, he should know almost that no one plays hard to get and thinking someone is playing hard to get just leads to treating them in ways that make them feel uncomfortable. People should be taken at their word. Also, I think that his approach about first borns and last borns may have been part of his problem. You pointed out that it’s inaccurate, but it is also a line that shows no real interest in getting to know the woman and only distinguishes her for something she can’t control at all—-her birth order. Had he said, “I admire a woman who has a fierce backhand/fights climate change/mixes a great martini/loves rescue cats…or any other characteristic that shows he sincerely thinks she’s singular in some way, she might have liked him. I realize that wasn’t exactly his question, but he’s going to keep getting rejected if he doesn’t notice much about the accomplishments or interests of the women he’s attracted to. I hope you don’t mind my two cents.
And…
Heaven forbid a woman should take an invite for “pizza and hanging out” as an invitation to, um, eat pizza & hang out. 🙄🙄
— CanadianChick (@SkepCdnChick) September 24, 2019
And…
You missed the mark, Dan. She (probably) wasn’t giving him a second chance. She was (probably) assuming he understood and accepted that she wasn’t looking to date anyone, and thought he was looking to just have a friendship with her. Dollars to donuts she sat on his bed because there wasn’t anywhere else to sit or because WUWH made it subtly awkward or inconvenient to sit anywhere else. And she’s (probably) happy to let any future contact go because WUWH can’t comprehend plain English over the sound of his dick.
Regarding CUFFS…
Being an (IMHO) open minded Mom,Grandma and Nurse I read the letter from this mom and your response with curiosity and I would like to add another potential idea. What if her son took up magic? The young man could learn about the magic of restraints in a way that is safe vs. learning about restrains via the BDSM world, which can be rather dark place for a young mind. Illusion and magic and play can often be a very fun and safe way to learn about things one is curious about at a young age without incorporating the sexual part and it would give them a way to have an open dialogue. Thank you for all you do to make the world a better place!
CUFFS was actually the boy’s father. That said, a 12-year-old boy in throws of puberty who’s tying himself up alone in his bedroom naked in the middle of the night… yeah, a powerful association has already been made between bondage and sexual arousal in that kid’s mind. That ship has sailed, that train has left the station, that strap has been buckled. And no one I quoted in that column was suggesting that CUFFS should drop his son off at a munch and introduce him, at age 12, to the organized kink community. Jimmy and Trikoot were simply pointing out that they were basically that kid at age 12—they were tying themselves up in their rooms alone, getting caught, and alarming their parents—and now they’re happy and productive adults with lots of friends. They advised CUFFS not to shame his son and to initiate a necessary, nuanced, and age-appropriate conversation with him about consent and safety and his future. And then, after having that convo, to give the kid the same space and privacy any other young person deserves.
Regarding SISTER…
You missed this one, Dan. What is happening here sounds like an only child’s reaction to the arrival of a younger sibling.
Regarding WTF…
Overall I agreed with your advice here. However, I think even if he is telling the truth that he tells ALL about his divorce on the first couple of dates, that could give the women a false impression. If they are looking for a boyfriend as opposed to something casual, they might think that the guy spilling all his secrets is really into them and so is into at least the notion of seriously dating. I was the woman in a similar situation and I ended up pretty hurt because I figured, if this guy was telling me his life story, well, he must really be into me. But I agree with you overall point: He should tell potential hookups maybe even in the dating app that he is newly divorced and just wants some fun and then reiterate that on dates and keep it light. But also maybe refrain from any deep emotional talk.)
And…
I was ready to pass the same judgement on WTF, the guy fresh off a divorce who’s not ready for a full-fledged relationship. But I think you were harsh. One of the reasons I stick to the poly community is because there’s a lot of assumptions in the monogamous community about what dating has to be. Obviously, you’re right, Dan: WTF should be clear from date one that he’s not ready for a commitment. But date three is a little early to start pushing for anything serious. Yet that’s the conversation he’s getting again and again. So while he should definitely put in his dating profile that he’s not currently available for an LTR rather than burying it in the fine print, with all the respect and admiration in the world, Dan, I call bullshit on your calling bullshit.
Remember CORNER? The woman whose husband asked her to dump her girlfriend after he knocked up his girlfriend because obviously non-monogamy was the problem and not going bare in violation of the rules of their open marriage? She sent an update…
Not sure how often you get updates but I wanted to let you know I really appreciated your insight and advice. I kindly (but firmly) took a stand and shared your letter with my husband. At first he argued, but then he relented and agreed that you were right. He admitted that he wanted to have SOMETHING to blame the baby on other than himself. We agreed to stay together and I prepared myself for the motherhood that I was not expecting. Then I caught him cheating on me with someone new. TWICE. And, yes, I say cheating because it’s possible to cheat in a non-monogamous relationship if you ignore all rules and blatantly lie to your partner’s face. (Surprise, surprise—sounds like what he did with baby mama!) He’s ditching me and baby AND baby mama and moving across the country to continue carrying on with his new fling. I divorced him and I’ve never been more relieved. I know I still have a lot to work through with my therapist, but it is like this huge weight of lies and betrayal has been lifted off of my shoulders. My girlfriend is being incredibly supportive and I am cautiously but excitedly looking forward to my better, queerer future. Thanks again! — CORNER
Regarding a recent call…
The caller on Savage Lovecast Episode #674 who is a demisexual polyamorous woman with a partner that is already married yet gets extremely unhappy when she dates other people really resonated with me. I was in a VERY similar situation. I am both polyamorous and demisexual and I met an amazing woman I connected with incredibly well… but she wanted two partners who focused primarily on her and only hooked up on occasion with other people, which isn’t something that works well for a demisexual person. We toughed it out for nearly four years… four amazing, wonderful, difficult years. I wish we had pulled the ripcord a year earlier because then we could have probably ended things on better terms. (I really wish we were still friends.) To the caller I’d say this: If you want a lot time with this particular partner you can expect of LOTS of opportunities for growth but very few opportunities to date other people. But that fundamental incompatibility is going to eventually cause enough pressure that you probably won’t be able to stay together. And if you’d like to remain friends afterwards, keep that in mind with your timing on leaving. Good luck and ENJOY your future relationships—and your current one, however long you stay!
Okay, we’re going to leave it there. Have a great weekend, everybody, and we’ll see you back here on Monday!
Impeach the motherfucker already! Get your ITMFA buttons, t-shirts, hats and lapel pins and coffee mugs at www.ITMFA.org!
Tickets to HUMP 2019 are on sale now! Get them here!
